Top
Best
New

Posted by jakequist 2 days ago

OpenClaw is what Apple intelligence should have been(www.jakequist.com)
513 points | 411 commentspage 8
epaga 2 days ago|
"Not Final Cut. Not Logic. An AI agent that clicks buttons."

...and that writes blog posts for you. So tired of this voice.

tgma 2 days ago||
Mac minis out of stock because of OpenClaw?

Nah if they are actually out of stock (I've only seen it out of stock at exceptional Microcenter prices; Apple is more than happy to sell you at full price) it is because there's a transition to M5 and they want to clear the old stock. OpenClaw is likely a very small portion of the actual Mac mini market, unless you are living in a very dense tech area like San Francisco.

One thing of note that people may forget is that the models were not that great just a year ago, so we need to give it time before counting chickens.

orliesaurus 2 days ago||
How much revenue do you think Apple made EXTRA from people buying Mac minis for this hype?
dcreater 2 days ago||
This is Yellow Pages type thinking in the age of the internet. No one is going to own an agentic layer (list any of the multitude of platforms already irrelevant like OpenAI Agent SDK, Google A2A) . No one is going to own a new app store (GPTs are already dead). No one is going to foundation models (FOSS models are extremely capable today). No one is going to own inference (Data centers will never be as cost effective as that old MacBook collecting dust that is plenty capable of running a 1B model that can compete with ChatGPT 3.5 and all the use cases that it already was good at like writing high school essays, recipes etc.) The only thing that is sticking is Markdown (SKILLS.md, AGENTS.md)

This is because the simple reality of this new technology is that this is not the local maxima. Any supposed wall you attempt to put up will fail - real estate website closes its API? Fine, a CUA+VLM will make it trivial to navigate/extract/use. We will finally get back to the right solution of protocols over platforms, file over app, local over cloud or you know the way things were when tech was good.

P.S: You should immediately call BS when you see outrageous and patently untrue claims like "Mac minis are sold out all over.." - I checked my Best Buy in the heart of SF and they have stock. Or "that its all over Reddit, HN" - the only thing that is all over Reddit is unanimous derision towards OpenClaw and its security nightmares.

Utterly hate the old world mentality in this post. Looked up the author and ofcourse, he's from VC.

nielsbot 2 days ago|
> No one is going to own an agentic layer

Don't underestimate the capitalists. We've seen this many times in the past--most recently the commercialization of the Internet. Before that, phones, radio and television.

dcreater 2 days ago||
Fair enough. This is my war time rhetoric. Its up to us to effect the future we want.
wooger 2 days ago||
This is the most obviously AI written text I think I've ever read.
jesse_dot_id 2 days ago||
It's just the juiciest attack surface of all time so I vehemently disagree.
yoyohello13 2 days ago||
If you can’t see why something like OpenClaw is not ready for production I don’t know what to tell you. People’s perceptions are so distorted by FOMO they are completely ignoring the security implications and dangers of giving an LLM keys to your life.

I’m sure apple et al will eventually have stuff like OpenClaw but expecting a major company to put something so unpolished, and with such major unknowns, out is just asinine.

chaosprint 2 days ago||
I completely disagree. 1. OpenClaw's design is ugly. 2. Its security is extremely worrying. 3. I hate this kind of marketing.

Personal opinion.

yoda97 2 days ago||
This post reads like an apple fanfiction
amelius 2 days ago|
Can't wait to buy a new ClawBook.
More comments...