Top
Best
New

Posted by csmoak 3 days ago

Tell HN: Mechanical Turk is twenty years old today

MTurk was built by two two-pizza teams at AWS over the course of a year and launched on Nov 2, 2005. It took a few days for people to find it and catch on, but then things got busy.

At the time, AWS was about 100 people (when you were on call, you were on call for all of AWS), Amazon had just hit 10,000, S3 was still in private beta, and EC2 was a whitepaper.

What did you create with MTurk and the incredibly patient hard-working workforce behind it?

94 points | 62 commentspage 3
malshe 3 days ago|
I assisted many professors in data collection for their research in the grad school. Later I also collected data for a couple of my papers. mTurk was very popular in the beginning in large part due to its low cost. Then one day they jacked up their commission so much, it was no more attractive to me. Also, the response/task quality went down significantly. My last time using it was in 2018 for a large scale image labeling task. After doing a pilot run, I concluded I was getting garbage. I went to some other vendor and never returned to mTurk after that.
slyall 3 days ago||
Never used it since it was only available in the US. Looks like additional countries were not added till Oct 2016, 11 years after it was first launched[0]

None of the companies I've worked for have used it AFAIK, despite them all using AWS. I think I've mostly ignored it as one of the niche AWS products that isn't relevant.

[0] https://blog.mturk.com/weve-made-it-easier-for-more-requeste...

abhiyerra 3 days ago||
I worked at two crowdsourcing companies built on MTurk. Humanoid and CloudCrowd. Had millions of tasks go through from transcriptions to labeling.
coderintherye 3 days ago||
I remember participating in the workforce early on transcribing really bad audio recordings along with the cheap survey type stuff. It was pretty neat back in the day.
cole-k 3 days ago||
Nothing of actual utility:

https://github.com/cole-k/turksort

dmd 3 days ago||
I used it to have transcribed our 2 kids x 5 years of daycare x 180 days a year worth of extensive wonderful daily reports from daycare.
antaviana 2 days ago||
I loved their old tagline: “Artificial Artificial Intelligence”.
ada1981 3 days ago||
I did a project where I had them write poems and draw pictures about and of robots.

I got about 100 of each.

jonatron 3 days ago||
I was in school and automated some MTurk HITs to make a small amount of money.
BoredPositron 3 days ago|
Tried it once or twice but never was worth the hassle and the feeling of exploiting other people.
More comments...