Top
Best
New

Posted by marc__1 3 days ago

Immunotherapy drug clinical trial results: half of tumors shrink or disappear(www.rockefeller.edu)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S153561082...
475 points | 92 comments
Spooky23 3 days ago|
I’m both sad and incredibly happy to read this. I lost my wife recently to a recurring metastatic melanoma. She was treated at MSK by an amazing team.

It was a terrifying diagnosis and literally would have been a guaranteed death sentence in 2017. In 2023, she had a very real chance of pulling through due to immunotherapy. Unfortunately some complications led to the worst outcome and we lost an amazing woman.

I remember that my wife said once that the everything she had on that journey was on the shoulders of those before. So maybe in some small way she helped with the research and a future mother, sister, wife, husband, son, dad will have hope where there was none.

PieTime 3 days ago||
I lost my wife before they developed sickle cell treatments recently. Knowing the pain she went through everyday, makes me grateful that children soon will not have to know that pain. Thank you for sharing your story.
bamboozled 3 days ago|||
I remember that my wife said once that the everything she had on that journey was on the shoulders of those before.

Very true and profound, I'm sorry for you loss, what an inspirational thing to say.

qmmmur 3 days ago|||
That this message passes on is testament to our loved ones spirit carrying on in ours and others hearts and minds
thinkingtoilet 3 days ago|||
She absolutely did. Sorry for your loss.
Avalaxy 3 days ago|||
I'm so sorry for your loss :(
Lalabadie 3 days ago|||
Oh man, sorry for your loss. Sounds like she was lucky to have you as well.
idiotsecant 3 days ago|||
That sucks, man. I wish I had something I could say that made a difference.
JamesSwift 3 days ago|||
So sorry to hear that. Im not sure the loss gets easier but Im going to start sharing your hope in better future outcomes.
nickandbro 3 days ago|||
She did man
behnamoh 3 days ago|||
I got goosebumps reading your sad story. So sorry, and I hope you recover from this.
znpy 3 days ago|||
I'm so sorry for your loss.
rvz 3 days ago|||
Very sorry for your loss.
spicyusername 3 days ago|||
It absolutely did!
mzs 3 days ago|||
my condolences
seidleroni 3 days ago|||
Having lost my mother to melanoma over 20 years ago, it is very encouraging to see the progress that has been made against this terrible disease. Very sorry for your loss.
yahoozoo 3 days ago|||
Damn. RIP to your wife. Hope you’re doing ok.
zlw241 3 days ago||
I’m so sorry for your loss and thank you for sharing your wife’s story. As a husband, father, and son starting treatment for melanoma tomorrow, your words mean a lot. It’s humbling to think of how much today’s progress is owed to courage of those who came before
liamwire 3 days ago|||
Sincerely, I’ll be thinking of you tomorrow. Best wishes with your treatment, give it hell.
Spooky23 3 days ago||||
Be strong, be well, and always be comfortable asking for help. Best of luck to you.
darkwater 3 days ago|||
Hope everything will go well! Stay strong!
psnosignaluk 3 days ago||
I am a walking, talking, laughing, smiling result of the effects of immunotherapy. I was on Pembrolizumab on a six week cycle across eighteen months, administered at Charing Cross Hospital in London, after diagnosis in early 2022. It effectively dealt with my lung and brain cancer, with minimal side effects. This year, I returned to the gym and am sucking up every last opportunity to extract as much fun as I can with my wife. I am amongst the luckiest of souls, and feel deeply sorry for everyone who is losing to or has lost someone to cancer.
cogman10 2 days ago||
That's my wife's current medication. We just had our 6 month CT and her largest tumor was reduced to half it's original size.

10 years ago, this wasn't an option. 5 or so years ago it wasn't a treatment for her cancer (metastatic renal).

I'm so thankful this treatment is available and that the genetic testing lined up.

DoesntMatter22 3 days ago||
That's amazing! Good for you man.
loganwedwards 3 days ago||
My sister was part of an immunotherapy trial years back. She was given weeks to live; the trial gave us years. Tailored medicine is truly a marvel.
adamsiem 3 days ago||
My mother had immunotherapy treatment last year for lung cancer. It caused a lethal arrhythmia within 24 hours that they could not treat. She was dead by the end of that day. The cardiologist said this was a known side effect (he muttered 5% as she lay there). It's still not a perfect solution.
ajross 3 days ago|||
To be fair, not knowing your mother's age or cancer, 5% is right around the mortality rate for major surgery in the elderly too. Things are just dangerous as you approach end of life and there are no good solutions for anything.
hinkley 3 days ago||||
What are the odds of chemo sucking every moment of joy out of your life and then you die anyway.

I think I could deal with 20:1 odds if I had a clean before and after. Tell everyone you love them, hope to see them soon, then take your 95% chance of having an extra few years.

frodo8sam 3 days ago||
That's pretty much what happens when you get a stemcell transplant. Luckily there is steady improvement in the survival rate. This is a very old therapy by now of course. But let's hope the various form of immuno therapy take the same trajectory, getting a little better every year.
hinkley 2 days ago||
Hank Green just did a follow-up about a question about “who has the most DNA”, where he back pedaled heavily on his previous attempt to answer.

