Top
Best
New

Posted by gaws 10/28/2025

Generative AI Image Editing Showdown(genai-showdown.specr.net)
342 points | 77 commentspage 2
seany 10/29/2025|
Is there anything like this comparison for nsfw images? I'm married to a boudoir photographer who sometimes wants to use ai tools for things, and they are all _awfull_ if there is nudity on photos. It's like some sort of neo puritanism has taken over.
tpierce89 10/29/2025|
I also do similar work and have run tests on many models. I have listed a few here with sample images using one prompt with a single run. I know it isn't a comprehensive review like OP, but it's something. My personal preference through experience is epicRealismXL.

https://imgchest.com/p/xny8e23jpyb

seany 10/29/2025||
Thanks for the tip. Need to see how well these work for inpainting
veunes 10/31/2025||
This is so much more useful than synthetic benchmarks. The most important column here isn't pass/fail, it's attempts. In production a model that gets it right in 2 attempts is 10x more valuable than one that needs 20 iterations of prompt engineering. It's a direct measure of cost and predictability.

Seedream 4 won on points, but Gemini seems more steerable and required less fighting on many of the tasks

kgwgk 10/28/2025||
Recent discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45708795
jumploops 10/28/2025|
Nit: the link there was `Text-to-Image` while this is `Image Editing`

Still useful comments, as the models mostly overlap

ineedasername 10/29/2025||
Kontext is very good. Get yourself a 5060 ti 16GB and never have to pay for API calls again for this purpose, at least not when you have the time spare. If you need this sort of editing at the speed of gui-clicking + 10s, then you'll need to pay API tolls, or capex for > 5070/80.
zamadatix 10/29/2025|
You have to REALLY be into AI to do this for generation/API cost reasons (or willing to have this as a hacking project of the month expense). Even ignoring electricity, a 16 GB 5060 Ti is more expensive than 16,000 image generations. Assuming you do one every 15 seconds, that's 240,000 seconds -> more than 2 months of usage at an hour a day of generations.

If you've already got a decent GPU (or were going to get one anyways) then cost isn't really a consideration, it's just that you can already do it. For everyone else, you can probably get by just using things like Google's AI Studio for free.

weberer 10/30/2025|||
>a 16 GB 5060 Ti is more expensive than 16,000 image generations

Sure, but now you get a good gaming GPU that you can write off as a business expense.

ineedasername 10/31/2025||||
16,000? Where are buying your GPU, or API calls? If you don’t want to wait for a bargain then $450 will get you the GPU, and even at that price you’d only be able to buy about 10,000 standard-resolution image gen api calls. Do you do design? Editing? Touch up? You can easily blow through a few hundred api calls an hour: “Turn the stitching green… slightly less saturated… now make the stitches more ragged… a little more… now just slightly less”.

Clearly you’re looking at the task through the eyes of a hobbyist or “of the month” project so the workflow and pace may not be obvious but API budgets spend fast. Just look at the benchmarks in this article to see how many tried some of these changes took- 47, there goes $3 in 3 minutes, or half that time if your quick on the keyboard.

And even then! Well, you’re limited aren’t you? Limited to the Gemini model, or OpenAI, or whoever, and you see the limits of any one model in the article as well. Or you plonk down for a mediocre GPU with some slight VRAM headroom and choose from dozens of models, countless Lora, control nets, and other options, infinitely flexible in painting and outpainting. Ahead of that you’ll need to budget at least a dozen hours to learn local genai tools, comfyui or others. Then, for under a $1 dollar in electricity, you can can queue up a dozen ideas overnight and get 1,000 variations on each of them handed to you in the morning to quickly triage over coffee and email catchup.

It’s not a one size fits all market though, and most professionals are likely finding they want both: A low-cost, high-control, high precision sandbox that isn’t as fast or scalable as the api, and the api for when fast and scalable is what you need.

spookie 10/29/2025|||
GPUs are needed for plenty of reasons. I assume plenty have a decent dGPU, even on laptops.
joomla199 10/29/2025|||
I have a 4080 RTX and Kontext runs great at fp8. I run several other models besides. If you want to get at all good at this, you need tons of throwaway generations and fast iteration and an API quickly becomes pricier than a GPU.
ineedasername 10/31/2025||
Precisely. Even inflated if the inflated 16,000 api calls was accurate for how much the cost of mediocre GPU would get you, that’s not an endless store of api calls. I’m also on a 4080 for lighter loads, and even just writing benchmarks, exploring attention mechanisms, token salience, etc, without image gen being my specific purpose I may trash half a thousand generations from output every few days. More if I count the stuff that never made it that far too.
zamadatix 10/29/2025|||
The point is just having a "decent" dGPU isn't enough. Even at 16 GB you're already quantizing Flux pretty heavily, someone with a 4080 gaming laptop is going to be disappointed trying to work with 12 GB.
lschueller 10/28/2025||
I wonder how much longer those annoying stock photo database will continue. They are great for press photography and such. But stock pics of people in offices for a website are nothing, I would buy a min 3 month subscription for anymore
delichon 10/28/2025|
As generative AI eats away at the high royalty, restrictive license, consent evading, stereotype reinforcing business model of stock photo companies, it will be a challenge to resist the schadenfreude.
CobrastanJorji 10/28/2025||
I'm pretty sure that "replace the homeless man with a park bench" image was a reference to some TV show making a gentrification joke, but I can't put my finger on it. Anyone recall?
vunderba 10/29/2025||
Yeah, I couldn't help myself on that one! It's a reference to the Cypress Creek promotional video from the Simpsons.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=foU9W7AkKSY

pram 10/29/2025||
Simpsons, the Frank Scorpio episode. The advertisement for the company town shows a beggar slowly fading out and being replaced by a mailbox.
dev2roofer 10/29/2025||
Yeah, it’s kinda crazy how fast this stuff leveled up. A year ago we were happy if hands looked normal — now we’re nitpicking shadows and curb textures. Wild times.
wawayanda 10/29/2025|
This is not the point of this post, but is anyone else getting tired of this front end style that Claude creates? I see it on web apps everywhere and (just like with AI writing and images) I get that funny "is this slop?" feeling
meowface 10/29/2025|
Yes, though it might be GPT-5 UI.
More comments...