Top
Best
New

Posted by NN88 10/25/2024

Elon Musk's Conversations with Vladimir Putin(www.wsj.com)
91 points | 49 comments
breadwinner 10/25/2024|
Whoever, owing allegiance to the United States, levies war against them or adheres to their enemies, giving them aid and comfort within the United States or elsewhere, is guilty of treason. [1]

To "adhere" means to support or be loyal to. In this context, it refers to someone aligning themselves with the enemies of the U.S., either by joining them or providing help and resources, such as intelligence, weapons, or logistical support.

[1] https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?edition=prelim&path=%2Fp...

Caius-Cosades 10/25/2024||
Hypothetically speaking, would supporting an entity that attacked an US Navy ship, directly resulting in death of US navy servicemen, constitute as such?
ttyprintk 10/28/2024||
Treason requires allegiance to the United States. Seditious conspiracy is more often used. For example, Jan 6 revolutionaries might have denounced the United States thinking that it would get them off a treason charge, only to discover that denunciation is a conspiracy to commit sedition.
lawn 10/25/2024|||
Sounds like Trump would match this description too with his relationship with Putin, how he sent Covid machines to him instead of the American people, how he's promised to withdraw all support to Ukraine and cripple NATO.

Essentially he wants to give Putin everything he asks for.

ttyprintk 10/28/2024||
He’s very protected because less than 2/3 of the Senate voted to convict his impeachable offenses. The reality of Presidential treason depends on his/her reputation among our betters in the Senate.
belter 10/25/2024|||
"...Following the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Musk floated a controversial proposal on Twitter in October 2022, arguing that Ukraine should permanently cede occupied territories (e.g. Crimea) to Russia, and that Ukraine should drop its bid to join NATO..." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Views_of_Elon_Musk

"Russia’s Putin praises Elon Musk as an ‘outstanding person’ and ‘talented businessman’" - https://www.cnbc.com/2023/09/12/russias-vladimir-putin-prais...

breadwinner 10/25/2024||
But more importantly, Elon Musk ordered Starlink to be turned off during Ukraine offensive: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/sep/07/elon-musk...
belter 10/25/2024|||
At least Peter Thiel smartened up...

"Billionaire FBI informant Peter Thiel dished about two Kremlin invites to private Putin meetings" - https://www.businessinsider.nl/billionaire-fbi-informant-pet...

inemesitaffia 10/26/2024|||
Retracted in linked article.
moosedman 10/25/2024||
[flagged]
baybal2 10/25/2024||
[dead]
MilnerRoute 10/25/2024||
That puts this story in a new light.

"In October 2023, Musk shared a meme to his millions of followers" that according to leaked documents obtained by a number of European media outlets "was put together by none other than the Social Design Agency" -- a Moscow-based group accused by the U.S. of orchestrating a "persistent foreign malign influence campaign" on behalf of the Kremlin.

https://futurism.com/the-byte/elon-musk-shared-putin-propaga...

libertine 10/25/2024||
I think the most obvious thing has been the volume of Russian propaganda bots that flooded Twitter since Elon acquired it.

We're talking about accounts posing as US citizens, for example, spreading disinformation.

It was like a backdoor was opened for this sort of thing to flow unchecked.

lawn 10/25/2024||
Musk financing the purchase of Twitter using Russian oligarchs is an even bigger proof.
blooalien 10/25/2024|||
Yeah, and Russia "mysteriously" getting more and more "illegal" StarLink terminals / access... Can't Musk cut off their service (since they're sanctioned and supposedly "illegally" using the service / equipment)?
inemesitaffia 10/25/2024||
[flagged]
libertine 10/26/2024||
It's quite mysterious how an internet service provider isn't aware of their devices being used in an active warzone at the hands of war criminals and doesn't seem to care that much to see if their devices are violating sanctions or not.

It's almost like you're saying that Starlink is a risk to national and international security because any terrorist group can use it unchecked.

Except when Putin requested him not to deploy Starlink on Taiwan, and looks like Elon complied: https://www.taiwannews.com.tw/news/4938264

If it's Russia using them on the battlefield, "oh anyone can use it it's a retail product"... if it's Taiwan "well it's complicated"...

So maybe you're right, Starlink should become heavily regulated moving forward.

I'm all for the law taking action on these matters. If there's corruption at play, let it come to light.

inemesitaffia 10/26/2024||
You're being ridiculous. The equipment is being used in Ukraine, not Russia and devices don't violate sanctions. People and Organizations do.

There's a Pentagon working group responsible for dealing with the proliferation issue in Ukraine and the Pentagon claims SpaceX is proactive and fully cooperative.

Starlink isn't operative in the areas of Ukraine subject to sanctions and SpaceX has no agreement with any Russian entity to supply them with equipment. They don't accept Russian payments or deliver to Russia

Any terrorist group can use any similar product. You can go online and buy similar products. Did you somehow think Starlink was the first company with SATCOM or phased arrays? I've noted the Taliban leadership has a preference for iPhones and Kim Jung Un drives a BMW.

The Taliban also used SATCOM on drones before Starlink existed.

