Top
Best
New

Posted by layer8 2 days ago

Denmark reportedly withdraws Chat Control proposal following controversy(therecord.media)
569 points | 228 commentspage 2
ranger_danger 2 days ago|
Why does the government think it is their job to save people from themselves in the first place?
johnisgood 2 days ago|
The weird thing is that even many people (citizens) believe this.
stinkbeetle 2 days ago||
If I was a conspiracy theorist I might think that the ruling class who so desperately want these kinds of powers are intentionally dividing nations and breaking down social cohesion so the populace must turn to the governments for protection. They're hoping to create societies where the people will beg them to scan private messages rather than to demand rights.

Give it another 10 years the way things are going, and I'm sure it will be back.

tavavex 2 days ago||
> Give it another 10 years the way things are going, and I'm sure it will be back.

I'm giving it 10 months or less. The rate at which things are worsening (in most aspects, not just this) seems to be rapidly climbing from my point of view.

jonbiggums22 2 days ago|||
The main purpose is to identify any nascent organization of political opposition to the status quo so it can be destroyed in its infancy with a minimum amount of resources. It will be used to solve some crimes too but solving crimes still involves a lot of manpower (expensive) and if they solved crime people would be less supportive of expanding surveillance powers even further so you don't really want to do a great job at that.
themafia 2 days ago|||
> must turn to the governments for protection.

It's so they can sell you out to corporate interests more effectively. It's a modern day fiefdom.

lysace 2 days ago|||
In practice it's a combination of:

a) wanting to soon expand this scheme to catch criminal gang communication (violent narco-related crime is exploding in e.g. some northern EU countries) [center-right goal]

b) wanting to make people more nervous about what they post online (immigration vs crime etc is a hot topic that many want to cool down). [center-left goal]

I suppose that there might also be some naive idealists that primarily care about the stated goal.

stinkbeetle 2 days ago||
In practice it is entirely about wanting to expand the power of the state and cement its supremacy over the rights of the individual.

Those other things are a means to this end. They would be extremely happy for there to be more crime and more unrest about immigration if it meant they could seize powers like these.

lysace 2 days ago||
> They would be extremely happy for there to be more crime and more unrest about immigration if it meant they could seize powers like these.

What country is this? Sounds really bad.

stinkbeetle 2 days ago||
What country is where the state's primary purpose is to perpetuate the power of the state, and where the ruling class desperately want to take more power and rights from the people? Lots of them. Denmark, for one.
lysace 2 days ago||
It sounds like you are approaching this from a Marxist perspective. Have you tried thinking about this from other perspectives? (Just as an exercise.)
stinkbeetle 2 days ago||
That's not an argument.
lysace 2 days ago||
You're right - it's an observation and an idea.
stinkbeetle 2 days ago||
Yes I am right. And now allow me to observe and suggest: It sounds like you're having a bad day. Why don't you try again tomorrow if you feel better then?
lysace 2 days ago||
Okay, I was trying to be constructive. Have a good night.
HPsquared 2 days ago|||
Deus Ex intro scene has a good line on this... "In the end, they'll beg us to save them".
willmadden 2 days ago||
I don't think sockpuppet, aspiring actor to politician EU governments will be around in 10 years. People are waking up.
ginko 2 days ago||
Did they apologize for proposing it in the first place?
pajamasam 2 days ago|
They’re just withdrawing it “for now” and not making it “mandatory.” They will try to find a different route.
hoppp 2 days ago||
Good. I was tired of it. Denmark is a great place to live but chat control wtf
Weloveall 23 hours ago||
In Denmark our government don't know shit about anything else. One day they say one thing and next day another.
burnerzzzzz 2 days ago||
HN is being affected by the American love of conspiracy once more. In reality:

Danes trust their state - for good reason. But this is obviously taking it too far.

Its not that Peter Hummelgaard is trying to create a spy state. He just doesn’t understand tech.

Simple as that.

BSDobelix 2 days ago||
>Danes trust their state - for good reason

>>Nordic Waste is owned by the family of Torben Østergaard-Nielsen, reported to be the sixth richest person in Denmark. Last week, the Danish Ministry of the Environment issued an injunction against Nordic waste, and yesterday (22 January 2024) the company was declared bankrupt. The company has declared that this ends Nordic Waste’s liabilities.

https://eos.org/thelandslideblog/nordic-waste-1

Blind trust always gets betrayed, and all the Scandinavian countries have closed their eyes for too long; I want Olof Palme back.

