Posted by SteveHawk27 10/29/2025
I bought the game after they added fences and fishing rods and before the Nether. The nether ruined the game, beds ruined the game, hunger ruined the game, potions, enchantments, villager trading, and hoppers ruined the game, but redstone and minecarts and dungeons didn't ruin the game because those were added before I bought it, see? If you bought it today, you wouldn't think hunger ruined the game, you'd rather think I took away a good feature if I showed you a version without hunger.
But a lot of things Mojang has added, if they had been mods some random developer made, we probably wouldn't have been putting in our modpacks. A new tier of armor, which requires a tedious grind in the nether to get? That's like baby's first mod. Happy ghasts? Pretty fun, and impressive that you can stand on them, but like the morph mod, kinda ridiculous and definitively doesn't belong in every pack. Eventually, if they keep doing it like this, Minecraft will be as ridiculous as the old kitchen sink modpacks.
And for what it's worth, I think I've visited The End once? What makes it a sandbox is that you can play however you want - let The End be your goal, if you'd like, or just mine and build big castles, or mess around in Creative mode. That's the brilliance of it.
In current Minecraft a lot of resources are renewable via villager trading. The best way to get many resources is to enslave some villagers and find a trading loop that nets a profit in emeralds on each cycle, then spend some of that profit on the thing you want. If you want the player to dig up coal to make electricity, they can make a trading hall or a wither skeleton farm instead. If you want the player to dig up iron to expand their factory they'll make an iron golem farm which produces it at a high rate for free. The section of the design space that you wanted to access is blocked off by the mechanics of the base game.
Or maybe it wasn't intentional, but emergent... sort of like, you know, playing in a sandbox?
Villager trading is another new(ish) mechanic I don't partake in. I know others who don't either. I don't think we're playing the game wrong.
And if a mod/pack developer doesn't want players to use vanilla mechanics, they can disable those, as many, many developers do.
You can't just remove the fields for a mob's armour items because all the mods that interact with mobs are checking what armour they have, and you'll get a runtime linking error. Best you can do is remove the code that spawns mobs with random armour so they always spawn without armour. There may still be armoured mobs spawned by mods.
In automation mods there was a concept called "sided inventory" where a machine block presents a different part of its inventory depending on which side of the block you access it from. When hoppers were added to the base game, they copied this exactly, but changed which sides accessed which part of which blocks to make them compatible with hoppers, because hoppers can only take items out of the bottom and put items into the top and sides. This affected all automation mods which, instead of using a more intuitive side mapping, use a mapping that makes sense for hoppers. Also, all other mods that add machine blocks now specify side mappings that make sense for hoppers.
Of course in principle you can rewrite the game and all your mods from scratch to match whatever vision you have, but I hope it's obvious that nobody would actually do that.
Even removing a single block or item is nontrivial. You can't remove the field because you'll get runtime linking errors from mods. You can't make it null. Even mods that don't rely on that item may be checking if a player is using it for some feature (and you'd like that check to always be false). There's a good chance many of the mods you want use it in recipes because it's available. Best you can do is remove the ways to obtain/create the item, and add a bunch of recipe overrides so it's not used in recipes either. If you have the mod that shows you a list of every item in the game, it'll still show up there.
After 15 years of playing, it still feels very much like a wonderful sandbox, which I regularly modify however I want, with very rarely any issues, including some of the exact things you've mentioned.
And thankfully, the modding scene is as vibrant as ever!
Yeah, 1.7.10 is many modders' favorite, I know. If you did stop at 1.7.10, I guess you know about the GTNH people's crazy work in keeping that version running? For a while, you could 1.7.10 with a newer version of Java than the current latest version.
Microsoft logs us out every damn time we close the software, which means my grade schoolers have my (now guessable) MS account password (and I scorch-earthed the account, because this is so dumb I won’t trust or use their crap moving forward).
Has anyone figured out how to pirate the binaries? I’d like to remove the yellow sticky note with the password from my monitor.
You'd still need to log in to update the game (I think), but for your purposes it'd probably work pretty well.