Top
Best
New

Posted by uyzstvqs 7 days ago

Tell HN: HN was down

- HN errored on all authenticated requests with 502 Bad Gateway. It did still respond to a limited amount of unauthenticated requests with presumably cached pages, which did not get updated. The last post on /newest claimed "0 minutes ago", but was actually much older (1:32:57 PM GMT) and not the newest post.

- This status page actually identified the outage: https://hackernews.onlineornot.com/ - Pages by Hund and Statuspal did not show the outage.

- The last post before the outage was https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46301823 (1:39:59 PM GMT). The last comment was https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46301848 (1:41:54 PM GMT).

- There was an average of ~4 seconds per comment just prior to the outage. Based on this, HN likely went down at 1:41:58 PM GMT.

599 points | 327 commentspage 2
steve_adams_86 7 days ago|
I was fortunate enough to get to watch a bunch of kids racing and bouncing in bouncy castles in our school gym during HN's downtime.

It's not that much different from HN, come to think of it.

(ha, ha)

ashf023 7 days ago||
Yes, and on one request I saw a message like "Restarting server - this won't take long", and soon after it's back up.
sltr 7 days ago||
Yeah I couldn't log in for a bit this morning. It's concerning how often and how many times I tried. Glad it's resolved.
imiric 7 days ago|
Next time try not to beat a dead horse expecting it to resurrect. :)
mlhpdx 7 days ago||
So now we call the refresh button CPR?
dhruv3006 7 days ago||
I was quiet surprised really. HN almost never goes down.
Aachen 7 days ago|
You don't visit enough my friend :)

It's down about 8.4 minutes per week. On 26% of days it doesn't work at least once, and on 12% of days it has more than one consecutive failed check. The longest uptime streak was 24 days

I've been keeping track since exactly 2 years (to the day!) because I was surprised that it seemed briefly down for me on a daily basis. Was I getting unlucky and hitting it every time, or was it just down very often? Nobody posted anything so I started answering the question for myself :p

I've been meaning to post the tracker to HN but there's a pesky bug I want to fix: the "is it currently down" stat. I don't know how this is beyond me but something in the code bugs out. So this is my first time posting about it

ayewo 7 days ago||
Would love to see it when you do get round to posting it :)
danielfalbo 7 days ago||
As soon as I noticed it was down I came to hacker news to post about it, but...
xxs 7 days ago||
PSA - if you delete your cookies, HN gets it easier. Or just test it in a private window.

It did work without being logged on. The auth service appeared to be down as the log in attempt (just showing the page) failed.

scottydelta 7 days ago|
Now it makes sense. I was puzzled about why it was working on the phone browser and not on my system. I'm logged into HN on my system.
dustfinger 7 days ago||
It would be a nice feature if hackernews had a simple news.ycombinator.com/status page that I could trust. I don't like loading those some-sketchy-domain/status-right-now sites.
mmooss 7 days ago|
> news.ycombinator.com/status page

That's not so useful when news.ycombinator.com is having problems.

dustfinger 7 days ago||
True. how about https://ycombinator-status.com or https://status.ycombinator.com. They can drop that link on their official ycombinator.com site just so it is easy to tell that it is legit when they are not down. They can maintain the status for all of their official sites there. Well, with the exception of ycombinator-status.com of course. I guess they can post that status on some-sketchy-domain/status-right-now - LOL!

Maybe ycombinator does have an official status page somewhere, but it is not easy to find if that is the case.

gaigalas 7 days ago||
I got confused by the "minutes ago" thing.

Working with full dates in the HTML and doing a tiny JavaScript that calculates the "minutes ago" would actually be a neat improvement.

codyklimdev 7 days ago||
I thought HN traffic got blocked on my work's network for a second, phew! My lunch breaks would've gotten a lot more dull.
zzixp 7 days ago|
First AWS/Azure/Cloudflare and now HN?!?
philipwhiuk 7 days ago||
Time to update the meme: https://preview.redd.it/cloudflare-had-a-rough-day-today-and...
imiric 7 days ago||
We can live without the former, but not HN!
gjsman-1000 7 days ago||
You won't be employed without the former.
More comments...