Top
Best
New

Posted by prefork 10 hours ago

Updates to GitHub Copilot interaction data usage policy(github.blog)
252 points | 119 commentspage 4
mt42or 10 hours ago|
Is it legal ? Surely not in any EU countries.
okanat 10 hours ago||
Does it even matter? They trained AI on obviously copyrighted and even pirated content. If this change is legally significant and a legal breach, the existence of all models and all AI businesses also is illegal.
0x3f 9 hours ago||
It might or might not be legal, but it seems materially worse to screw over your direct customers than to violate the social-contracty nature of copyright law. But hey ho if you're not paying then you're the product, as ever was.
mentalgear 10 hours ago||
At least one instance where it was enabled in EU countries as well.
TZubiri 10 hours ago||
If this doesn't sound bad enough, it's possible that Copilot is already enabled. As we know this kind of features are pushed to users instead of being asked for.

Maybe it's already active in our accounts and we don't realize it, so our code will be used to train the AI.

Now we can't be sure if this will happen or not, but a company like GitHub should be staying miles away from this kind of policy. I personally wouldn't use GitHub for private corporate repositories. Only as a public web interface for public repos.

djmashko2 10 hours ago||
> Content from your issues, discussions, or private repositories at rest. We use the phrase “at rest” deliberately because Copilot does process code from private repositories when you are actively using Copilot. This interaction data is required to run the service and could be used for model training unless you opt out.

Sounds like it's even likely to train on content from private repositories. This feels like a bit of an overstep to me.

semiinfinitely 9 hours ago||
ill be moving off github now
baobabKoodaa 10 hours ago||
(oops)
tech234a 10 hours ago|
It’s currently March
baobabKoodaa 10 hours ago||
Oops. Thank you for correcting me!
marak830 5 hours ago||
As it's enabled by default, does that mean everything has already been siphoned off and now I'm just closing the gate behind the animals escaping?

Shit like this shouldn't be allowed.

rvz 10 hours ago||
> From April 24 onward, interaction data—specifically inputs, outputs, code snippets, and associated context—from Copilot Free, Pro, and Pro+ users will be used to train and improve our AI models unless they opt out.

Now is the time to run off of GitHub and consider Codeberg or self hosting like I said before. [0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22867803

0x3f 9 hours ago|
Codeberg doesn't support non OSS and I'd rather just have one 'git' thing I have to know for both OSS and private work. So it's not a great option, IMO. Self-hosting also for other reasons.

I'm not sure there are any good GitHub alternatives. I don't trust Gitlab either. Their landing page title currently starts with "Finally, AI". Eek.

eipi10_hn 6 hours ago||
Maybe sourcehut? https://sourcehut.org
pugchat 4 hours ago||
[dead]
iam_circuit 5 hours ago||
[dead]
ComputeLeap 5 hours ago|
[dead]
More comments...