Top
Best
New

Posted by zorrn 1 day ago

Changes to GitHub Copilot individual plans(github.blog)
492 points | 200 commentspage 2
october8140 2 hours ago|
So can I just have my credit card do a charge back? This fundamentally changes the thing I paid for.
pngwen 2 hours ago||
I wonder what this will mean for all of my students. I have been weaving copilot into my software engineering and code centric courses, but that depends on copilot pro as provided by the GitHub education package. If those signups are paused too, that means I can’t bring in any new ones, at least not to this stack. For me, I’ll probably have to send them to Claude code where they will have to pay for access. (Though it is a better product IMHO.)

This points toward a deeper issue though. We’ll probably see more individual offerings dry up over time. That means you’ll have individuals stuck with hand coding while the hyper productive AI assisted coders will all be at large organizations. If that happens, we’ll enter a phase where computing will once more be available exclusively to the elite few.

whatever1 12 hours ago||
All of the evidence shows that anthropic is dealing with a capacity crisis since February.

There are no good solutions for them.

If OpenAI is indeed overbuilt they will completely eliminate Claude.

diath 1 day ago||
I guess it makes more sense for me to just get Claude Pro instead. I was using my Copilot license only because of Opus 4.6 access as all other models seemed crippled in comparison in Copilot; does not even make sense to upgrade to Pro+ which goes from $10/mo to $40/mo and only gives you access to a model that has 7x the rate - 5x the limit at 7x the rate for 4x the price does not seem appealing at all.
girvo 15 hours ago|
Claude Pro no longer includes Claude Code
almyk 15 hours ago||
where have you read this? According to https://claude.com/pricing/pro it is included.
girvo 13 hours ago|||
According to https://claude.com/pricing it no longer is. They’ve explicitly updated that page to exclude it (it was on there before)
bwat49 12 hours ago||
its showing claude code as included in pro now on that page
girvo 11 hours ago||
Apparently if you believe them it was a “test”
sassymuffinz 10 hours ago||
A test to see if they could get away with it. I think we're really in the thick of token rationing right now and the fallout is going to be funny to watch.
Indian_in_US 14 hours ago|||
https://bsky.app/profile/edzitron.com/post/3mjzxwfx3qs2a
WhiteDawn 1 day ago||
I wouldn't mind this change that much if opus-4.7 worked properly in copilot cli. It keeps stopping mid-thought or task and forces me to waste more prompts for no observable reason.

Looks like I'm ending my subscription, good (likely too good, no way my account was even remotely within profitable range) access to opus-4.6 was the only reason I used this at all.

p1necone 1 day ago|
Are you using through regular copilot (the 'local' agent type), or through the separate claude agent type (which I believe you have to activate in your repository settings on github).

I had the exact same issues with the latter - randomly stops working, wipes chat history, just generally seems to be totally broken. But the former works totally fine and still lets you select sonnet/opus. My experience was before this recent 4.6 -> 4.7 change though.

WhiteDawn 12 hours ago||
Regular local agent. Seems like as soon as the context fills up (and it only has about 160k of context so that doesn't take much) it starts to fall to pieces. I even tried using opencode as a harness instead and it causes opus 4.7 to lose all memory every time I hit a compaction step.
rectang 1 day ago||
Welp. I already added a $20 Claude Pro subscription to complement my $10 Github Copilot Pro subscription and $10 DuckDuckGo Plus. That was partly to show support for Anthropic after the OpenAI/DOD episode, but also because I've been using Opus 4.5 exclusively with Copilot and I figured I should try Claude Code eventually.

Now it's going to cost me an upgrade to $39 Github Pro+ to keep using Opus, and even then it's with much higher multipliers. I don't fully understand the extent to which this reflects actual costs for Opus versus Microsoft leveraging network effects to discourage the usage of a competitor.

I didn't really want to wander outside of VSCode just yet because I was happy with VSCode/Copilot/Opus-4.5 and I don't want to spend all my time experimenting when stuff is changing so fast. But I guess my hand has been forced.

thecopy 1 day ago||
>$39 Github Pro+ to keep using Opus,

For what its worth, i have been paying for Pro+ and i still got locked out of Opus. I only have access to Opus 4.7 at 7.5x

diath 1 day ago||
> I didn't really want to wander outside of VSCode just yet because I was happy with VSCode/Copilot/Opus-4.5

This was my first thought too but apparently you can just use Claude Code within VSC: https://code.claude.com/docs/en/vs-code

codazoda 15 hours ago|||
You can also use Claude Code in a VS Code terminal window, which I much prefer for reasons I can’t quite put my finger on. Granted, I’ve moved to Zed in the past few months. I’m doing the same there.
rectang 1 day ago|||
I've started messing with this and the experience seems pretty similar.
shevy-java 4 hours ago||
Microslop, 'xcuse me, Microsoft is working hard to make github less and less appealing. It's a bit weird how an initially fairly good idea, over time becomes ... worse.
qaz_plm 1 day ago||
Worst part is them doing this mid-billing cycle and not at the start of the next in 11 days. I cancelled and requested a refund.
sovietmudkipz 1 day ago||
I cannot describe how disappointing it is to be switching to this insane time limit window based pricing. I absolutely abhor that I'll be subjected to 5 hour chunks of time where I'll be limited at some point in that window of time, and be told I'll have to wait. And then there is a weekly limit.

That's not how my creative energy works. I have time that I want to solve problems, and I want to solve them. I don't want a cooldown timer applied to solving a problem. Not to mention the anxiety of realizing that while I sleep I could have burned tokens in that time.

I'm incredibly disappointed when I sat down to my hobbyist programming time and realized copilot was suddenly and dramatically changed in a way that is incredibly disheartening.

Meter my token usage DON'T tell me when I can use them! ARGH.

toraway 15 hours ago||
Agreed. WTF is the point of offering a certain # of messages on each plan tier if you're then rate limited and can't even make full use of them?
ignoramous 7 hours ago|||
> Meter my token usage DON'T tell me when I can use them! ARGH.

Think GitHub will do that eventually, just like everyone else is. TFA ends with:

  The actions we are taking today enable us to provide the best possible experience for existing users while we develop a more sustainable solution.
xienze 13 hours ago||
> I'm incredibly disappointed when I sat down to my hobbyist programming time and realized copilot was suddenly and dramatically changed in a way that is incredibly disheartening.

Guess it’s time to rediscover the lost art of programming without an LLM.

walthamstow 1 day ago|
I'm not surprised at all. This was one of the most generous plans out there, offering frankly ridiculous pricing based on a single prompt regardless of turns taken or tokens used. I was subscribed for a month around Christmas and got a shitload of tokens out of Opus 4.5 for a measly $10.
More comments...