Top
Best
New

Posted by geox 9/11/2025

From burner phones to decks of cards: NYC teens adjusting to the smartphone ban(gothamist.com)
284 points | 232 commentspage 3
unglaublich 9/11/2025|
Lovely news.
tootie 9/11/2025||
[flagged]
spiderice 9/11/2025||
"Louder lunchroom" is a measurable outcome. So is kids playing Poker
lmm 9/12/2025||
Was it measured before and after? Or did they take a couple of anecdotes (from people with a vested interest, at that) as fact?
kelnos 9/11/2025||
The article is full of accounts of positive, measurable outcomes, that are already happening.
tootie 9/11/2025||
Outcomes meaning test scores, behavior, mental health. I have two kids in NYC high schools including at least one of the schools they were canvassing at. They have not observed any changes. My oldest used to use her phone for schoolwork during the day pretty frequently and now she can't, so homework is taking longer.
aaomidi 9/11/2025||
A single school shooting is going to reverse this.
pessimizer 9/11/2025|
Yes, we'll miss getting to listen to recordings of children being murdered while the police fail to go in.
ragnot 9/11/2025||
It's more that parents are afraid of not being in contact with their child when a school shooting happens. It's not some far flung thing in America unfortunately.
ranger_danger 9/11/2025|
What ban where?

Not everyone wants to read an article to even find out the location they are talking about or if this is relevant to them... otherwise what's the point of titles and headlines?

We can write much better post titles than this.

bmacho 9/11/2025||
Original title:

  From burner phones to decks of cards: NYC teens are adjusting to the smartphone ban
rovr138 9/11/2025||
It's in the article.

Come on people, read.

> Schools have rolled out a range of strategies, with most schools either collecting phones at arrival and storing them in lockers or distributing magnetic pouches that have to be locked and unlocked at the beginning and end of the day.

JumpCrisscross 9/11/2025|||
To be fair, the title has been editorialized.

From the guidelines: “…please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize.”

(I’ve flagged. Happy to unflag once title is fixed.)

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

ranger_danger 9/11/2025|||
Yes I understand it's in the article, but that wasn't my point.

People from all over the world read this site and many won't click on articles they aren't sure are relevant to them... why can't we put even the location of the story in the title? Is that too much to ask?

rovr138 9/11/2025||
I don't think the relevant part is where there's a smartphone ban. It's that teens are adjusting to the ban on their phones. That even if they're always on them, they can actually disconnect and adjust to it.
ranger_danger 9/11/2025||
I don't presume to know people's reasons for wanting to read a story or not... I just think we should at least put the applicable location in the title.