>Its not that Peter Hummelgaard is trying to create a spy state. He just doesn’t understand tech.

Oh nooo that poor little guy, cant even think 5 minutes into the future, he's 42 not 80.

ghusto 2 days ago|||
It sounds like they're like the Dutch. The government is trusted because they've been shown to be trustworthy, but they are always accountable. If something dodgy happens, people are quick to point it out and demand action.

So it's not blind trust. I understand why Americans are so mistrusting of their government, it's because they are untrustworthy. The mistake is thinking everywhere in the world is like that.

burnerzzzzz 1 day ago|||
Denmark often copy policies and implementation from the netherlands. Our societies are quite similar.

Learning about what policies work by looking at other countries is of course a foreign concept to American exceptionalists

Yeul 2 days ago||||
It's because both Denmark and the Netherlands have more than 2 political parties.

In the US they basically elect a king who gets all the power for 4 years- including appointing the goddamn Supreme Court!

burnerzzzzz 2 days ago||||
Nordic Waste and Olof Palme seem like quite random unrelated references. Sweden and Denmark are different countries btw.

The public debate in Denmark clearly shows that it’s difficult for non technical people to understand the limits of tech. Regardless of age.

BSDobelix 2 days ago||
>Sweden and Denmark are different countries btw.

I was talking about Scandinavian Country's, most of those Country's are called "high trust societies" often with too much trust in their government.

>debate in Denmark clearly shows that it’s difficult for non technical people to understand the limits of tech

Install a system that reads your private messages is absolutely not a technical thing.

burnerzzzzz 1 day ago||
Hummelgaard and his colleagues have repeatedly demonstrated that they believe a backdoor can be made that would only be used occasionally only by the right authorities. Even some of the opposition seems to believe this.

When discussing politics in foreign countries, consider how much context you are missing. Those of us that live in the country and speak the language have consumed its news for years.

HN discussions about politics in foreign countries are bizarre

BSDobelix 1 day ago||
>Hummelgaard and his colleagues have repeatedly demonstrated that they believe a backdoor can be made that would only be used occasionally only by the right authorities.

That's what every politician would say about restricting privacy, it's for the kids, it's in the right hands, we would never betray your trust.

>HN discussions about politics in foreign countries are bizarre

No really bizarre is your believe that 42yo -->justice<-- minister Hummelgaard is just a naive child who knows nothing about "Internet stuff"

In his own words: "We must break with the totally erroneous perception that it is everyone's civil liberty to communicate on encrypted messaging services"

He absolutely knows what he's talking about.

codingbot3000 2 days ago|||
Olof Palme? The socialist who squeezed tax payers out like lemons, and a bit more?
BSDobelix 2 days ago||
Jup the guy who was probably killed by his own military because talking with the USSR is against Nato strategy [1] funny how history repeats itself [2]

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Secret-War-Against-Sweden-Submarine/d...

[2] https://www.amazon.de/-/en/Provoked-Washington-Started-Catas...

Argonaut998 2 days ago||
If you are so sure about that why wouldn’t they make it a domestic law instead of an EU wide law? I’m not American nor Danish and I certainly do not trust my government. Kind of naive - no one should trust their government in this day and age.

It’s also convenient that Denmark is essentially the US’ eyes and ears in Europe, who even spied on other nations for them.

burnerzzzzz 2 days ago||
Having a largely non corrupt government that enjoys the trust of the general population yields benefits on all levels of society. Its a big part of the reason these countries are the happiest and healthiest.
bobsmooth 2 days ago||
Withdraws it for now.
kragen 2 days ago||
For now. It will return unless we end the careers of the politicians who were grasping for such absolute surveillance powers.
bratwurst3000 2 days ago|
what people dont get about mass surveilance is that big systeme are easy corrupted. for example if I want privat data about peoplw from police or assurance or state office there is a way to get them with money and connections.

So if mass surveilance is implemented it would be missused for personal benefit of whoever has the money and the possibility

More comments...