Top
Best
New

Posted by borisandcrispin 3 days ago

A tab hoarder's journey to sanity(twitter.com)
104 points | 120 commentspage 3
kazinator 2 days ago|
> bookmarks only show titles and favicons

Bookmark titles are editable. If you create a bookmark and the title doesn't mean anything, change it.

I often put bookmarks on the toolbar, so I shorten them to one character, or empty string (if the icon is clear) to have space for as many as possible.

> I don't like the browser bookmarking system because it's too hard to organize the folders and it's not visual

But then goes on to write a whole section of the article "Here's a few interesting links I discovered buried in those 664 tabs" which gives nothing but topic headings, under which are lists of raw links with no description.

:)

alexpotato 2 days ago||
I switched to using Pinboard [0] for all bookmarking and never looked back.

The real unlocks were:

- using the bookmarklet that pops open a small browser window with the page title, suggested tags

- doing the same on my iphone

- have a couple in browser bookmarks that point to the tags for important things

It's so good I even used it to track all of my LinkedIn connections tagged by location, job function etc (inspired by Derek Sivers post on having a database [1])

0 - https://pinboard.in

1 - https://sive.rs/dbt

knuckleheads 2 days ago||
I hoard tabs as well, and https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tab-manager-p... has been a game changer. Let's me move them around within windows, which I like a lot. Let's me create windows that have specific purposes. The tree style tabs never sat right with me mentally, couldn't say why, I want each window to have a purpose.
Yizahi 2 days ago||
Thankfully Firefox helped me with tab hoarding dependency, by silently losing saves session without any visible crash or issue, just on the normal open. Now I have to treat tabs as if they won't be saved ever again and don't leave anything important open. Thanks Mozilla, great use of your time and money, spending them on useless LLM integration and lining CEOs pockets instead of fixing damn basic functionality.
kasabali 2 days ago||
So much this. Thankfully it hasn't lost tabs for me for a very long time, but I find it ridiculous that Firefox's session persistence is basically "yeah let's deserialize it into a single line of JSON and write it to disk every 15 seconds".

On top of that, what was their solution when it became apparent it was slowly killing your SSD by blowing up write amplification through the roof [1]? Zipping the JSON. Yeah. Seriously.

I mean sure, this storage format might've been a nice first implementation as a PoC, but you'd think they'd redo this at some point and store the session in an Sqlite DB file or something, I mean it's not like they haven't been using it already for history and bookmarks.

1. https://www.servethehome.com/firefox-is-eating-your-ssd-here...

random3 2 days ago||
lol - Chrome does the same - state management is pure crap
nathan_compton 3 days ago||
I just close my browser and all tabs all the time. I cannot understand why this bothers people so much. I don't even bookmark stuff.

If its important, I just remember it.

chankstein38 2 days ago|
Because some people might have 10 different things they're doing in any given day and sometimes their ADHD distracts them from one thing to the other and you don't want to lose all that context.

The article does actually explicitly address this as well.

>I do this because I have ADHD and I'm a visual thinker. if I don't see something, I forget it exists. So I keep tabs open, group them by project, save things to read later. Before I know it, I have another browser window with multiple tabs sprawling across my screen.

Which mirrors my experience. My brain can obsess over things all it wants but if I don't see that set of tabs open roughly in the same order as I had them then I am promptly forgetting about that. I've gone through setting things up before only to realize a week before I had done the same thing in a different spot that I didn't name very well.

RyanOD 2 days ago||
Every couple weeks, I click the red "x" and close all my tabs and start fresh.

This approach has never once caused me any issues...and it sure feels good.

BeetleB 2 days ago|
Here's a more intermediate approach:

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tabwrangler/

The basic idea: It closes any tab that has not been visited in the last N hours.

You can lock tabs to prevent them from closing (you can match on domain names, etc).

You can also see the last so many tabs it closed (1000? I forgot if this is configurable).

It's been fantastic. I don't need to manually manage tabs any more. I happily keep opening new tabs, knowing full well it will clean up after me.

random3 2 days ago||
This sort of denies there was any purpose to keep the tab open to begin with.
tacker2000 3 days ago||
Tabs on mobile arent really the same.

I never close tabs or re-use old open tabs on mobile, since the UI just buries them and I just open a new tab if i want to check something, so I will just accumulate useless tabs.

On my Laptop i try to only hoard a handful of tabs. I just noticed I have some open since months, but never gotten to reading them.

The thing is i want to read the content, but never find time, so they just stay there.

Numerlor 2 days ago||
Why is their browser using so much memory? I'm quite bad at closing tabs since I've switched to vertical and just open new windows instead. And even with that I don't think I ever broke 10gb on edge except for when I opened many YouTube videos at once and then went through them which kept the tabs loaded
r_lee 2 days ago||
>reads title

smells like ADHD

"I do this because I have ADHD and I'm a visual thinker. if I don't see something, I forget it exists."

yup

nancyminusone 2 days ago||
Doesn't make sense to me, and I've been diagnosed with the same.

I consider tabs to be inherently volatile and disposable. I rarely have more than 10 open at once. There is no hope of finding anything with more than that many. If you need to save something, doesn't it make more sense to actually save it?

Apart from that, I usually have the browser history open.

r_lee 1 day ago|||
if you're not like working on much then of course no need for many tabs, but I tend to ctrl click a lot of links / videos etc. so I end up with having 10 tabs in one window 5 in another, 15 one other etc...

and then there's sometimes a graveyard of them but I tend to keep them "just in case" even though I may not ever need those tabs, but I don't remember so I tend to play it safe

I don't use the browser history much, maybe that's your equivalent?

random3 2 days ago|||
You know in a chrome you can search through tabs, right?
jebarker 2 days ago||
> if I don't see something, I forget it exists.

To some extent this seems like a feature, not a bug. I have many tabs open that I find myself resistant to closing but I'm pretty sure if they just got closed and I forgot they existed my life would be no worse.

r_lee 1 day ago||
This is exactly my experience. sometimes it does come handy, but most of the time it really doesn't matter. but that "risk" of potentially closing something that you'll need / want to look at later makes me just create a new window and drag that one in the background for safekeeping
RBerenguel 3 days ago|
I wrote a (not published to the store, it's kind of just for me) Chrome extension (together with Gemini, pretty early in the days of it) that attaches an expiration date to tabs. Works reasonably well to cure it (except I keep setting many to 31 days… but eventually a month passes)
More comments...