Top
Best
New

Posted by Stwerner 18 hours ago

Warranty Void If Regenerated(nearzero.software)
As an experiment I started asking Claude to explain things to me with a fiction story and it ended up being really good, so I started seeing how far I could take it and what it would take to polish it enough to share publicly.

Over the last couple months, I've been building world bibles, writing and visual style guides, and other documents for this project… think the fiction equivalent of all the markdown files we use for agentic development now. After that, this was about two weeks of additional polish work to cut out a lot of fluff and a lot of the LLM-isms. Happy to answer any questions about the process too if that would be interesting to anybody.

412 points | 241 commentspage 4
nirav72 11 hours ago|
Thanks for sharing. This was an amazing read. I’d love to see novels with similar style stories about speculative near future tech and world.
andai 1 day ago||
I enjoyed this very much. But I have to wonder, was this written by Claude?

Edit: got it right!

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47419681

Stwerner 1 day ago|
Haha well it was me and Claude ;)
Syntonicles 1 day ago||
I wonder if it was de-indexed from HN for this reason.

30 minutes ago it was on the front-page, now I can't find it listed in the top 200.

Stwerner 1 day ago|||
Yeah I was wondering the same thing. I didn’t realize there was any kind of rule against this kind of stuff
pseudalopex 1 day ago||
There was another rule you did not know seemingly. Please don't use HN primarily for promotion. It's ok to post your own stuff part of the time, but the primary use of the site should be for curiosity.[1]

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

cluckindan 15 hours ago|||
And now it’s #1 on the front page.
tengwar2 1 day ago||
There's a bit of a tradition of introducing engineering ideas through stories. I remember a novella which was used to introduce something like MRP II (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_requirements_planning) in the 80's. One of the reasons I think it works is that it keeps a focus on the human elements - like why Tom fitted the switch in your story. I remember automating a lab system back in 1985, which would bring in £1000 per day. Two weeks later I found out that the reason it wasn't in use was that the user wanted an amber monitor rather than a green one. I fitted the switch.

I don't know if this is what the future will look like, but this looks realistic. And if my non-existent grandson starts re-coding my business without asking, he's going to spend the next six months using K&R C.

TrainedMonkey 14 hours ago||
I really enjoyed fantasy part of many small farmers. It felt rustic. However based on my understanding the modern world is moving towards megacorps and economies of scale.
gzread 5 hours ago|
Has moved.
fishbacon 4 hours ago||
The (very clearly AI-generated) watercolors were an immediate sign to be wary of this. But I read it because I liked the first paragraphs.

The prose is decent, I like the premise, thought provoking idea.

One issue though: I had to use firefox' reader mode, because the contrast between text and background was terrible.

dwd 12 hours ago||
That it was largely/mostly generated by Claude adds a certain poignancy to it.

As an allegory it reminds a lot of one I read as a teen: Joshua by Joseph Girzone. Not a literary masterpiece but a cleaver thought-raising story.

ethansinjin 1 day ago||
A fun read. I was hoping for the title to have some more relevance to the story, like someone who had handcrafted a piece of software and didn’t want others messing with it! Was that ever part of a draft?
Stwerner 1 day ago|
Ugh yeah, I had an aside about the right-to-repair fights still going on indefinitely into the future that I ended up cutting. I kept the title because it seemed like a warning the characters would see on everything they bought, even if they ignored it. I'm sure I'll explore the idea more in the future though, I plan to explore insurance and liability and law at some point too.
Havoc 17 hours ago||
This sort of article really needs at least a vague clue as to what it is about.

It's a long article and from skimming I see chat of farming, software, GPS. I can't tell whether this is worth investing time to read if I can't even tell what it may be about

acuozzo 17 hours ago||
It's speculative fiction.
SegfaultSeagull 17 hours ago||
[dead]
shermantanktop 16 hours ago|||
It's worth reading. It's about AI.
Supermancho 13 hours ago||
Having read most of it, I don't agree that it's worth reading. A bunch of made-up technical jargon and situations that never happened to frame specific problems that are part of the made-up situations using more jargon, in a farmer-centric area. It was a waste of time and a waste of concentration to try to make sense of it. There was no learning, nor was it worth quoting, nor comparing to anything else.
phyzix5761 15 hours ago||
[dead]
danhorner 13 hours ago|
I started reading this and it gave a strong whiff of Richard Stallman’s “the right to read” - once dystopian and now a commonplace.

Then I started scrolling and thought the author was just verbose like RMS.

When it just kept going I was just mad to have fallen into the AI tarpit.

Fun idea. 5x too long. I need to calibrate my ai spidey sense better.

More comments...