Top
Best
New

Posted by nar001 5 hours ago

France's homegrown open source online office suite(github.com)
436 points | 207 commentspage 3
tjwebbnorfolk 3 hours ago||
This is a toy. It really makes it look like they aren't that serious.
halapro 3 hours ago|
It's typical of non-technical people to ask for "like Facebook, but x y z." They just don't know the magnitude of effort required behind these projects.
bsenftner 4 hours ago||
I would not be surprised if American PACs adopted this out of concern that US based office suites are politically compromised.
jmclnx 5 hours ago||
Very nice.

You (at least I) would not think of France as having a good Open Source presence, but they do. Over the years I have heard of many good Open Source Projects coming out of France.

I sometimes wonder if it is because of French vs English Language were you hardly hear of their projects in English speaking Countries.

astrolx 4 hours ago||
I think an unsung hero in making open source broadly known and adopted in France is Framasoft [https://framasoft.org/en/], a non-profit association. They have since many many years an initiative to de-google internet and provide free and hosted alternatives and resources.
BiteCode_dev 4 hours ago||
+1 on this, they had an amazing presence in the French community for 20 years and many of us own them our passion for FOSS.
bsenftner 4 hours ago|||
The French have amazing technologists, I worked with many stunningly brilliant French men and women across 3D gaming, film and media production. However, culturally they end up in a little "French pod" when not working in France because they know how to and really enjoy vigorous debate. If one cannot hold their own in their free wheeling intellectualized conversation and debate style, one might end up feeling insulted and stop hanging out with the frogs. There also seems to be a deep cultural understanding of design that is not present in people, generally, from other nations. That creates some interesting perspectives in software interactive design.
guerrilla 2 hours ago|||
> You (at least I) would not think of France as having a good Open Source presence

France has always been super heavy on open source. They even used to host Les Trophées du Libre, international open-source software competition. FramaSoft (i.e. PeerTube) and VLC are also French.

akdev1l 4 hours ago|||
Isn’t VLC French also?
jodrellblank 4 hours ago||
OCaml and early Prolog are from France:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OCaml

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alain_Colmerauer

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Institute_for_Research_... (INRIA)

Galanwe 4 hours ago||
Also QEmu and ffmpeg.

Also Docker.

Also Lichess.

Also Scikit Learn.

caned 4 hours ago|||
Two words: Fabrice Bellard
tokai 1 hour ago||
>would not think of France as having a good Open Source presence

You have not been paying attention.

sylware 4 hours ago||
Of course, it is not forcing to use any whatng cartel web engines namely has noscript/basic (x)html interop support (aka classic web) and/or with public and as simple as possible network protocols anyone can implement a rich GUI client for.

Of course its SDK has components choosen with care to maximize alternative (present and future) availability and its code is not stored on microsoft github.com.

ChrisArchitect 3 hours ago||
Another one?

Previously:

This week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46873294

2 weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46767668

johnjames87 2 hours ago||
[dead]
Cynnabar 5 hours ago||
[flagged]
nixass 5 hours ago||
Somewhat related, more overall context

France dumps Zoom and Teams as Europe seeks digital autonomy from the US https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46873294

nar001 5 hours ago||
Exactly what it says on the tin, France's gov made an office suite, online based, and video calling as an alternative/sovereign version of GSuite/Office 365
ginko 5 hours ago|
What's the value of it being online? Surely being able to run it as a native application would be preferable?
LunaSea 4 hours ago||
It means that it is de-facto compatible with all operating systems.

Also means that the tooling to make collaborative work in this suite possible already exists because it's a common use case on the web and less so on native software (see Microsoft Office vs. Microsoft 365 online).

mimasama 3 hours ago||
Sure, "all" operating systems. "All" that is OSes that have a web browser built for it that at least supports [TransformStream](https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/TransformSt...)... And the browser and spec written and maintained mostly by people outside of France. Kinda compromises the point of being "sovereign" doesn't it?
touisteur 3 hours ago||
Forking Firefox whenever the rug is pulled seems doable (with elbow grease), and in the meantime Europeans can invest on problems that don't have an already mature fully open-source solution.
vman81 4 hours ago|||
Managing documents on the back end can be very sensible, depending on your work context. Not having to deal with installations is also a real advantage in a heterogeneous environment with a mix of US-controlled operating systems and unencumbered OSes. It also makes migration between them easier, since you only need a common browser to be supported.
ddulaney 4 hours ago|||
There are definitely some benefits! Installation and updates become trivial. Also, collaboration is generally easier, because all you have to do is send a link.

These are the same reasons Google Docs took off, and they are real advantages.

More comments...