Top
Best
New

Posted by oldfuture 2 days ago

Umbrel – Personal Cloud(umbrel.com)
213 points | 120 commentspage 3
popalchemist 2 days ago|
This looks really well done. The software is both well-designed (from UX / UI pov) AND it's OSS AND it's just an SSD / NAS underneath it all, I think this kind of thing is a welcome addition to the market.
ugh123 2 days ago|
The entire UI seems lifted from icloud and osx. I can't even tell the difference
popalchemist 2 days ago||
Personally I'm cool with that. Originality is overrated. Do whatever works.
avazhi 2 days ago||
Ok, and what do I do when these guys go out of business/get bought by Amazon/microsoft/whatever in 3 or 5 years? Like, the game’s up with this cloud stuff, surely. None of it is to be trusted.
esskay 1 day ago||
Why would anyone want this? It's got a fairly tiny drive size for this day and age, not to mention it appears to just be a generic aliexpress N150 box thats been branded and had their software pre-installed.
thedangler 2 days ago||
IF I already have a NAS/mini pc can I just install this stuff and get all the benefits because I don't need the hardware?
jazzyjackson 2 days ago|
Yes looks like they offer the OS for Raspberry pi and "any x86 system"

https://github.com/getumbrel/umbrel

kevinak 2 days ago||
I run an umbrel on an off the shelf mini pc and it’s been great! Very polished and nice experience!
block_dagger 1 day ago||
Picked up an Umbrel server to run Bitcoin Knots node last month. Works extremely well, I highly recommend it for similar applications. Nice web based UI.
krick 1 day ago||
Cool, but honestly I always end up regretting another device that is not just plain "non user-firendly" Linux. First you buy Synology because it's just quick and easy to set-up, and "I'll figure the rest later". But when time comes to figure the rest out, it's just so unreasonably inconvenient. In theory, it is just Linux, and DSM is just for convenience, and there are special packages intended to use Docker and install stuff and all, but there are so many "user-friendly improvements" on top of that, that I get tired even just thinking about all the hoops I have to jump to do something super-simple and end up choosing some another device for all tasks that theoretically would be a good fit for my NAS to perform. The only good thing is hot-swap and automatic volume rebuild, that is super convenient. But, honestly, are these 2 minutes of convenience worth the rest? I don't know.
bigiain 1 day ago||
"run a Bitcoin node" <closes tab>
dJLcnYfsE3 1 day ago|
Eh. If it was released in early days of crypto and was dedicated only for that task and quite cheap - I don't think it would be anything wrong with it. Think of hosting a TOR relay or some kind of WiFi/Mesh network . So it is just 10 years late, no one believes anymore that cryptocurrency will be a real decentralized payment method. The only community left is "the line goes up" people.
dizhn 2 days ago||
Seems to be a hardware + software thing.
EvanAnderson 2 days ago|
Here's a comparison on running it on your own hardware vs. theirs: https://github.com/getumbrel/umbrel/wiki/umbrelOS-on-Umbrel-...
dizhn 1 day ago||
They even have install instructions on a linux vm. Pretty cool. Thanks.
nikolay 2 days ago|
Last time I looked at it it had some craptocurrecy stuff, which lost me as a user.
kevinak 2 days ago||
It very much came from the Bitcoin world and was sold as a way to run your own node. Great experience if you’re into that but it’s nothing that is forced on you, they’re just “apps” like everything else you can install on it.
wmf 2 days ago||
I had the same feeling but that was years ago. They seem pretty neutral now.
More comments...