Top
Best
New

Posted by coloneltcb 12/17/2025

GitHub postponing the announced billing change for self-hosted GitHub Actions(twitter.com)
https://resources.github.com/actions/2026-pricing-changes-fo...
157 points | 126 commentspage 3
N_Lens 12/18/2025|
The outcry against this move was much larger than Microsoft anticipated. While there is some logic for charging for self-hosted, it just doesn't make sense for the consumers.
ChrisArchitect 12/18/2025||
Related:

initial development and reactions:

Pricing Changes for GitHub Actions

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46291156

donatj 12/18/2025||
The utter rent-seeking audacity of charging by the minute for action runners you run on your own server...

Charge a flat fee per Action, sure. There is a tiny cost on GitHub's part associated with the API calls for starting and stopping, but if my build takes 8 hours on a self-hosted runner there is no more cost to GitHub than it taking 10 seconds.

That's the whole point of self-hosted runners.

Maybe there was more outrage elsewhere, but I was frankly confused at the seeming lack thereof here on Hacker News.

ClikeX 12/18/2025||
Yeah, the per minute pricing is what really does it. It makes me think they've gone with the worst option first, so people will swallow the new adjusted workflow they'll come up with.
franktankbank 12/18/2025||
I don't even understand how they could do it. You own the servers that are giving them responses to determine the start/end times, so fudge the numbers fuck them, maybe you could find bugs in their shitty code so they start crediting you.

I think they kinda fucked themselves 3 concrete ways (among the nerds which may not be a problem for them):

1) this whole thing

2) the infinite running jobs issues which called attention to how poorly managed the GHA system is

3) zig et al announcing their departure and all the positive conversation around that

brodo 12/18/2025||
https://archive.ph/3nsGi
ryandvm 12/18/2025||
Seems like a year with record downtime for them is not a great time to announce a price increase...
top_sigrid 12/18/2025||
See also:

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46304379

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46305216

Daviey 12/18/2025||
Oh good, I can postpone my migration for personal projects.
redrove 12/18/2025|
Or, rather, you have more time to execute it. They _will_ rug pull again, this is Microsoft ffs.
duskdozer 12/18/2025|||
It's the classic strategy of floating an extreme change, "listening to feedback", and then coming back later with the price they intended to charge all along.
KJBweb 12/18/2025|||
That's the signal I'm getting here and they're not even being coy about it, they're just postponing some form of inevitable price increase.
egorfine 12/18/2025||
Who could've thought, really
ath3nd 12/19/2025|
[dead]
More comments...