Top
Best
New

Posted by bilsbie 11/9/2025

Montana becomes first state to enshrine 'right to compute' into law(montananewsroom.com)
541 points | 330 commentspage 3
teucris 11/9/2025|
I’m all for this movement provided it’s actually focusing on the rights of individuals rather than empowering corporations to own and operate massive amounts of computing power unchecked. When I first read the article, I frankly assumed this was meant to limit regulation on AI. From what I’ve read in the law that doesn’t seem to explicitly be the case, but given the organizations involved, I fully expect to see more in that vein.
Sleaker 11/9/2025||
Interesting, has the EFF done a writeup/opinion on this legislation yet? I tend to trust them on breaking things down from the legalese and implications.
kragen 11/10/2025||
Damn right. Keep yer damn laws off my exocortex!
yard2010 11/10/2025||
I love how lawmakers jerk each other doing jack shit at the expense of the public.

This is a long text that actually says nothing.

threecheese 11/9/2025||
Any idea how “citizen” is defined here? Does this apply, like speech (and campaign donations), to corporations?
sandworm101 11/9/2025|
Yes. In written laws "citizen" generally means any person and/or organization subject to the laws of the state. It doesnt mean just living people who can vote.

Many a young law student has pontificated that as non-citizens, visiting tourists have no rights. There is no more loaded a word in US politics, and none more malleable under the law, as "citizen". It means something different in every context.

zkmon 11/9/2025||
I mean, without this law, are the people not allowed to use computing? What exactly is the difference it brings? Does it force government to provide computing to all citizens?
manbart 11/9/2025|
Makes it harder for people to oppose construction of data centers in their back yard
hermannj314 11/10/2025||
Can someone give an example of a law Montana passed or tried to pass that this law now prohibits a future legislature from passing?

I don't like a legislature compelling a future legislature to not have power, isn't that really a state constitutional thing?

This is going to be used to fuck over people, no way this is a good thing.

cat-whisperer 11/10/2025|
its' time for government owned agencies to be more open to integrating intelligent systems. I would prefer if this happens in india too.
More comments...