I learned, as he had, that sometimes bone marrow transplants don’t take and one option is to administer another, or several, which could make you much more chimeric than the average stem cell recipient. But I don’t understand how the marrows don’t end up fighting each other in a death match. Is that a special property of marrow?

John23832 3 days ago|||
I'm really sorry for you loss (and the way it happened).

That said, we all know that these are not perfect solutions. They save some more, they don't save all.

sharkweek 3 days ago||
Friend was told he had 12 months to live maybe 20 years ago (some rare form of melanoma).

Him and his wife committed hard to tons of clinical trials and is still alive to this day and has no indication he’ll be dying anytime soon.

He’s the very first patient on a number of studies, which he thinks is pretty cool.

neuronexmachina 3 days ago||
Direct study link: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S153561082...

> Fc-optimized CD40 agonistic antibody elicits tertiary lymphoid structure formation and systemic antitumor immunity in metastatic cancer

> CD40 agonism enhances antitumor immunity but is limited by systemic toxicity and poor efficacy. Here, we present a phase 1 study (NCT04059588) of intratumoral (i.t.) 2141-V11, an Fc-engineered anti-CD40 agonistic antibody with enhanced binding to the inhibitory receptor FcγRIIB. Among 12 metastatic cancer patients, 2141-V11 was well tolerated without dose-limiting toxicities. Six patients experienced tumor reduction, including two complete responses in melanoma and breast cancer. 2141-V11 induced regression in injected and non-injected lesions, correlating with systemic CD8+ T cell activation and mature tertiary lymphoid structures (TLSs) in complete responders. In CD40/FcγRs humanized mice bearing orthotopic tumors, i.t. 2141-V11 promoted de novo TLS formation, facilitating i.t. CD8+ T cell effector responses independent of lymph node priming. The resulting local immune responses by 2141-V11 mediated abscopal antitumor effects and sustained immune memory. These findings demonstrate that i.t. 2141-V11 is safe and promotes immune-privileged tumor microenvironments that promote systemic and durable antitumor immunity.

MostlyFragile 3 days ago||
As a young person with Multiple Myeloma, these articles give me hope but I know a cure is a long way off.

I feel like I'm at the stage where Ill be one of the last people to die from it or I'll be one of the first to be cured of it.

I'm watching companies like Deepmind with great interest. It's my hope that these AI tools speeds up a cure before it's too late.

choilive 3 days ago||
While promising, be VERY skeptical about efficacy claims of these early stage research drugs.

Tons of drugs in the pipeline that goes after these promising receptor targets. PD-1/PD-L1, CD47, CD40 (as mentioned in the article) etc. Keytruda (PD-1) is an incredible success both clinically and commercially, but there are many many other drugs buried in the clinical trial cemetery that initially showed promising results.

Medicine is really hard.

sarchertech 3 days ago||
> but there are many many other drugs buried in the clinical trial cemetery that initially showed promising results

Mot many that showed such dramatic results across different types of cancer with very low toxicity.

Even if it turns out this drug kills 10% of patients outright, it would still be useful.

toomuchtodo 3 days ago||
Can anyone comment on near term success of the prostate cancer trial? Asking for a friend.

> The findings have sparked a number of other clinical trials that the Ravetch lab is currently collaborating on with researchers at Memorial Sloan Kettering and Duke University. Now in either phase 1 or phase 2 study, the trials are investigating 2141-V11’s effect on specific cancers, including bladder cancer, prostate cancer, and glioblastoma—all aggressive and hard to treat. Collectively, nearly 200 people are enrolled in the studies.

xiphmont 3 days ago||
Waiting for the Derek Lowe post, but... if this is legit, it's a 'holy flipping s**' moment. That kind of success in Phase I human trials is incredibly rare.
OsrsNeedsf2P 3 days ago||
Had to look this up, seems like Derek Lowe is a reputable blogger[0] in this space

[0] https://www.science.org/blogs/pipeline

poszlem 3 days ago||
Look at the photos in the study that show the disappearing melanoma. Incredible.
GeekyBear 3 days ago||
The fact that they were only testing a tiny group of patients (to make sure the treatment would not do more harm than good) with such astonishing remissions for two different very aggressive cancer types warms my heart.
hinkley 3 days ago|
With an autoimmune solution I worry that you have to test on a vast number of people to determine the actual safety. And maybe even to come up with a way to determine if a candidate is in an at risk group.

And then god forbid it turns out to only work for a couple of major ethnic groups and then is starts to look like eugenics if you don’t immediately plow all the money into creating versions that work properly for everyone else.

nick__m 3 days ago|
Low toxicity, effective against many cancers, it's almost unbelievable.

If clinical success holds in phase 2 and 3, this is the next Keytruda.

More comments...