Top
Best
New

Posted by surprisetalk 12/2/2025

Gundam is just the same as Jane Austen but happens to include giant mech suits(eli.li)
244 points | 188 commentspage 2
rilindo 12/10/2025|
Where is my janpla model kits, then?
0x457 12/10/2025|
Fine china tea sets.
underlipton 12/10/2025||
Jane Austen crossover series based around customizing your china sets.
femiagbabiaka 12/10/2025||
If you are someone for whom this article resonates, you should watch Legend of the Galactic Heroes, the old one, not the new one.
zhivota 12/11/2025||
Now someone tell me the equivalent of P.G. Wodehouse and I'll check it out. Wodehouse feels like the lighthearted successor of Austen, focused more on the comedy and farcical plots, than serious romance. Funny enough, I started reading his stuff on the recommendation of Paul Graham.
underlipton 12/11/2025|
I can't speak to Wodehouse's style, but as far as mecha series that weave comedy into plots that are fairly serious but also genre-aware (and ready and willing to take the piss out of them), in a well-constructed setting, I would look at Martian Successor Nadesico for old-school, Majestic Prince for a newer series.
Onavo 12/10/2025||
The Witch from Mercury is excellent. It's almost like a space opera version of Open AI board drama.
wisty 12/10/2025||
I read somewhere that Code Geass originally didn't have mechs in the script.

Every anime has a production committee who figures out how they pay for it (anime make miney from a wide range of sources) and they told the writers they needed to write mechs in to get the gunpla bucks.

inerte 12/10/2025||
Moonrise Kingdom and Snow White too https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ARoKJ00cEZ8
dluan 12/11/2025||
I thought it was pretty well known that Gundam is a commentary on class and the effects of imperialist wars on normal people. The OG series didn't glorify violence and instead showed a lot of gratuitous civilian deaths, and most of the main characters are the poor-orphan-becoming-a-knight archetype.

Plus Jane Austen at the time was a sharp critique of English nobility and high class, but presenting it in a stylized and popular way.

HelloNurse 12/11/2025||
Weapons and violence in Jane Austen's novels include characters hunting with shotguns and (remotely implied) armed Navy ships.

Nothing comparable to treating a mobile suit like an extension of the body, or killing people, or both at the same time (e.g. the "duel" between Char Aznable and Kycilia Zabi).

ericmcer 12/11/2025||
> "the tragedy isn’t just that war is bad, but that institutional logic and personal desire are fundamentally incompatible"

Pretty good quote from the article and a succinct way to sum up the human dilemma of existing in a society.

ndesaulniers 12/10/2025|
I feel attacked.

Where my Gundam Wing fans at? (there are literally dozens of us...dozens!)

More comments...