Top
Best
New

Posted by WaitWaitWha 12/18/2025

Deliberate Internet Shutdowns(www.schneier.com)
327 points | 173 commentspage 3
krautburglar 12/22/2025|
Worship of the eternal steady-state. Whoever speaks against any intervention to preserve it is a heretic, and must be excommunicated.

Whether it’s ML training, pentesting, or old-fashioned engineering, we have to throw the occasional curve-ball at our systems in order to improve them. Surprise internet shutdowns are good, even if the ostensible reasons for them are dumb. Maybe people will host more information offline, and become less dependent on cloud services…

BLKNSLVR 12/22/2025|
> Surprise internet shutdowns are good

I'll correct that to: Surprise internet outages are good

For the same outcomes though. More and varied methods of contingency.

kallo 12/22/2025||
Ha
temptemptemp111 12/22/2025||
[dead]
hannukahharry 12/22/2025|
This is concerning in the comments:

> I suspect most can guess where this mess will end up, and it’s not good.

What I read from this is going to sound conspiratorial, but I think it’s a valid “read between the lines” of an insider. I think they’re saying that they’re alarmed that Silicon Valley is supporting the current U.S. administration assuming he’s doing what’s best for their welfare, while it’s clear based on the activities of Iran and others that are practicing working without internet that they are planning on losing internet, which could either be because Iran, Russia, China, or the U.S. itself may plan to sever or disable internet connections (while unsure what would be isolated or disabled) as an act of war or extreme and dangerously naive nationalism.