Top
Best
New

Posted by ColinWright 19 hours ago

I verified my LinkedIn identity. Here's what I handed over(thelocalstack.eu)
1156 points | 406 commentspage 3
flumpcakes 7 hours ago|
I am about to talk about "vibes" and "feelings" so please take this with a grain of salt:

Does anyone else get the impression that they feel like the nefarious surveillance state is now real and definitely not for their benefit?

It's been a long running trope of the men in black, and the state listening to your phone calls, etc. Even after Snowdon's leaks, where we learned that there are these massive dragnets scooping up personal information, it didn't feel real. It felt distant and possibly could have been a "probably good thing" that is it was needed to catch "the real bad guys".

It feels different now. Since last year, it feels like the walls are closing in a bit and that now the US is becoming... well, I can't find the words, but it's not good.

weird_tentacles 5 hours ago|
You are slooowwly waking up.
tagyro 11 hours ago||
I almost fell for a very sophisticated phishing attack last December and most of the "verifiable" information was from my LinkedIn account.

For each role I had described some of the tasks and accomplishments and this was used in the phishing message.

Since then, I removed my photo, changed my name only to initials and removed all the role-specific information.

It's a bit of a bummer as I'm currently in the process of looking for a new job and unfortunately having a LinkedIn profile is still required in some places, but once I find it, I'll delete my profile.

randycupertino 10 hours ago|
I'm routinely shocked how biased people I work with are against individuals without a linkedin page. So many hiring managers across 15 years in my industry won't consider people without pages. One guy goes on rants how people are "sketchy" if they don't have a verified page and a lot of skill endorsements and testimonials! He'll pull up our vendors pages and check them out during meetings, complain if it isn't available or complete. I used to keep mine very minimal and locked down but I felt pressure from peers to flesh is out and keep it public which I hate.
Aurornis 8 hours ago||
I agree for in-person jobs.

For remote jobs with remote interviews, not having a LinkedIn page or having a LinkedIn page full of generic information that can be disproven by a quick background check are common traits of scam applicants.

A friend’s employer started requiring more verification after they hired a group of remote workers who would some times connect from North Korean IPs when they made a mistake with their VPN.

7777777phil 17 hours ago||
> If you’ve already verified — like me — here’s what I’d recommend

Did you actually follow through with 1-4 and if so what was the outcome? how long did it take?

kburman 7 hours ago||
I don't get the whole idea of treating identity verification as a private enterprise problem. I realize it's easy to just blame LinkedIn or Microsoft here, but the core issue is architectural. We are trying to solve a public utility problem by building private honeypots.

The government should provide an API or interface to validate a user, essentially acting just like an SSO. Instead of forcing users to upload raw passport scans to a third-party data broker, LinkedIn should just hit a government endpoint that returns an anonymized token or a simple boolean confirming "yes, this is a real, unique person." It gives platforms the sybil resistance they need without leaking the underlying PII.

egorfine 2 hours ago|
We have exactly that in Ukraine. And in Poland. And in many other countries.

This does not conform to the requirements of american KYC/AML provisions that require KYC service to store and leak PII.

po1nt 6 hours ago||
>Count them. 17 companies. 16 in the United States. 1 in Canada. Zero in the EU.

We regulated innovation out of the market. Why are you surprises that the only companies finding your data valuable are in the US?

danpritch 6 hours ago|
Maybe it's just me but I don't count tracking people as innovation. Tell me what's innovative about it.
PacificSpecific 16 hours ago||
I wonder what mongo and snowflake are doing with that data. The table is a little vague.

I was under the impression they just make database products. Do they have a side hustle involving collecting this type of data?

SahAssar 16 hours ago|
Subprocessor usually just means that you use their products in a way that your personal data passes through them. For example, let's say you are using cloudflare and aws to host a site, then your subprocessors would be cloudflare and aws.

It can be some more nefarious use, but it can also just be that they (persona in this case) use their services to process/store your data.

PacificSpecific 16 hours ago||
Ah I see that makes sense. Thanks for the clarification.
lacoolj 8 hours ago||
This is a little unnerving because I know I've had to provide similar ID verification somewhere online, but I can't remember where. And based on everything here, it was almost certainly Persona.

I guess I'll just be in the corner crossing my fingers none of it is found in a hostile foreign land or used against me.

throwaway77385 16 hours ago||
How does this work for the myriad banks I've had to prove my identity to in the same way? I'll be attempting steps 1-4 and see what Persona comes back with.
hliyan 10 hours ago||
Here's what I found the most frightenting:

> Hesitation detection — they tracked whether I paused during the process

> They use uploaded images of identity documents — that’s my passport — to train their AI.

> Persona’s Terms of Service cap their liability at $50 USD.

> They also include mandatory binding arbitration — no court, no jury, no class action.

8cvor6j844qw_d6 12 hours ago|
Seeing some of my colleagues verify through Persona on LinkedIn, and I can't quite figure out what they're getting out of it.

Every hiring process I've been through already requires proof of identity at some point. Background checks, I-9s, whatever it may be. So you're essentially handing your ID to a third party just to get a badge that doesn't skip any steps you'd have to do anyway.

Aurornis 8 hours ago||
It does provide an advantage when applying to remote jobs at some companies. They try to filter scammer applicants out early and the verified profile is one signal they look for.

Depends on the company, but in a competitive job market any extra signal can help.

There are a crazy number of fake LinkedIn profiles out there that are used for scamming companies or people.

Nextgrid 11 hours ago||
The badge could (I don't know, haven't done it yet) help you differentiate yourself in a sea of monkeys slinging ChatGPT'd profiles from a third-world boiler room.

(whether it actually does or the monkeys now got a steady source of fake/stolen IDs is another matter)

More comments...