Top
Best
New

Posted by jakequist 2 days ago

OpenClaw is what Apple intelligence should have been(www.jakequist.com)
513 points | 411 commentspage 5
xngbuilds 2 days ago|
I imagine in a few years our phone will become our AI assistant, locally and cloud powered, that understand us deeply. And Apple will release a human robot, loaded with the same intelligence in the phone to become our home assistant or companion. But first Apple needs to allow us to rename our phone agent/helper other than Siri.
zkmon 2 days ago||
So far, personal assistants have only been an initial wonder that faded away. Siri, Alexa, Cortana, Google Home etc hardly had any big impact. It's not fault of the company or product. Usecase is not strong and not worth the hassle and privacy. It's not a basic need yet.
RobMurray 2 days ago|
That's because all of those products are laughably bad compared to chat gpt or similar, and they are still bad despite the advances in AI. Apple integrated Siri with Chat GPT and some how managed to make it so much worse. It can't even do a conversation and the speech recognition is near useless and hasn't improved in 10 years. Alexa is the same except I feel like it used to hear me better. Now I have to shout.
kempje 2 days ago||
This reads like it was written by an LLM.
epaga 2 days ago|
"Not Final Cut. Not Logic. An AI agent that clicks buttons." (and writes blog posts)
deadbabe 2 days ago||
I used to have little cron jobs that would fire small python scripts daily to help me detect when certain clothes were on sale or in stock on a website it scraped and then send me an email or text. I was proud of that “automation”.

I guess now I’ll just use an AI agent to do the same thing instantly :(

mold_aid 2 days ago||
What are the actual numbers on these purpotedly all-encompassing mac mini sales?
queenkjuul 2 days ago||
They have all the time in the world, practically. OpenClaw is nowhere near an Apple product for myriad reasons. When Apple is able to build an agent that is safe and reliable, they will.
jordiburgos 2 days ago||
How OpenClaw got so much promoted in days? Maybe Apple is behind them and wants everybody to beta test it before they sell it as a service.

So all the current users or OpenClaw are just beta-testers.

anon_anon12 2 days ago||
Hell no. There's so much friction in setting up OpenClaw to be able to utilise it efficiently. Then the security concerns. I'd in no way want my daily driver to do something with my data that I didn't want it to do.
ed_mercer 2 days ago||
The author is a bit extreme for expecting apple to have done something as complex as ooenclaw, not even OpenAI or Anthropic have really done it yet.

However this does not excuse Apple to sit with their thumbs up their asses for all these years.

dmix 2 days ago|
> However this does not excuse Apple to sit with their thumbs up their asses for all these years.

They've been wildly successful for all of those years. They've never been in the novel software business. Siri though one could argue was neglected, but it was also neglected at Amazon Alexa and Google home stuff still sucks too (mostly because none of them made any money and most of their big ideas for voice assistants never came true).

acdha 2 days ago|||
They haven’t been truly novel if you want to say that, for example, the Lisa was covering Xerox PARC ideas but I think you’d have to ignore a lot of significant work to say they didn’t substantially innovate in GUIs, personal assistants and handwriting recognition (Newton), touchscreen behavior (iPhone), etc.

The key thing is that they tend not to ship things which aren’t mature enough to be useful (Vision Pro and Apple Intelligence being cautionary tales about why) and voice assistants just aren’t doing a whole lot for anyone. Google and Amazon have been struggling to find a market, too, and it’s rare to find someone who uses those dramatically more than Apple users do Siri. I think most of the big advances need something close to AGI: if you can’t describe something in a short command, it’s usually much faster to use a device with a screen and a lot of the useful tasks need a level of security and reliability which requires actual reasoning to deliver.

jjtheblunt 2 days ago|||
MacOS and NeXTstep / OSX were very much novel software for mass market consumers.
binsquare 2 days ago|
Genuinely just tried this and thought, this is what Siri / Alexa should be
More comments...