Top
Best
New

Posted by jaypatelani 10/26/2025

Let's Help NetBSD Cross the Finish Line Before 2025 Ends(mail-index.netbsd.org)
406 points | 238 commentspage 2
jmmv 10/26/2025|
Donated! I should have done this months ago when I started using NetBSD for an embedded project idea (that has gone nowhere).

But I feel this link illustrates a big problem with NetBSD’s “no hype” approach: I clicked the link you shared and found an email. The email has the donation link at the very end, and it’s not clickable. When I go to the donation page, there is a ton of text before I even get to see an ugly PayPal tiny button or a tiny form to donate via Stripe.

It’s too hard to notice and too hard to do. The project’s homepage does a better job though. But I think it should be made even more prominent if this is critical for the project’s health!

jaypatelani 10/27/2025|
Thanks a lot for donation :)
skullone 10/26/2025||
Donated! Thank you very much, NetBSD was one of my first experiences, on a Pentium 60 with a 504MB hard drive. It made me who I am today, eternally grateful to have learned from such amazing and talented people.
jaypatelani 10/26/2025|
Thanks a lot :)
GeorgeTirebiter 10/26/2025||
I just donated. It's important to keep projects like NetBSD vital, as a monoculture benefits nobody but the monoculturists. I think of it as a way to help ensure Survival of the Species - by diversity.
jaypatelani 10/27/2025|
Thanks a lot :)
jonahx 10/26/2025||
Out of pure curiosity, is all the actual programming work for the foundation provided free of charge by volunteers? And the foundation expenses are mostly legal and administrative?

It wasn't clear to me based on the financials: https://www.netbsd.org/foundation/reports/financial/2023.htm...

Maybe the consulting section includes payments for programming work? Presumably at cheap rates, if so?

fujigawa 10/26/2025|
>Maybe the consulting section includes payments for programming work? Presumably at cheap rates, if so?

Have we reached the point on the timeline where we believe low-level operating system code should be acquired at "cheap rates"? While simultaneously, I assume, believing webshit cloud bollocks still demands top dollar?

jonahx 10/26/2025||
I do not hold that belief, and nothing in my reply implies that I do.

Per the link I included, the total spent on consulting was 17,939.51 USD. So, if they were paying people, the people were working cheaply. But the consulting may have been for non-programming work. Hence my question.

owl_vision 10/26/2025||
an offspring to build your own minimal BSD UNIX system: https://www.smolbsd.org/
olivia-banks 10/26/2025||
Donated!! I run a small cluster of a few nodes I bought for cheap, and I’m experimenting with SSI on them. The kernel is really nice to read and modify.
jaypatelani 10/26/2025|
Thanks a lot:)
jmclnx 10/26/2025||
Such an underfunded project. Even with such low resources they can get a lot done.
motorest 10/26/2025|
It surprised me that a project such as NetBSD only managed to raise ~$10k throughout the year. What's going on with the project?
jmclnx 10/26/2025|||
The last few years or so, its activity seemed to have increased quite a bit, or maybe they are getting more press then they have had in many years :)

FWIW, this is the first time I have ever seen any mention of donations on any major tech WEB site.

atomic_princess 10/26/2025|||
[flagged]
xyproto 10/26/2025||
Does NetBSD really help reduce e-waste any more than Linux already does?
unleaded 10/26/2025||
Maybe not yet but I can see Linux's place as the shitbox saviour start slipping a bit in the next few years. Debian dropping x86, distros getting fatter in general.. I can't really see those trends reversing. Meanwhile NetBSD goes against them.

However it goes, the main issue is one no operating system can solve which is modern life relying on the Web and beefier browsers. Unless you want to rebel against that you're probably better off getting a laptop from the past 10 years for < £100 on eBay.

Imustaskforhelp 10/26/2025|||
Although I agree with beefier browsers, I also want to say that there are browsers like dillo etc. which can be good enough for simple websites and also not everything needs a web browser to be usable

Imagine this, a system which can watch movies, edit texts, create disks, have curl/wget, send and recieve files using piping server (which is a curl thing) , view pdfs, mpv and what not, a desktop manager, file manager etc.

As someone hacking around with the legendary tiny core linux, I am more and more mind blown each day with just how much can happen in 14-21 MB, you can definitely build a mini self hosting rack with just some remastering as tinycore can actually run podman as well (combine this with alpine containers to create a super duper minimalist self hosting things too)

the possibilities are endless. When I ran tiny core linux on my pc and ran nothing else, It took 21 mb in ram for a whole gui with editors and file managers etc. all running in ram so super fast filesystem with a package manager

I personally wanted to build my own operating system to limit myself to the most minimal system so taht I just study and do nothing else, I thought tiny core was it but then I tried to hack around it and there are sooooo many things in 21 mb, makes me appreciate minimalism

dijit 10/26/2025||
> which can watch movies

I have to say, the sheer fucking irony of this statement made me do a double-take.

I might be showing my age a bit, but I'm still remembering when web-browsing was considered a "light" activity (without extensions like Web Java), and watching a video was "very computationally expensive".

I guess some shift happened in the early 2010's where video playback was hardware accelerated more frequently; and complicated javascript started taking off as Google unveiled v8.

malfist 10/26/2025||
As much as the tech bro billionare class salivate over the idea of bringing an "everything app" to the market, we already have those. They're called browsers.
Imustaskforhelp 10/26/2025||
This might be one of the reasons why things like chatgpt (OpenAI) etc. are releasing atlas etc.

This is their attempt of everything app, where the whole internet would be behind the UI of their chatbot and it would go through an LLM before being changed by it and then it would pass to us.

