Posted by usefulposter 2 days ago
> Off-Topic: Most stories about politics
One particularly egregious example (to me) of this is the politicisation of science [1] by various factions like governments, advocacy groups etc. because if we lose the integrity of science bad things will happen.
All that to say, the line has blurred so much, I highly doubt you can separate these topics again. HN reflects that as much as any other site.
This forum was founded in 2007. The US was very much involved in Iraq and Afghanistan at that time. If the same bar for coverage was in place at the time, HN would have been flooded with US Military content the way it is now. So yeah, obviously the bar has moved lower for this particular matter and it's because the current community on the site wants it to. Likewise the "generated/AI-edited comments" guideline seems equally squishy to me. And despite a rule about being "curmudgeonly", I'm pretty sure 80% of this site's content is curmudgeonly rants.
IMO at this scale dang, tomhow, and other mods need to be much stricter. When HN was 1/10 the size a shaming comment would often set a poster in place. Now they just sneer back in another comment and post 20 other guideline breaking things.
“most”
“extremely significant”
What’s extremely significant for someone is an offtopic for someone else and vice versa
I won't give you examples because all of them can be spinned about being relevant
"Well HN is an american site after all"
"Most of the HN users are american voters so it's relevant for them"
"Hackers need to be aware of what's happening in the world"
"You only say that because you disagree with that side"
etc
Same with the stories about Tesla flagged. If you read the comments it's always the same: "Pro-Tesla crowd is flagging everything negative about Elon so the bad news never reach the front page" vs "Anti-Tesla crowd flagging everything because they hate Elon"
HN is the best without politics. But it's not up to me.
Where's the curiosity about this world-changing technology? As all the CTOs have recently said: AI use not an option and it must change everything we do. /s
The next step is to run Pangram on every post and ban the offenders! Fight AI with AI! /s
In all seriousness, this is one of the few places I trust for genuine conversations with other people. Forums are mostly dead, Reddit is bots-galore, and I'm not signing up for Facebook just for groups.