Top
Best
New

Posted by joering2 4 hours ago

Tell HN: Chrome says "suspicious download" when trying to download yt-dlp

On a newest version, I attempted to download newest yt-dlp only to be warned of "Suspicious Download". No explanation what that means was provided.
216 points | 65 commentspage 2
ddtaylor 3 hours ago|
Linux user here unaffected as I get it straight from my command line.
eis 4 hours ago||
Which link exactly did you try to use? Or what specific version on the Github releases page? I checked both the latest windows and macos versions against Google Safe Browsing and all were fine.
owlninja 3 hours ago|
I can't reproduce this either, OP is light on details.
uoaei 1 hour ago||
Chrome and YouTube are both owned by Google. There's an obvious reason why they want to discourage use of that extension.
NiloCK 3 hours ago||
Interesting to inspect any telemetry on this. Could end up on a list.
nnevatie 3 hours ago||
You wouldn't download a downloader.
waffletower 3 hours ago||
Chrome for work, Safari or Arc for everything else. I envy you if your use of yt-dlp is work related.
apparent 1 hour ago||
Why use Chrome when there's Brave? I can't remember the last time I opened Chrome.
iririririr 3 hours ago||
you almost got it rigth. safari and arc are as bad as chrome. arc is just stable-chrome (it will have the same nonsense with a custom ui next release)

firefox sadly is still what you should use.

LollipopYakuza 3 hours ago|||
I started giving a try to Zen (based on firefox) a few days ago. I like it especially while heavily relying on a tiling window manager.
johnthedebs 3 hours ago|||
Agree with sibling comment as someone who used Zen for many months, maybe as long as a year or two. It constantly breaks and often stays broken in small but fundamentally important ways, to the point that I just switched back to FF last week and am glad to be off the roller coaster. Before Zen I had tried Arc and left for a lot of the same reasons.

For all of the (valid) criticism against FF, it's still the best available browser that's not just an experiment IMHO.

Edit to add: part of the switch back is that FF now supports, to some degree, all the features I was using Zen for: vertical tabs (needs customization but works well enough), custom search "engines" (ie, shortcuts), split view, not-Chrome

jrajav 3 hours ago|||
I daily drove Zen for months. The design and implementation are overall fantastic. Unfortunately it still has chronic performance issues, gobbling up CPU randomly - and they don't seem to be too focused on despite it being a commonly reported issue.

I don't want to burn out my battery quicker than usual, so I was forced to switch off. I'm currently trying Orion instead and have been loving it - aside from several poorly implemented websites just not working on it. And the Cloudflare false positives, but that's as much or more an issue on Zen.

jrajav 3 hours ago|||
Why is Safari as bad as Chrome?
bigyabai 3 hours ago||
Website compatibility is inconsistent, extension compatibility is a slog, the desktop UI is confusing and nonstandard, WebKit itself is woefully incomplete, and on non-Apple platforms WebKit barely works covers conformance tests even with hardware acceleration disabled.

I don't use macOS anymore, but when I did I used Firefox without missing out on anything Safari would have given me. Now that I've abandoned macOS I don't think I can name one advantage of installing a WebKit browser on my system versus something Chromium-based.

sleepybrett 3 hours ago||
break this shit up, break all of this shit up.

Google needs to be at least what four companies.. gcp, youtube, search, workspaces...

Apple needs to be at least two hardware/os, music/tv+

Microsoft, meta, etc, Monopolies are bad and our SEC/FTC/Government is doing a poor job of controlling them. At least as equally trecherous are these businesses that overly vertically integrate... anyways, we're fucked.

rdevilla 4 hours ago|
It's over. The internet culture of the 20th and early 21st century has been appropriated for profit.
thesuitonym 3 hours ago||
No it's not, and no it hasn't. That old Internet is still there, you just stopped going to it.
rdevilla 3 hours ago||
[flagged]
throwaway_19sz 3 hours ago||
You are not under attack. It’s just someone disagreeing with you. Please keep things civil.
rdevilla 3 hours ago||
Where is the incivility? If anything it's coming from those who project their simplistic ideas of others unto the complexity of others' persons to pigeonhole them into their own idiosyncratic mental categories.
josteink 3 hours ago||
We built it on enthusiasm for enthusiasts and for that reason alone, it became something great.

Then they stole it all for profit.

Probably not the first time in history this has happened.

izzydata 3 hours ago|||
The amounts of times someone invented something that was important to them and then never make any money from it only for some other entity to make tons of money from it is way too high.
recursive 3 hours ago|||
And hopefully not the last