Top
Best
New

Posted by Hooke 4/1/2025

How Silica Gel Took Over the World(www.scopeofwork.net)
231 points | 174 commentspage 2
Uzmanali 4/1/2025|
As a kid, I imagined silica gel was a special treat. It seemed like the ultimate ‘DO NOT EAT’ dare. I put one in my mouth, waiting for superpowers or disaster.

Turns out, it just tasted like disappointment and regret. 10/10 would not recommend, but at least I lived to tell the tale!

FridayoLeary 4/1/2025||
Why does it have the words DON'T EAT printed on every single package? you don't usually come across such warnings on other products.
netsharc 4/1/2025||
Probably because they look like candy, and they're packaged with food a lot?

Even if not packaged with food, these sachects left on the table while unboxing, e.g. a pair of shoes, might entice kids... And it's just easier to print "DO NOT EAT" rather than have separate production lines for "for shoes" and "for food".

Although, from the description, it seems they're perfectly safe (because they're inert) to eat...

mmmlinux 4/1/2025|||
I realized this week for the first time exactly why. there was one in my instant ramen along with its other seasoning packets. If not paying attention you could easily be having your noodles with added desiccant flavor.
stavros 4/2/2025||
Yep, my mother in law did.
Ekaros 4/2/2025|||
Also used with food stuff. So just producing one SKU with "DO NOT EAT" saves money and doesn't really hurt in other use.
timerol 4/1/2025|||
Your body likes having water inside of it, and doesn't like having glass shards inside of it
celticninja 4/1/2025|||
Actually they are quite safe to eat.

https://www.theguardian.com/notesandqueries/query/0,,-186193...

rapjr9 4/5/2025|||
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silica_gel

"Silica gel is irritating to the respiratory tract and may cause irritation of the digestive tract. Dust from the beads may cause irritation to the skin and eyes, so precautions should be taken."

Also from the same page:

"Silica gel, also referred to as silicon dioxide or synthetic amorphous silica (SAS), is listed by the FDA in the United States as generally recognized as safe (GRAS), meaning it can be added to food products without needing approval. Silica is allowed to be added to food in the US at up to 2% as permitted under 21 CFR 172.480. In the EU, it can be in up to 5% concentrations. In 2018, a re-evaluation by the EFSA Panel on Food Additives and Nutrient Sources added to Food found no indications of toxicity even at the highest estimates of exposure level."

"Listed uses include: anticaking agent, defoaming agent, stabilizer, adsorbent, carrier, conditioning agent, chill proofing agent, filter aid, emulsifying agent, viscosity control agent, and anti-settling agent. Silica can be found commonly in foods including baked goods, spices and herbs, dairy products, cocoa products, and more."

Irritation is not toxicity? I guess not, but it seems like irritation should be also be considered when adding it to food. Long term irritation can be a health issue.

marcosdumay 4/1/2025||||
In small quantities. As somebody already pointed, your body likes to keep its water inside it, it also doesn't like when stuff carries large quantities of unmixed digestive fluids from one part of your body to another.

They are probably quite harmful if large pieces get eaten in non-small quantities. Or powder in large quantities that are not previously mixed with a liquid. But I don't know of anybody that tested that.

genewitch 4/2/2025|||
You can also ingest up to one cup of gasoline.
celticninja 4/2/2025||
You can ingest a litre of boiling oil.
genewitch 4/2/2025||
well, i hoped i implied "without major injury". or so i've heard. I don't particularly like the flavor so i have avoided drinking gasoline thus far.
lovecg 4/1/2025|||
With millions and millions of those things around I’d guess quite a few get ingested accidentally and we don’t hear of them causing problems. It must be pretty safe (well as safe as eating a small amount of sand is).
celticninja 4/1/2025||
https://www.theguardian.com/notesandqueries/query/0,,-186193...
AdamH12113 4/1/2025|||
The packets look like the little salt packets that come with fast food, and the stuff inside looks kind of like salt.
giraffe_lady 4/1/2025|||
I'm pretty sure it's just following the rules of the strictest food packaging laws among the places they expect them to end up. In some jurisdictions non-food that is directly inside a package along with food needs to be labeled that way. So they just do em all like that.
wildzzz 4/1/2025|||
It's a choking hazard that is sometimes included in food packaging so it's just to cover the manufacturer since they don't really know what products it may end up in. Silica gel is non-toxic although maybe could cause some issues if you deliberately ate a huge quantity of it.
madcaptenor 4/1/2025||
Before I had kids I wondered this. But it's really telling you to make sure your kids don't eat it.
peterarmstrong 4/2/2025||
"That single gram of silica gel could have an internal surface area of eight hundred square meters—the size of almost two basketball courts."

This reads like something from The Three Body Problem :)

dkbrk 4/2/2025||
CNC Kitchen put out a great video on the practical use of silica gel. I especially found his exploration of different methods of drying to be of interest.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6tHInlFfMcM

amiga386 4/1/2025||
https://onegianthand.com/post/188730414621/silica-gel
dm03514 4/3/2025||
“That single gram of silica gel could have an internal surface area of eight hundred square meters—the size of almost two basketball courts.“

Can someone help explain this? I’m having a hard time wrapping my head around this. The tiny packet has this much surface area due to how much space exists within the balls???

AngryData 4/3/2025|
Yes, think of it like crumpling up tissue paper into a tiny little ball. Lots of surface area, but it can be packed into a really small size.
benwikler 4/1/2025||
Can't see this headline without thinking of my favorite cartoon of all time https://www.reddit.com/r/me_irl/comments/sqap29/me_irl/
benwikler 4/1/2025|
Ah, seeing that (apparently like-minded amiga386) came here to post the same thing: https://onegianthand.com/post/188730414621/silica-gel
jas39 4/1/2025||
This is sold as crystal cat litter. Very useful to put a sock in the car, the boat or the check-in luggage.
yetihehe 4/2/2025|
Careful with check-in luggage. Apparently it might be mistaken for crystal meth [1].

[1] https://www.huffpost.com/entry/man-jailed-in-bust-of-the-yea...

jas39 4/3/2025||
Yes, I imagine in Singapore: - Is this chrystal meth, lah? - No, it's cat litter. - You stoopid, that is even worse!
tim333 4/2/2025||
archive link

https://web.archive.org/web/20250401195714/https://www.scope...

zzbn00 4/2/2025|
I reuse ones I find in consumer goods by putting them into a jar, together with open superglue bottle(s), and putting the jar into fridge. Not a scientific study, but it does seem to keep the glue for longer then just fridge.
Cthulhu_ 4/2/2025|
Isn't it also because the jar is closed that the superglue keeps for longer? A fridge also dehydrates the air (condenses on the back wall in most cases).
zzbn00 4/2/2025||
Maybe that would be enough. But the belt-and-braces approach of superglue with silica gel bags in a closed jar, in a fridge, seems to work well and has meant the superglue is still usable when I end up needing it....
More comments...