Top
Best
New

Posted by johnathandos 2 days ago

Ask HN: What would you do if you didn't work in tech?

This question generated some very interesting discussions in another online community I’m in. I would likely pursue a career in occupational therapy or speech-language pathology. I would love to do work that directly benefits the lives of others and to spend more time interacting with people from all walks.
61 points | 140 commentspage 3
bpt3 2 days ago|
Some form of building things in the physical world rather than the digital; probably working in construction since I already do it on the side.
disantlor 2 days ago|
im with you, im completely over digital at this point
bpt3 2 days ago||
I'm not at all, but if I had to leave it behind I'd just keep building offline exclusively instead of doing both.
ajma 2 days ago||
Doctor. Still want to explore "systems" to diagnose issues and build plans for improvement.

When I was 45, I did briefly consider making the switch

ProllyInfamous 2 days ago|
As a med-school dropout, in his early 40s (left medicine two decades ago), I cannot even imagine having enough energy to even apply for medical school. At least in the United Hates of America, this is my jaded perspective.

I became an electrician, instead, with stints IBEW and self-employed residential. Lots of money-making opportunities, but lots of unlicensed competition from handymen that "know just enough to be dangerous" — most customers only care if the light turns on, not that it's long-term safe.

bespokedevelopr 2 days ago||
Are you self-employed now? Why stick with residential repair work instead of trying commercial or new construction?
ProllyInfamous 2 days ago||
I'm actually attempting to get into officework, somewhere. I can't do another twenty years of physical construction, whether in houses or factories.

>Are you self-employed now?

Yes, but I choose not to work regularly.

Fortunately, I have enough savings to not be too worried — presuming the economy picks up within the next few years (I can outlast this presidency, doing nothing).

JTbane 2 days ago||
Probably something blue collar like electrician, plumbing or auto repair.
ProllyInfamous 2 days ago|
I became a union electrician specifically to get away from tech and then found myself spending most of my apprenticeship wiring data centers.

Can't seem to escape from the tech gods.

Unfortunately blue collar labor takes its toll on bodies — probably best-left to hobby grunt work (and not full-time) unless you like back/knee/hip pain =D

I'm currently attempting to transition back into white collar tech (early 40s) but we all know how that's going (in this economy). Fortunately twisting wires together for decades has allowed me to stack enough savings that I'm not in a rush / desperate for re-training/employment.

crossroadsguy 2 days ago||
One of these or a mix of - history, archaeology, and literature. But as they say, you never know.

I absolutely knew even when I left school ("school" school) that none of these would pay, so I assume your question has an implicit "if money was no concern". Because money/job was the reason I picked engineering and CS in college. While I did quite well (academically and professionally), I never loved it. Maybe I liked it here and there. Then I knew this would happen; that's the reason I was at least prudent enough to never do that CS MS (with multiple options for full scholarships in Europe around a decade ago). But not prudent enough to explore masters in many of the non-STEM fields that were there for the taking pretty much. Some of those might have paired well with this STEM bachelors in some way or the other.

schmookeeg 2 days ago||
I fully expected to age out of tech by the time I hit 40 (just hit 49, still in tech) -- so I do flight instruction, aircraft inspections and relocation. It's tech money but not tech consistency, and has basically pivoted my favorite hobby and turned it into a job, which has its own challenges.

I'm still building it out. Going for my Repair Station license next year and hoping to add pitot-static and transponder calibration to my services menu. I wrench on my own plane, but the liability exposure is insane, so I won't sign work for others.

It's really odd, but I think when I disclose this to my tech masters, there is something of a novelty value, and they appreciate that I can sling code... and also other things. That old "well rounded" trope I guess.

Desafinado 2 days ago||
Do I need to make money? If the answer is no, then I would do something physical and mindless like stocking shelves or landscaping.

If the answer is yes, I'll stick with software.

When I was in college I did residential landscaping in the summers, and in retrospect it was a good time.

trenning 2 days ago||
Before I got my degree I was a machinist/ millwright and doing various things in between. Took a break after covid to go back for a little to decompress from tech but inevitably came back to programming.

Love the work but hate the pay and toll it took on my body.

Carpentry is fun too but metal is better.

bicx 2 days ago|
I’ve looked into putting together a small shop, but you’re right. Startup cost is really high, pay is shit.
_alternator_ 2 days ago||
I’ve made some interesting things in the past few years, in particular singing Tesla coils and digitally-controlled plasma tube lights. Was thinking about making bespoke musical instruments based on some of these learnings.

Of particular interest was some interesting types of feedback that came from the Tesla coils. Basically we modulated the frequency we drove the coils to produce sound, but the coils would interfere with one another because that’s how electromagnetism works. We had to tune them to different resonant frequencies to play sound. But the interference itself could sound unique and eerie, sometimes like an old-timey radio. It’s similar in principle to a theremin but a very different sound.

Or I could just get a soul sucking job and do this in early retirement. Shrug.

drunken_thor 2 days ago||
All the jobs I rather be doing are antiquated. Furniture maker but it’s not a viable job anymore either. A machinist, tool-die maker. Or mechanic maybe. I have always thought that mechanics are just debugging a very specific architecture. None of these make money though.
Froedlich 1 day ago||
A friend of mine is getting ready to retire after 30-odd years in IT. He has already tooled up and trained for his retirement profession: farrier; the guy who makes and installs horse shoes. It's more profitable than it used to be since few people do it any more, and farriers typically work on their own schedule.
jtolds 2 days ago||
> Ford CEO says he has 5,000 open mechanic jobs with up to 6-figure salaries from the shortage of manually skilled workers: https://fortune.com/2025/11/12/ford-ceo-manufacturing-jobs-t...
speakfreely 2 days ago||
"Up to" is doing a lot of work in that sentence.
lesuorac 2 days ago||
Honestly, it seems to me that it's "undoing" a lot of work.

Labor Rate at dealerships around me are over $200/h. Granted the mechanic doesn't get 100% of that but 200 * 52 * 8 is nearly 600k. It seems like you could go somewhere else and get the same amount of money as Ford (or more) and don't need to worry about future salary increases not occurring.

speakfreely 2 days ago||
The problem is that the mechanics are paid fixed hours for a given type of job (according to the dealership's standard for how long a given job should take). They are not truly being paid per hour. While it's supposed to encourage efficiency, you can imagine how this negatively affects the mechanics as well as the work quality outcomes.
Froedlich 1 day ago|
The pool of tech jobs in my area was sparse, but the local employers were fully on board with the big-city "use them for a while and toss them out" system. So when times were good in IT, I bought a machine shop, and in between times of lucrative IT employment, I did short-run metalworking and engine rebuilding.
More comments...