Your single comment explains a lot really and this is something that I agree. Everything App is the browser/internet, combining it with things like wasm, you can even run whole iso files in browser wasm itself (Its fresh on my mind because I shared it to somebody on HN right now but try out copy.sh/v86 [1])

[1]: https://copy.sh/v86/

dijit 10/26/2025|||
How is TLS negotiation and transport on older hardware (with no AES-NI hardware acceleration)?

I remember it used to be expensive as heck to do TLS back in 2014~, so much so that we bought accelerator cards and segmented "secure" servers so that load wouldn't hit the ordinary browsing of our sites...

1vuio0pswjnm7 10/26/2025||
"How is TLS negotiation and transport on older hardware (with no AES-NI hardware acceleration)?"

I use a TLS forward proxy. With today's overpowered hardware, I can even run the proxy on an old "phone" (but I cant run NetBSD^1)

This allows the older computers I own to use plaintext HTTP like the good old days

1. Despite https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T-Mobile_Sidekick

p_ing 10/26/2025|||
The argument for NetBSD is that it runs on almost anything that was ever produced. That isn't the case for Linux, even older x86 is no longer supported in the mainline.
jmmv 10/26/2025||
That may be technically true but…

Linux (the kernel) may have been ported to more machines and architectures than NetBSD’s kernel, yes. But is all the code present in the same source tree or do you have to go find patch sets or unofficial branches?

More importantly: is there a modern distribution that builds an installable system for that platform?

The special thing about NetBSD is that you get the portability out of a single and modern tree for many more platforms than any single Linux distribution offers.

pabs3 10/28/2025|||
The Linux ecosystem is removing support for lots of stuff, especially the distros, but also the kernel.
p_ing 10/26/2025|||
You said the same thing I did with extra steps.
jmmv 10/26/2025||
That’s because… I misread your comment.

In any case, NetBSD is not well known and “why bother because Linux also runs everywhere too” so I thought it was worth explaining.

p_ing 10/27/2025||
Sadly the BSDs are not well known.

I asked a major employer why they're using Linux + Apache for an RP when OpenBSD + HAProxy + CARP is a significantly better option. Crickets.

I want a good laptop for OpenBSD (or FreeBSD, at the least) that isn't 10 years old or weighs 5+ lbs.

kakwa_ 10/26/2025|||
https://technically.kakwalab.ovh/posts/silly-sun-server-intr...

Some architectures are no longer practical with Linux. The kernel might still support it, but distribution support is sketchy.

For a SPARC64 server refurb project, the choices were pretty much OpenBSD or NetBSD in my case.

pabs3 10/28/2025||
Debian still has a sparc64 port (sid only).
xhkkffbf 10/26/2025|||
Some of the Linux distros are getting pretty fat and don't work so well on older hardware. Of course some are lean too. But NetBSD has a goal.
xyproto 10/30/2025||
Lean Linux distros also have goals?
ptrwis 10/26/2025|||
What do you think, there are milions of people or companies running NetBSD on 486 to protect the planet from e-waste? How many times have you replaced your phone with a newer model in the last 10 years?
timeon 10/26/2025||
> How many times have you replaced your phone with a newer model in the last 10 years

Once, after accident.

iberator 10/26/2025|||
yes. It supports like 60 different cpu architecture all back to 1979 VAX 790 INCLUDED.

Its also one of few OSes where 32-bit 386 is still tier 1 release.

All from single code source code tree.

xyproto 10/26/2025||
Does running NetBSD on VAX from 1979 help to reduce e-waste, though?
iberator 10/26/2025||
Yes if you still run it. 0 metal wasted.
atomic_princess 10/26/2025||
[flagged]
rfrey 10/26/2025|||
I think they were talking about physical computers ending up in landfills.

Edit: nvmd, I see this account was created 20 minutes ago and has only low-effort comments attacking BSD. I've never understood how people can develop such negative feelings about technologies.

jamesnorden 10/26/2025|||
That's not what e-waste means.
phendrenad2 10/26/2025||
Big fan of NetBSD. From the perspective of a kernel hacker, I found the NetBSD codebase to be very readable and easy to work with. FreeBSD and OpenBSD, while being more fully-featured and security-minded respectively, had to make compromises in their codebase as a result.
bfkwlfkjf 10/26/2025|
OT what's with the email addresses with percent signs in them?
layer8 10/26/2025||
See http://www.faqs.org/docs/linux_network/x-087-2-mail.address.... (next to last paragraph)
berikv 10/26/2025||
“Then there is the % address operator: user %domainB@domainA is first sent to domainA, which expands the rightmost (in this case, the only) percent sign to an @ sign. The address is now user@domainB, and the mailer happily forwards your message to domainB, which delivers it to user. This type of address is sometimes referred to as “Ye Olde ARPAnet Kludge,” and its use is discouraged“
MontyCarloHall 10/26/2025||
>Ye Olde ARPAnet Kludge

Seems fitting that NetBSD's internal mailing lists still use ossified address syntax from a time before DNS.

andai 10/26/2025||
I would guess it's an anti-spam measure. Although if I'm reading sibling comment right, it is actually a valid email address? (Assuming you have a mail server running on localhost.)
layer8 10/26/2025||
It’s rather the opposite: Spammers used to exploit that mechanism back when it was more widely enabled.
andai 10/27/2025||
I'm not sure I understand. Why would the website use that format then?
layer8 10/27/2025||
The respective mailserver likely checks which domains it is forwarding mails to, e.g. only allowing netbsd.org, or only allowing mails from localhost. In the more distant past, that wasn’t the case, so spammers would send their mails to the domain of such mail servers, who would blindly forward it to whatever domain is encoded after the percent sign in the local part. They’d effectively serve as an open mail relay then.
More comments...