Top
Best
New

Posted by doener 6/29/2025

YouTube No Translation(addons.mozilla.org)
469 points | 332 commentspage 2
oc1 7/1/2025|
So Google assumes that its user only speaks one language and needs translation for everything else. Is this the educational standard in America?
kalleboo 7/1/2025||
What's crazy is the US actually does have a decent proportion of multilingual speakers thanks to its history of immigration (a quick search reveals 20% of American residents are bilingual). Even Google staff should be a pretty multicultural bunch of people as they recruit globally.
simongray 7/1/2025||
I mean... 20% is not really a lot. It's probably a lot closer to 100% in most countries of the world.
mslansn 7/1/2025|||
Is it? That doesn’t sound right.
pjc50 7/1/2025|||
Depends. English first language countries remain mostly monolingual. But the rest divides into:

- educated people are expected to learn English in school and end up consuming English media anyway (where you'd expect >50% multilingual, but not everyone)

- country has many official languages (many people are multilingual, but not necessarily in English; e.g. India, Indonesia, possibly China)

- country has literacy problems (not so many left now, maybe in sub-Saharan Africa)

- proud monoglots of a language that isn't English: Japan, France (but even here a lot of people consume English media anyway)

Aachen 7/2/2025||
> - country has many official languages

Belgium has 3 languages but my guess would be that each region speaks English better. The French, pardon, Walloniers scarcely speak Dutch and while the Flemish area speaks better French it's usually not great (unsure whether most people would qualify as fluent). Afaik Flanders has mandatory French in school but Wallonia doesn't need to take Dutch, even though 60% of the population is Dutch-speaking. The German-speaking region is mostly forgotten about and they either integrate with the French-speaking part or work in Germany with Belgium as a cheap place to live

The Netherlands has Papiamento as the native language of most people in a part of the country. They're overseas but they vote for the same government and live by the same law. I literally didn't know this until a few years ago (I'm 30). I assume they don't want independence due to things like getting defence and other benefits from a much larger economy (and we're right to feel the need to pay such repairs) but man, this feels really 1800s slave trade levels of wrong. Not a soul speaks Papiamento in the european Netherlands, it's not even an option in school — let alone compulsory!

In Luxembourg it's hit or miss whether someone speaks the national language (Luxembourgish), French (an administrative language), or German (another administrative language). Many will speak at least two, but many also only one (French in particular)

Very eurocentric perhaps but that's my experience with countries that have more than one official language: nearly nobody bothers learning the other if there is no direct necessity

matsemann 7/1/2025||||
90 % of Norwegians speak English according to a quick search I just did. 89 % in Sweden.
mslansn 7/1/2025||
That’s not “most countries”.
simongray 7/1/2025|||
Maybe you can argue why it's not most countries? It seems obvious to me that it is, but I also come from a country where everyone is bilingual.

Many former European colonies are mostly bilingual, e.g. Africa is highly multilingual out of necessity. Much of Europe itself is also mostly bilingual. If you want to communicate outside your own little region and your native language isn't a lingua franca, you need to be bilingual in this world.

The main holdouts when it comes to bilingualism are former imperial powers who managed to both kill domestic language diversity (e.g. France, UK, Russia) while also spreading their national language as a lingua Franca. Another group of holdouts are settler colonies such as the US, which didn't have a dominant native population after the arrival of Europeans.

But even if e.g. Russia itself isn't super bilingual, the rest of the former Soviet Union certainly is, since that is just the reality if you live in a small and/or formerly colonised country.

Aachen 7/2/2025|||
Contribute more data points of your own then, or even just one. Maybe eventually we'll get to know whether it's most or not rather than dismissing someone who's helping
joseda-hg 7/1/2025|||
I believe the more damning thing is, there are more multilingual english speakers than monoglots, merely by virtue of ESL being more common than Native English
dagw 7/1/2025||
Is this the educational standard in America?

Even if it is, Google is itself is very international and multilingual, including the literal head of YouTube. They obviously know what the world looks like, and decided to do this anyway.

jacek 7/1/2025||
It is incredible how many addons I need to make YouTube usable. Here's my list (all Firefox):

- uBlock Origin - ad block

- SponsorBlock - to skip in video ads (some other nice features like highlights too)

- YouTube Row Fixer - for the tiles to adjust to the window

- Return YouTube Dislike - self explanatory

- YouTube No Translation - thanks for the suggestion!

Xaphiosis 7/1/2025||
BlockTube is a must - can block specific channels from showing up, videos with "Journaling" and "changed my life", hide videos watched over 50%, etc.

Enhancer for Youtube is also super useful: disable shorts entirely, autoplay next only on playlists, tweak number of videos per row, default playback speed, default theater mode, etc.

