Top
Best
New

Posted by angadh 6/26/2025

Starcloud can’t put a data centre in space at $8.2M in one Starship(angadh.com)
199 points | 349 commentspage 4
hughes 6/27/2025|
Who's asking for datacenters in space?
aleph_minus_one 6/27/2025|
> Who's asking for datacenters in space?

At https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44397026 I speculate that in particular militaries might be interested.

PaywallBuster 6/27/2025||
good use case for bitcoin mining?

- lots of cheap power - deploy 100s of ASICs, let each of them fail as they go

tenuousemphasis 6/27/2025|
No. Too much heat to dissipate. Plus there's no benefit to mining in space.
varelse 6/26/2025||
[dead]
fsh 6/26/2025||
[flagged]
SirFatty 6/26/2025||
"...dumbest possible idea.."

It's a crowded field, you have to do something to stand out!

wlesieutre 6/26/2025||
Solar roadways!
MarkusQ 6/26/2025||
Recently had a conversation of space based solar power pros and cons screech to a halt when someone said "Well what about space based geothermal?"
Nevermark 6/27/2025|||
What's the issue? If we can beam power down, we can beam it up!

More realistically, just drop a thermally conductive cable down to low solar orbit. Absolutely unlimited.

meepmorp 6/27/2025||||
I guess from a certain perspective, all our sources of geothermal energy are already located in space
Metacelsus 6/26/2025|||
maybe on Io :)
ricardobeat 6/27/2025|
The launch costs in the article look quite off from the outset.

A Falcon Heavy launch is already under $100M, and in the $1400/kg range; Starship’s main purpose is to massively reduce launch costs, so $1000/kg is not optimistic at all and would be a failure. Their current target is $250/kg eventually once full reusability is in place.

Still far from the dream of $30/kg but not that far.

The original “white paper” [1] also does acknowledge that a separate launch is needed for the solar panels and radiators at a 1:1 ratio to the server launches, which is ignored here. I think the author leaned in a bit too much on their deep research AI assistant output.

[1] https://starcloudinc.github.io/wp.pdf

angadh 6/27/2025|
please read Table 1.
ricardobeat 6/30/2025||
What about it? They estimate an unrealistic $5M launch cost, but the point is that it is likely to be ~$25M and not the $100M+ this article suggests.