Top
Best
New

Posted by edent 4/13/2025

My imaginary children aren't using your streaming service(shkspr.mobi)
87 points | 123 commentspage 3
jstanley 4/13/2025|
Yeah, totally.

Has anyone else noticed how every streaming service has an "Audio Description" mode?

My imaginary deaf people aren't using your streaming service! I don't want to be reminded of deafness!

refactor_master 4/13/2025||
Is this mandated by law in certain countries? I’ve never seen this.
Vilian 4/14/2025|
My impression it's the us-american weird mix of "think about the kids" and "purism" culture, its fine to give your 12y a gun, but got forbidden it hear a swear word
amazingamazing 4/13/2025||
For Netflix I deleted mine by clicking the pencil and then remove.
danielktdoranie 4/13/2025||
this is a case of “well if it isn't the consequences of my own actions coming back to haunt me”. People like the article's author (and probably the article's author) have been petitioning the government and big tech companies for years asking for more censorship to protect them from big mean hurty words and now they wonder why the internet is a nanny state.
anal_reactor 4/13/2025||
> What's the solution?

rutracker.org

Thank you for coming to my TED talk.

cruzcampo 4/13/2025||
Set up Stremio with Torrentio.

You'll have a UX that's nicer than most commercial services, you'll have all the content you've ever wanted and you won't be feeding predatory capitalist services with your hard-earned cash.

annieghazali_1 4/15/2025||
it's like everyone who can afford something needs to have kids as the next logical step.
nkrisc 4/13/2025||
> The world doesn't revolve around children.

I mean, it kind of does. There is no (human) world without kids.

Every adult who can’t stand children was once a child and will be cared for by the annoying children of today when they’re old and infirm. Not by their own kids, of course, because they don’t have any, but by other people’s kids. So, you’re welcome, I guess. Sorry you had to see things for kids.

croes 4/13/2025||
What if you have friends visiting with children?

No need to set up a special account, it’s already there.

freetonik 4/13/2025||
It could be in some settings menu two clicks away from the main screen.

By the same logic you may have Greek friends visiting some time, so for that reason the welcome screen should always provide an option to switch to Greek content. No need to set up a special account, it’s already there.

croes 4/13/2025|||
There is a difference if a Greek watches an English show and a child watches an adult show.
graemep 4/13/2025|||
yes, because those are equally common occurrences!
theandrewbailey 4/13/2025||
> What if you have friends visiting with children?

As a general rule, don't let other people's kids near your TV's controls. Your friends will appreciate it, and if they don't, a kids account on Netflix won't help.

croes 4/13/2025||
I mean you can let them watch a show without setting up a profile first.

It’s unlikely the kids would choose the correct profile in the first place.

ungreased0675 4/13/2025|
I find this a strange thing to be annoyed by, strange to the point of novelty.

Perhaps the kids mode needs to be easily accessible and prominent, because it might need to be used by kids? Maybe it’s good design to have it available on the very first screen.

It’s also distasteful to borrow trauma from others to justify personal preferences. Don’t speak for people who have experienced extreme tragedy as a way of reinforcing an argument. It’s weird.

globalnode 4/13/2025||
Hes just asking for an opt out since its not important to him and hes giving an example of what he thinks might be more supporting evidence for why its important to have options :)
snmx999 4/13/2025|||
Imagine that instead of a forced "Children" account your Netflix would show an account "Thomas" (or any other name which is not yours or your family members') you cannot get rid of. Would that not annoy you one bit? And if not, you cannot emphasize with people who are annoyed by that?
klodolph 4/13/2025||
“Children” -> Easy to understand the benefit. ~40% of households have children. Some households which do not have children will have children visiting at times. People taking care of children have an obvious and clear interest in wanting to provide entertainment at an appropriate age level.

“Thomas” -> ??? Who came up with this idea? This is an awful idea. It doesn’t make any sense.

We can empathize with people, but ultimately, we don’t have to agree with their complaints. If you have 300 million customers, there’s no one set of UI choices that annoys nobody. The current UI seems to annoy a very small number of people and, in turn, benefits a very large number of people. Needs of the many, and whatnot. I could equally be annoyed by wheelchair ramps. They’re an annoyance to me, but I recognize that they’re very useful to others.

oezi 4/13/2025|||
I would argue that the whole Netflix profile system is rather broken.

As my kids are growing up, the kids mode makes less and less sense. We would like to watch family friendly movies but not stuff for very small children.

Using your own profile for this makes the recommendations become out of whack quickly.

watwut 4/13/2025|||
Then watch family friendly movies from the kids profile. That being said, we watch family things from adult account and recommendation are not really out of whack. It is jus that family friendly stuff appears in them.
valiant55 4/13/2025||
The Disney+ kids account doesn't have Lion King (animated) the last time I checked and I've run into similar issues on Netflix.
mingus88 4/13/2025|||
Create a profile and only watch family movies on it
jmye 4/13/2025||
> I find this a strange thing to be annoyed by, strange to the point of novelty.

Do you find all personalization configuration “strange to the point of novelty”?

Your second paragraph is irrelevant - all of those things could be true, but have absolutely nothing to do with it being a perpetual, unremovable item on the screen. I think this was clearly addressed in the article, so it seems odd to try to relitigate it while adding absolutely nothing to the discussion.