Top
Best
New

Posted by RubyGuy 19 hours ago

Do_not_track(donottrack.sh)
358 points | 114 commentspage 2
latexr 11 hours ago|
Same thing has been suggested a few years ago and it went nowhere.

https://web.archive.org/web/20200613155957/https://consoledo...

sneak 36 minutes ago|
It didn’t go nowhere; a few projects implemented it. The philosophical basis was wrong, though.

Opt out should not be encouraged via an off switch. It should be eradicated, and the people who accepted money to write such malware should be plainly named so that such actions can be part of their professional reputation.

sandeepkd 4 hours ago||
A GLOBAL do not track on the browsers works largely cause the target is all the websites being browsed and the tracking associated with it for advertising purposes. However telemetry is altogether a different thing, blocking it by default can be one idea, however using one standard variable to express the intent for all the tools is not practically viable
LeoPanthera 17 hours ago||
The most useful part of this page is the list of optout commands to stick in my shellrc.

Is anyone maintaining a more complete list of those?

paddw 17 hours ago|
an LLM would do a fine job for most common things, doesn't really matter if a few of them get hallucinated
0123456789ABCDE 16 hours ago||
just sinkhole the domains

https://dpaste.com/E7RZ34MVD

https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts

PunchyHamster 3 hours ago||
The reason browser's DNT header failed is that they don't want to user to turn off tracking by default

The reason they will not adopt common env is that because they do not want it to be easy to turn off

AndyMcConachie 3 hours ago|
The reason the DNT header failed is because there is no way to enforce it. The browser can set the flag, but there's no way to ensure it's actually respected. There are no protocol police.
CobrastanJorji 5 hours ago||
> We just want local software.

You just want local software to...send commands to your Cloud providers?

batisteo 17 hours ago||
It worked so well on the browser already
XCSme 17 hours ago||
I thought it would be a sh script to automatically set the flags for all known do not track env vars.
drayfield 17 hours ago||
Given the URL and list of different opt-outs I thought this was going to be a shell script to set all these for you. In fact, I've just had an idea...
SpyCoder77 16 hours ago|
Exactly what I was thinking.
0xbadcafebee 16 hours ago|
I don't think there is any way to stop people from tracking you. Technically speaking, you can pretty much always be tracked. Even if you eliminated all third party requests you could still be tracked. Downloads, logins, queries, etc all can be tracked. Virtually all software now has the "continuously upgrade to the latest version" bullshit so you are tracked every time you open the app. Even if you turn it off, they stop the app from working until you upgrade, so they force you to be tracked.

I think the only solution is to make it law that you can't track anyone for any reason without their consent, and can't sell consensual tracking data without an additional consent agreement. It would be a huge blow to the advertising industry, so it will never be made law, but it's the only thing that would work.

pizzly 15 hours ago||
Also every time you install a program Microsoft, Apple and Google knows depending on the device. For your safety of course. The tracking is so pervasive and the majority of people do not care.
slashdev 15 hours ago||
It’s already a law in Europe. GDPR and ePrivacy. You have to get consent from the user. Having worked for European companies, they take it seriously.
ezfe 12 hours ago||
The assumption that telemetry is not allowed by GDPR is flawed

https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-26/

xigoi 8 hours ago||
Anonymous telemetry is allowed – and I don’t have a problem with that.
0xbadcafebee 7 hours ago||
Unfortunately there's no such thing as anonymous telemetry. There are multiple techniques to re-identify scrubbed data, and some [seemingly innocuous] data is inherently identifying.

https://techcrunch.com/2019/07/24/researchers-spotlight-the-... | https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/11/debunking-myth-anonymo...

More comments...