Top
Best
New

Posted by jonathanberger 10/23/2024

Don't use "click here" for link text(www.dont-click-here.com)
114 points | 62 commentspage 3
citrin_ru 10/23/2024|
> But people won't know where to click? It's not 1995.

In 199x it was easier to tell were to click on a web site - hyperlinks were underlined and usually blue. On many modern sites links are de-emphasized; different sites using very different styles doesn't make it easier.

matthewfelgate 10/23/2024||
Missing a great source of humour to have the Hacker News headline link "click here"
desbo 10/23/2024||
Good advice! A rule of thumb I use is that the sentence should make sense if it was read outside of a browser, which results in roughly the same thing.
fsckboy 10/23/2024|
but if the sentence makes sense outside of the browser where there is no place to click, why should the sentence read the same inside the browser where there is a place to click?

your (collective) POV doesn't need to be explained to me, I get it, it's a fun little intellectual puzzle to write a sentence which works both ways and magically the user intuits that clicking is the thing to do, but none of that says the other way is wrong. People choose to do it the other way because it makes sense to them. Who are you to say "no, it doesn't make sense to you"

high_na_euv 10/23/2024||
Idk why, but I prefer click here version
CPLX 10/23/2024||
I dunno, seems pretty clear to me and it’s a super common approach.

Is this science or just kind of a style question?

pphysch 10/23/2024|
It's hard science as far as accessibility goes. A screen reader user wastes a lot of time if they have to differentiate what 10 different "click here" links mean.
fsckboy 10/23/2024||
i'm sure if you published the hard science here, all sorts of holes could be poked in it. this idea that deciphering what links are clickable wastes time is nonsense and probably brought to us by primitive AIs that are measuring how many ads per second they can get the multitudes to click on.

people who make their own pages invariable "click here" and there's absolutely nothing wrong with it.

A few months back a proud father posted his daughter's first website that she made herself and it was all "click here" and not a single person either told her off or complained about the waste of time.

pphysch 10/23/2024||
Maybe you don't understand what accessibility is? It's not a vibes-based term like UX, there are actually laws that enforce proper accessibility. If you run a big American website that isn't accessible, you could get sued under the ADA.

https://www.w3.org/WAI/fundamentals/accessibility-intro/

fsckboy 10/24/2024||
>Maybe you don't understand what accessibility is?

and you think "click here" disrupts accessibility, and the elimination of "click here" enhances it? poppycock.

Maybe you don't understand what accessibility is.

mcdonje 10/23/2024||
Nice. Anyone have a list of these single issue PSA static sites?
realjohng 10/24/2024||
But using old 90s ux is so satisfying
lightamulet 10/23/2024||
> To review or adjust your AutoPay settings, click here.

> You can review or adjust your AutoPay settings at any time.

I honestly find the latter more confusing. It reads like documentation, so I'm primed to think that the link will take me to a documentation page about autopay settings rather than to my personal account settings. The former is very clear that it is prompting me to take an account action if I desire.