Top
Best
New

Posted by ersiees 3 days ago

Anthropic is Down(updog.ai)
153 points | 144 commentspage 4
jackinthehat 3 days ago|
Yup. SOS
StingyJelly 3 days ago||
Seems like a wider issue. Signal is down too, youtube seems to be struggling. Here we go again...
Jgoauh 3 days ago||
its up !
ath3nd 3 days ago||
[dead]
musak_kreatr 3 days ago||
[dead]
copilot_king 3 days ago||
[dead]
Rahmer 3 days ago||
[flagged]
EngineerUSA 3 days ago||
What does Down mean in this context? I imagine running inference on any server suffices. Just rent AWS since Amazon owns it anyways and keep Claude running.
peter422 3 days ago||
Fortunately before working hours on the west coast so it shouldn't impact that many people.
hackeman300 3 days ago||
I hear you on the west coast, but two thirds of the population lives east of the Mississippi and is in working hours
esskay 3 days ago|||
Ah yes, because only the west coast of a single country are the priority for a globally distributed company.
hk__2 3 days ago||
HN users assuming the US are the only country in the World, episode #53985902582.
atonse 3 days ago||
Only one half of the US :)

Us east coasters here are having a chuckle (what else can we do? we can't get work done while Claude is down... I'll be damned if I have to type in code letter by letter ever again!).

throwup238 3 days ago||
We all have a chuckle when AWS east is down.
gsibble 3 days ago|||
Yikes man.
mike-cardwell 3 days ago||
Just a healthy reminder that places outside of the USA exist.
bergheim 3 days ago|
Everybody that uses it knows it is down, what value does this add? No context here either. Posts like these feels so much like a low hanging first-to-post-this for karma grab.

It's like.. Popular service is down, let me post that to hn first! Low effort but can still end up popular.

I dunno. Maybe I'm being overly critical. Thoughts?

To add something to the discussion though: this is a reminder why you should not invest in one tool, claude or otherwise. Also, don't go enhancing one of these agents, ond only one of these agents. beads spent the better part of a medium sized country in energy to create a simple TODO list and got smeared in 10 minutes once claude integrated todos in their client.

zamadatix 3 days ago||
The usual impetus is that the official status pages habitually under report and sharing the status page showing the best information gives a basis to form a place to have discussion about where/how/why it was down. Unfortunately, many seem to take the other interpretation instead and said discussion often ends up being low quality in a self fulfilling loop of reasons.

The second note probably deserves to be a separate comment.

bergheim 3 days ago||
This is a good take. You are right, they rarely do report actual status.

And yes, it probably should have been :)

nerdjon 3 days ago|||
Not everyone that interacts with a service is interacting with it directly? How is this a serious question.

A thing called API’s exist and if your users rely on it but your not interacting with it directly yourself, seeing this could save you time to investigate an issue.

Or you are using it yourself and seeing this post confirms it is not just you having an issue and you can move on with your day.

This has nothing to do with it being AI and it being a large service. It is the same with posts about an Azure or AWS.

bergheim 3 days ago||
I wasn't using it. I was just on hn. And yes, it is the same about all of these services of course, which was my point.

Not sure how "nothing to do with being a large service" and then you bring up Azure and AWS matches though, but fair enough.

Now I know you guys care, so fair game.

zenexer 3 days ago|||
It’s more about the ensuing discussion.
romanovcode 3 days ago|||
Completely agree, not to mention it was down for couple of minutes. Who even cares?
emsign 3 days ago|||
I don't use it but I'd like to know even if it's just entertainment value. But I can imgine people who intend to use it learn something from it: redundancy must be part of their strategy like you said.
thehamkercat 3 days ago||
Everybody who uses anything knows that it's down

So what value does it add saying "X is down" anywhere?

It's just for discussion, you can't just ignore it and not talk about it with anyone if a particular service is down and posts like this are pretty common on hn and i haven't seen anyone complaining, it's you being overly critical, yes

bergheim 3 days ago||
Fair enough!