Top
Best
New

Posted by ibobev 12/19/2025

Garage – An S3 object store so reliable you can run it outside datacenters(garagehq.deuxfleurs.fr)
722 points | 182 commentspage 3
agwa 12/19/2025|
Does this support conditional PUT (If-Match / If-None-Match)?
codethief 12/19/2025|
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46328218
tenacious_tuna 12/20/2025||
Anyone know if it's possible to bandwidth-limit the sync operations? I'd love to set up garage instances across my families' houses to act as a distributed backup, but I don't want to hose their (or my) down/uplink during awake hours. Having redundant selfhosted S3like storage would solve many problems for me, but I really need that capability.
allanrbo 12/19/2025||
I use Syncthing a lot. Is Garage only really useful if you specifically want to expose an S3 drop in compatible API, or does it also provide other benefits over syncthing?
lxpz 12/19/2025||
They are not solving the same problem.

Syncthing will synchronize a full folder between an arbitrary number of machines, but you still have to access this folder one way or another.

Garage provides an HTTP API for your data, and handles internally the placement of this data among a set of possible replica nodes. But the data is not in the form of files on disk like the ones you upload to the API.

Syncthing is good for, e.g., synchronizing your documents or music collection between computers. Garage is good as a storage service for back-ups with e.g. Restic, for media files stored by a web application, for serving personal (static) web sites to the Internet. Of course, you can always run something like Nextcloud in front of Garage and get folder synchronization between computers somewhat like what you would get with Syncthing.

But to answer your question, yes, Garage only provides a S3-compatible API specifically.

sippeangelo 12/19/2025||
You use Syncthing for object storage?
k__ 12/20/2025||
Half-OT:

Does anyone know a good open source S3 alternarive that's easily extendable with custom storage backends?

For example, AWS offers IA and Glacier in addition to the defaults.

onionjake 12/20/2025|
Storj supports arbitrary configured backends each with different erasure coding, node placement, etc.
yupyupyups 12/20/2025||
Garage is amazing! But it would be even more amazing if it had immutable object support. :)

This is used for ransomware resistant backups.

ekjhgkejhgk 12/19/2025||
Anybody understand how this compares with Vast?
BOOSTERHIDROGEN 12/20/2025|
I use juicefs