Taiwan doesn't want Starlink. When they are ready to deal they'll get it. Like many countries and territories have.

Read that article you linked and stop with jumping to conclusions on headlines. You'll get the insights you need. A hint is SpaceX doesn't do joint ventures.

Starlink is already heavily regulated by multiple regulators

inemesitaffia 10/25/2024|||
[flagged]
Zigurd 10/25/2024|||
8VC is a Russian-run firm and an investor in Twitter.
inemesitaffia 10/26/2024||
[flagged]
lawn 10/25/2024|||
They were recently forced to release their investors and yes there's Russian money there. It's just an internet search or two away.
belter 10/25/2024|||
There is no such thing as Russian money...Only Kremlin money...
inemesitaffia 10/26/2024||
[flagged]
inemesitaffia 10/26/2024|||
[flagged]
dzhiurgis 10/25/2024||
> shared a meme

You can stop reading here

luuurker 10/25/2024||
Why would you stop reading there? Because the content in question is an image with text instead of a video or a short article?
aspenmayer 10/25/2024||
https://archive.is/CsaUx
moosedman 10/25/2024||
Treason season started early.
schiffern 10/25/2024||
Under US law, "treason" means either 1) trying to overthrow the government or 2) providing "aid and comfort" to enemies in war. The last time I checked, the US has not declared war with Russia.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treason_laws_in_the_United_Sta...

dekhn 10/25/2024|||
I think the Logan act is probably more apt? It came up a year ago when this was originally reported https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-08-21/musk-told...
inemesitaffia 10/25/2024||
[flagged]
JojoFatsani 10/25/2024||||
War or not, he is aiding and comforting hostile nations.
dzhiurgis 10/25/2024||
Allegedly.

Are you actually unaware he is getting contracts from DOD?

Zigurd 10/25/2024||||
Has anyone litigated whether a war needs to be declared to be a war? Not treating war as a technicality is one reason judges exist.
ttyprintk 10/28/2024||
It’s irrational to demand that. Treason can obviously preclude war. In practice, seditious conspiracy charges are far more common. There was a slave revolt in the 1800s after which charges of treason didn’t stick because resisting slavery is not war against the nation.
ttyprintk 10/28/2024||||
Many treason cases do not depend on Congress declaring war:

Slave rebellions

Puerto-Rican separatists

American citizens implicated in terrorism

The Congress has never even come close to declaring war in any of these circumstances.

moosedman 10/25/2024||||
We're well on our way towards war, but also I did add the word early.
aguaviva 10/25/2024|||
No one said anything about US law specifically (which wouldn't apply to Musk anyway in this regard), or any kind of law.

One can also read it as: "moral treason", betrayal, etc. Not for talking with the guy, per se. But at the moment, if anyone is talking with Putin, it should be for one purpose only: to end the war -- and with that explicit framework in mind. Not business as usual of any kind.

And we shouldn't be expected to believe that they talked about “space as well as current and future technologies" in any case.

Zigurd 10/25/2024|||
There is a reason treason is both prominent is US law: it's in the constitution, and it is hard to convict because the definition is very narrow and requires specific evidence. The men at the center of our revolution were labelled traitors by the British.

Though Elon is the kind of overachiever to possibly surmount a high bar, FARA might be a better bet.

schiffern 10/25/2024|||
On the contrary, in this very comment section posters have already called for Musk to be put on trial and possibly executed for treason. That doesn't sound very metaphorical...
aguaviva 10/25/2024|||
I see one such comment, but either way: I meant of course "no one" not posting the type of comment you'd be likely to ignore anyway.
JumpCrisscross 10/25/2024|||
Musk is speaking to people who facilitated attacks on U.S. warships. He should not have a security clearance if this is true. If that means him giving up control at SpaceX, so be it.
inemesitaffia 10/25/2024||
[flagged]
JumpCrisscross 10/25/2024||
> you're reading this because the contacts were reported

No? No evidence that’s the Journal’s source. And we don’t know when what was reported.

> article claims it's all good

Where?

inemesitaffia 10/26/2024||
The article claims the intelligence agencies see nothing to take action over. One thing will be a lack of reporting of contacts
BoredPositron 10/25/2024||
Speed running being Henry Ford any %.
amai 10/25/2024||
"Putin has no common topics to discuss with Scholz now — Kremlin"

https://tass.com/politics/1850993

That was the answer when the German chancellor was thinking about talking to Putin.

So it seems Musk has common topics to talk about with Putin.

MilnerRoute 10/25/2024||
Non-paywalled link

https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/elon-musk-s-secret...

breadwinner 10/25/2024||
The correct title is Elon Musk's Secret Conversations With Vladimir Putin.

Omitting the word "Secret" makes it seem like the conversations were innocuous. Keep in mind that Musk has a security clearance that allows him access to certain classified information. If he is having secret conversations with Putin while possessing classified information that's a problem.

inemesitaffia 10/25/2024|
[flagged]
karp773 10/25/2024|
Looks like Putin, at 72, still enjoys working with high profile agents personally. What a dedication to the craft.
More comments...