Top
Best
New

Posted by thepuppet33r 10/28/2024

Apple put the Magic Mouse's charging port on the bottom again(www.theverge.com)
5 points | 8 comments
not_your_vase 10/28/2024|
I will go ahead and ask another question: why does it need built in battery?

In the past 15-ish years since I have been using wireless mices, I have had only 1 that used up the battery in less than 4 months (incidentally I'm using it now, $4 garbage) - everything else was tagging along without a hitch for about a year, without turning them off. And when the battery starts to die, they just start blinking like a week ahead... I think mouse is one thing where replaceable batteries make a lot of sense still.

jfengel 10/29/2024||
Apple puts the charging port on the bottom because they want to make the upper surface as smooth as possible.

They certainly wouldn't tolerate anything as bulky as a battery door on the upper surface. And designing a battery door for the bottom, which also wouldn't interfere with the smooth motion of the mouse... it's probably something Apple engineers could pull off, but it would take a lot of work.

Combined with the other advantages -- less waste, the fact that charge ports are ubiquitous, fewer moving parts -- it's no surprise that Apple, at least, would prefer a built-in battery.

As for everybody else, I dunno. It may literally just not have occurred to them that some people would prefer it.

thepuppet33r 10/28/2024||
Replaceable and externally rechargeable batteries were my go-to for wireless mice. Replace the batteries with charged ones, and put the old ones on the charger.
thepuppet33r 10/28/2024||
I've never been an Apple user, so I haven't dealt with this from the consumer side, but this still makes sense to me.

Constantly moving around and tugging on the charging port seems like asking for a port replacement in a year. Is there a reason people who want to have their mouse plugged in while it's charging don't just use a wired mouse? (Not being sarcastic, genuinely curious.)

tjr 10/28/2024|
The main issue I run into with this is, if I neglect to charge it, and I go to use the computer and the mouse is dead. So then I need to plug it in for a bit, and can't use it until it is charged.

But that really hasn't happened to me much. In any event, a good reason to keep a wired mouse in hand too just in case.

thepuppet33r 10/28/2024||
Does it not warn you of low battery? I would think with them being one ecosystem, it could both flash a light on the mouse and warn you on the desktop.
tjr 10/28/2024||
In my experience, I don't see any desktop warning until the battery is very low indeed, such that it might be too late for me to do anything about it. Probably depends on exactly when it runs out, and if you happen to be actively using the computer at just the right time.

There may be some way to make the current battery levels display more obvious than the default; I've not looked into it much.

_chu1 10/28/2024||
Call me old fashioned but I'm fine with a few AAA batteries.