Top
Best
New

Posted by microflash 12 hours ago

Malus – Clean Room as a Service(malus.sh)
https://fosdem.org/2026/schedule/event/SUVS7G-lets_end_open_...

https://malus.sh/blog.html

1018 points | 396 commentspage 6
fuddle 7 hours ago|
> MalusCorp International Holdings Ltd. is not responsible for any moral implications, existential crises, or late-night guilt spirals resulting from the use of our services.

I think they should take some responsibility!

izucken 9 hours ago||
Some parties wouldn't be thrilled about their "source available" getting cleaned this way. So when this gets completed it would only "clean" real open source that can't afford legal trouble. Satirically structured LLM text is not a defence.
pradn 6 hours ago||
Is AI-driven clean room implementation a wild west at the moment? I suppose there haven't yet been any cases to test this out in real life?
ivanjermakov 9 hours ago||
First I thought this is about manufacturing. Like semiconductor fabs requirement for room cleanness.
fraywing 8 hours ago||
The smells suspiciously like a well positioned gag that is secretly seeking VC attention. The emotional reaction turned attention seeking feels a bit like having ulterior motives... or maybe Moltbook has made me paranoid?
sam0x17 9 hours ago||
Have fun when using this service is itself used in court as evidence for creating a malicious copy
amiga386 11 hours ago||
I did try to upload a requirements.txt with "chardet < 7.0" in it ("Copyright (C) 2024 Dan Blanchard"? I don't think so buddy, it's mine now), but despite claiming otherwise, the satirical site only takes package.json so I uploaded the one from https://github.com/prokopschield/require-gpl/

It does actually generate a price (which is suspiciously like a fixed rate of $1 per megabyte), and does actually lead you to Stripe. What happens if someone actually pays? Are they going to be refunding everything, or are they actually going to file the serial numbers off for you?

mapcars 9 hours ago||
Heh, why don't you do the opposite - recreate proprietary software with open source license
intrasight 9 hours ago|
I expect that thousands of people are now doing just that. Most proprietary software is just a shiny UI in front of a crappy database schema.
Perz1val 8 hours ago||
I'd have mined the copied libraries with something that makes it possible to later change terms and extract fees, as it'd be expected that nobody reads the terms for such service
neya 9 hours ago|
You know the satire is so good that people actually confused this for something real:))
More comments...