As another commenter said, Youtube is one of those sites that really requires multiple plugins to be useful :/

jacek 7/1/2025||
Thank you! I'll use it.
addandsubtract 7/1/2025|||
Also DeArrow to replace clickbait titles and thumbnails with more relevant ones.
gfdujdufituj 7/1/2025||
I use BlockTube. If channels advertise that their content is trash via clickbait thumbnails and video titles, I can get rid of them once and for all.
weberer 7/1/2025|||
Also "Enhancer for Youtube" which allows

- Hiding Reels

- Setting a default playback speed

blendaddict 7/6/2025||
I can't watch without enhancer anymore. I always have my mousewheel on the speed control to regulate the pacing myself, because most people can't pace. Also, when I am looking for a specific second long clip in an hour long video, it is very helpful that I can set the speed to something like 8x.
sebtron 7/1/2025||
To you know any extension to get more than 4 videos per screenful on my 27" monitor?
Narishma 7/1/2025|||
I just use this ublock origin filter:

    www.youtube.com##ytd-rich-item-renderer:style(--ytd-rich-grid-items-per-row: 6)
jacek 7/1/2025|||
YouTube Row Fixer
oakstendheim 7/1/2025||
This is such a Google thing. I'm browsing from a German IP address, have my language set to English only and my region set to the US. This is still not enough for Google, and Youtube by extension, to not show me German search results. It is honestly incredibly frustrating. Same goes for the trending page on YT. This appears to only be based on your IP address.
oc1 7/1/2025||
Reddit is the worst offender. I really wonder what goes through the mind of the management clerks at these companies.
userbinator 7/1/2025||
I really wonder what goes through the mind of the management clerks at these companies.

"More $$$!!1"

0wis 7/1/2025||
Yeah, short term. Because power users that are used to switch between languages using internet slang do not like half baked polished translation in their IP-location language. So they leave. Remain mainly low quality users who couldn’t or didn’t wanted to switch between languages. A more powerful forever September again.
felindev 7/1/2025|||
While it is annoying, reddit at lest gives you option to see original text.
mailund 7/1/2025|||
ah yes, and the auto translation on reddit broke a very useful trick I used all the time

- need information about something in general -> search in English - need information about something specific for my home country (laws, local events, local shops, etc) -> search in my native language

now, I get weird auto translated content informing me about laws that are only applicable in the US and recommended products that are not even available in my home country.

lawik 7/1/2025||
Right. This was incredibly useful.
StefanBatory 7/1/2025|||
Even worse - if I search something in my native language, it's because I want to see things relevant to my country! I don't care about experiences of someone in USA or Brasil if I look up for something in Polish :<
petargyurov 7/1/2025||
When I first encountered this on Reddit I was really confused... They were (are?) translating even the text INSIDE an image. Can't believe how expensive that must've been across the entire frontpage.

But hey, another way to shoehorn AI into being "useful".

kcaseg 7/1/2025||
I wish there were a YouTube app with this + no reels, I have YouTube premium, I am already paying, stop forcing stuff on me.
DecentShoes 7/1/2025|
Revanced lets you remove reels
dizhn 7/1/2025||
It's embarrassing that something like this is needed. For some reason Youtube has always been weird about languages. They have language and location information, yet they won't let you search by language, will return other languages when you search, won't search by location, won't default to another language in videos and now they are force translating video titles/descriptions and force dubbing videos. Nobody asked for any of this. They have been asked plenty of times to provide options related to languages yet they have not implemented any of it. Super super weird. When did we start to accept such bullshit even in paid products?
doener 7/1/2025||
The same plugin for Chrome: https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/youtube-no-translat...
felindev 7/1/2025||
This change has really been annoying me and as far as I tested, no extension worked. Quick look through network activity and it confirmed that it was done server side, no original titles were supplied anywhere. Only option was display language and titles were pre-translated to it. Just give me option to see original content, that is why I'm here
RJIb8RBYxzAMX9u 7/1/2025|
I've just installed this extension, and confirmed that -- at least for now -- it works. The translated titles will be flashed first, then replaced by the original titles.
gethly 7/1/2025||
I've been using "YouTube Anti Translate" for a year or two. I think the developer figured out all the bugs and quirks by now and it's pretty good.
timbit42 7/1/2025|
This add-on seems to only fix video titles. The add-on this post refers to fixes audio translation.
Alifatisk 7/1/2025|
What is it with Youtube and adding things no one asked for? I especially dislike when they make it default, so I have to figure out how to disable new features. My browser language is EN, my preferred language in YT settings is EN, I live in a European country, yet, videos get translated into Arabic? What the hell Youtube. Why can't I just visit your platform, look up videos I am interested in and watch it.

The old Youtube was way nicer, it felt snappy, easy to interact with and didn't have all that bloat we have today. I also miss when the ads where a popup at the bottom of the video instead of having to watch double ad segment every 5 minute.

More comments...