Top
Best
New

Posted by cdrnsf 10 hours ago

Thoughts and feelings around Claude Design(samhenri.gold)
249 points | 162 commentspage 3
peteforde 7 hours ago|
Honestly, I never understood the move to create an artificial dichotomy between design and code with a heavy layer of tooling.

I suppose that a layout engine made sense in the context of Flash, and you saw the future of the web as a set of keyframe animations. But the notion that there's a lot of value in creating a very heavy, high-friction abstraction between the UI/UX and the platform it ultimately runs on was always going to be a loser.

In the end, it turns out we're all just web developers, regardless of your weapon of choice.

xnx 6 hours ago||
Figma is going to regret not having sold to Adobe.
0xdyl 7 hours ago||
Can someone please help me understand why people are obssessing over this as a Figma killer and not, more clearly, a shot at Replit, Lovable, etc.?
operatingthetan 7 hours ago|
The AI app builders are part of the AI economy already. They are essentially re-selling tokens/compute. It's an existing horse race.

Bringing a Figma killer to the market is converting a conventional software sector into an AI one. So it's more disruptive.

nailer 4 hours ago||
I got deeper into Figma than I ever had to before yesterday.

It turns out there’s no way to use Math in variables built in to the product. The most common plugin is 99 dollars. To add what is obviously mustache JS. To browser based software. It’s not good.

thomasfl 7 hours ago||
I hope the authors mom is not on the internet. Cursing in capslock. Good grief.
i_love_retros 7 hours ago||
If you get to the post script it sounds like they are just pissed they didn't get hired by figma.
ghoulishly 4 hours ago|
I promise I am fine lol, I actually had a really productive chat with their panel last year and found it wasn’t the right role for me anyway for some logistical reasons.
slopinthebag 7 hours ago||
I feel like we're leaning way too much into the "vibe" aspect of using LLMs at the moment. There is definitely a good use case for LLM's here, but is just prompting your way into a design really the best method here? I feel like something in between Figma and Claude Design would give designers the control they want, but still removing the friction of going between design files and the code impl.
troupo 7 hours ago||
Oh no. Figma has variables and instances and it's hard to debug bad colors.

And here I am with Claude Code... That so far generated a 2000-line CSS file for a 7000-line app consisting of literally three web pages [1]. Where almost every single color, component, class and style is duplicated at least two times. Where custom classes are fighting with Tailwind classes (yes, there's also Tailwind ON TOP of custom CSS) that are fighting with inline hardcoded style= declarations.

Figma is definitely going to suffer the vibe-coded design slop-app from Anthropic.

[1] 7k lines are almost justified for the functionality in them, and I tried to keep an eye on the code. It's harder to keep an eye on CSS

zmmmmm 6 hours ago||
Have had similar dramas with CSS. Opus/Sonnet seem to have far less taste and discipline in writing CSS - constantly they are trying to slam in changes with !important or inline styles rather than think through how to do it properly.
cageface 3 hours ago|||
LLMs tend to do better with component libraries like shadcn or daisy than writing raw CSS in my experience.
bombcar 7 hours ago||
We can blame AI for slopcoding but it's just what we've been doing for decades now - who cares if it takes 9000 lines to do what in theory Linus and Knuth and Carmack could do in 3000? Our CPUs eat a million lines of code for breakfast and demand more.
troupo 7 hours ago||
Strange then that so many apps are barely usable on these powerful CPUs. Perhaps, CPUs can no longer demand more
johnwhitman 8 hours ago||
[dead]
jheriko 8 hours ago|
[dead]