Top
Best
New

Posted by vinhnx 1 day ago

How I use Claude Code: Separation of planning and execution(boristane.com)
895 points | 554 commentspage 16
aufklarer 18 hours ago|
[dead]
snigsnog 9 hours ago||
[dead]
ZeelRajodiya 18 hours ago||
[dead]
straydusk 14 hours ago||
This got upvotes? Literally just restating basics.
hilliardfarmer 1 day ago||
[flagged]
crazygringo 1 day ago|
Please don't be knee-jerk dismissive of posts. Absolute nothing about this article looks "LLM-generated style" to me.
bonsai_spool 1 day ago|||
I think it was edited with an LLM - the voice flits from human to bot but various tells are present. The heterogeneity of sentence structure is the clearest signal.

Here’s an older article from the author from 2024: https://boristane.com/blog/learnings-from-starting-building-...

zahlman 1 day ago||
I also suspect that people who spend too much time reading LLM-produced content and using LLMs end up suffering a kind of brain-rot from the "LLM house style", and start naturally using those idioms in their own writing even if they do it all by hand.
gregoryl 1 day ago|||

  >> Why This Works So Well
hilliardfarmer 17 hours ago|||
That was the giveaway for me too!
thousand_nights 1 day ago|||
an obvious tell from another tech influencer and Hn will eat it up
alexmorgan26 1 day ago||
[dead]
dimgl 1 day ago|
Pretty sure this entire comment is AI generated.
rob 1 day ago|||
Almost think we're at the point on HN where we need a special [flag bot] link for those that meet a certain threshold and it alerts @dang or something to investigate them in more detail. The amount of bots on here has been increasing at an alarming rate.
zahlman 1 day ago|||
There has been this really weird flood of new accounts lately that are making these kinds of bot comments with no clear purpose to making them. Maybe it comes from people experimenting with OpenClaw?
bluegatty 1 day ago||
I don't see how this is 'radically different' given that Claude Code literally has a planning mode.

This is my workflow as well, with the big caveat that 80% of 'work' doesn't require substantive planning, we're making relatively straight forward changes.

Edit: there is nothing fundamentally different about 'annotating offline' in an MD vs in the CLI and iterating until the plan is clear. It's a UI choice.

Spec Driven Coding with AI is very well established, so working from a plan, or spec (they can be somewhat different) is not novel.

This is conventional CC use.

dack 1 day ago|
last i checked, you can't annotate inline with planning mode. you have to type a lot to explain precisely what needs to change, and then it re-presents you with a plan (which may or may not have changed something else).

i like the idea of having an actual document because you could actually compare the before and after versions if you wanted to confirm things changed as intended when you gave feedback

bluegatty 1 day ago|||
'Giving precise feedback on a plan' is literally annotating the plan.

It comes back to you with an update for verification.

You ask it to 'write the plan' as matter of good practice.

What the author is describing is conventional usage of claude code.

gitaarik 1 day ago|||
A plan is just a file you can edit and then tell CC to check your annotations
ramoz 1 day ago|
One thing for me has been the ability to iterate over plans - with a better visual of them as well as ability to annotate feedback about the plan.

https://github.com/backnotprop/plannotator Plannotator does this really effectively and natively through hooks

prodtorok 1 day ago|
Wow, I've been needing this! The one issue I’ve had with terminals is reviewing plans, and desiring the ability to provide feedback on specific plan sections in a more organized way.

Really nice ui based on the demo.