Top
Best
New

Posted by firexcy 11/12/2025

Homebrew no longer allows bypassing Gatekeeper for unsigned/unnotarized software(github.com)
345 points | 287 commentspage 4
AlexandrB 11/13/2025||
There will be delicious irony when MacOS is locked down to the point that running homebrew is no longer possible.
supportengineer 11/12/2025||
It seems this mostly affects Intel systems.
JohnTHaller 11/12/2025|
Only true because this only works on Intel code. You can't use the typical method to bypass Gatekeeper because Apple removed it for ARM64 code.
saagarjha 11/13/2025||
No, the mechanism is the same.
Aaron2222 11/13/2025||
To clarify, the macOS kernel requires a signature on all Apple Silicon binaries, but this can just be an ad-hoc signature. Ad-hoc signed Apple Silicon applications are treated much the same as unsigned Intel ones.
westondeboer 11/12/2025||
TL;DR

Homebrew is removing --no-quarantine because:

Apple is killing Intel support.

Apple Silicon won’t run unsigned apps anyway.

Homebrew will soon require all apps to pass Gatekeeper.

They don’t want to help users bypass macOS security.

This is basically a security + future-compatibility cleanup.

Aaron2222 11/13/2025|
> Apple Silicon won’t run unsigned apps anyway.

Technically true, but misleading. The macOS kernel won't execute an Apple Silicon binary that doesn't have a signature, but as Apple documents, an ad-hoc signature is enough to meet that requirement. That won't get you past Gatekeeper, but that's no different to how it is with unsigned Intel binaries.

sunaookami 11/13/2025||
I use Nix for my CLI needs but homebrew for GUI programs, anyone know of any good alternative? A lot of casks will be removed, like mktvoolnix-app (the GUI program, not the CLI tool). Also this Mike guy is insufferable.
andrewmcwatters 11/12/2025||
[dead]
theturtle 11/12/2025||
[dead]
miketheman 11/12/2025||
[flagged]
mvdtnz 11/13/2025|
I can run whatever I want on my Windows and Linux machines. I wouldn't put up with this, but I guess some people really feel they need their silly fruit computers.
platevoltage 11/13/2025||
You run something that Windows doesn't like (like an Activator), Windows straight up deletes the application.
15155 11/15/2025||
Try permanently disabling Windows Defender on modern Windows 11 and get back to me.