Top
Best
New

Posted by maxloh 6 days ago

Trademark violation: Fake Notepad++ for Mac(notepad-plus-plus.org)
633 points | 304 commentspage 2
ares623 6 days ago|
(posting my comment from the other thread) Hilarious. How long does it take to vibecode the requests to change the logo and name. Vibecoding a port from scratch is super fast as long as you don't need permission huh. Then when the adults ask you to not infringe on copyright, it's all "please be patient guys. I am boy. Give me one week pls."
WesolyKubeczek 5 days ago||
I see a Russian name, I assume very cavalier approach to copyright and trademark laws, especially if it is about someone else's copyright or trademark. This heuristic has had enough nines for me to qualify as 100% accurate.

Source: having been in ex-USSR through all of 1990s and 2000s.

Lucasoato 5 days ago|
Trademark laws? Copyright? Private property? Comrade, you must have hit your head hard, now quick, get the shovel, we need to load the coal in another truck for the glory of the Soviet Union!
aethertron 5 days ago||
> "It actually expands notepad++ brand to mac"

> "My intention was to expand your brand."

Funny he thinks 'expanding' someone else's 'brand' is doing them a favour.

'I inflated your currency! There's more now, you should appreciate!'

KORraN 6 days ago||
Original announcement and discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47916964
redbell 5 days ago||
Visiting the referenced website (https://notepad-plus-plus-mac.org/), the first thing I see is a big, green Announcement that says:

  In coordination with Don Ho, the creator of the original Notepad++, I'll be evolving the branding of the macOS version so it stands on its own while respecting its lineage. These updates, such as a new logo, a refined name, and likely a new domain will ship with version 1.0.6 in the coming days. Continuity for existing users is a priority, and I'll make the transition as seamless as I can. Thank you for your patience.

Did Don Ho really coordinated with this author?! If no then why he lies and he knows he is lying? Where this path leads to?! Really weird times to be alive!!
sleepybrett 5 days ago|
coordination must mean, 'i've been threatened legally by'
f3408fh 6 days ago||
FFS. I installed it after seeing it here on HN and on MacRumors. Terrible failure on my part but MacRumors should offer an apology for endorsing this fake release.
AureliusMA 6 days ago||
This is such a blow for MacRumors... I won't be taking them seriously anymore after this. They are complicit.
dewey 5 days ago|||
A website that's specialized into running unconfirmed rumors for clicks, shocking!
ezfe 5 days ago||||
9to5mac writes clickbait headlines but MacRumors violates journalistic integrity. They always have been worse, there’s nothing new.
odie5533 6 days ago||||
The National Enquirer publishing rumors and gossip?! I'll never read them again!
layer8 5 days ago||||
You can’t take MacRumors seriously in that sense in general, they often distort their sources and barely do any journalistic due diligence. They are serviceable as a news feed for the sources they link to, and for the rumored-upcoming-features summary listicles.
f3408fh 6 days ago|||
Me neither. So far all I see is a puny "[Updated]" title on the article with no apology or indication of what was updated.
pndy 6 days ago||
An apology? That'd be... breaking news /s
nguyenkien 6 days ago|||
First thing I do is check official notepad++ website. I didn't see anything, that what's stop me.
f3408fh 6 days ago||
Smart. Good on you for noticing it wasn’t the real website.
0x000xca0xfe 5 days ago|||
Same with heise online, Germany's largest IT news site:

https://web.archive.org/web/20260430011533/https://www.heise...

j1elo 6 days ago||
I mean, the website is called "Rumors", so their reliability is in compliance with the letter of the contract :-)
Fokamul 5 days ago||
Anyone from Moody's, BNY, AxiomSL, Amex. Who knew "Andrey Letov" and can contact him on his personal email/phone to verify?

Author of Mac notepad github repo claims he worked there, https://aletik.me/ (1 month old personal website), he also has new Github and new Linkedin. https://github.com/aletik

If someone has reverse image search platform, use his github profile picture. There is another Linkedin profile, with same guy, but slightly different picture.

yokoprime 5 days ago||
I would not trust this "Notepad++ for Mac" at all. The author of the "port", aka Vibe Coded slop, Andrey Letov has absolutely zero commits anywhere before he suddenly vibes up this mac release. He brands it as an official Notepad++ version, is slimy in the way he interacts with the Notepad++ team etc. I would not be surprised if theres some sort of back door or malware attack vector embedded in this software. Stay away! Remember the XZ Utils backdoor!
amiga386 5 days ago||
Heck, even remember that state-level actors abused a flaw in NPP's update mechanism and hijacked NPP's hosting provider to deliver malware to specific targets: https://notepad-plus-plus.org/news/hijacked-incident-info-up...

There are a lot of NPP users out there, and probably the most important thing, given that they use it to edit all their files, is that they can trust the software. Some rando out of nowhere saying they've written "NPP for Mac" is red flag central.

ButlerianJihad 5 days ago|||
So would you say that the Notepad++ author got Letov with a technicality?
kaiwn 5 days ago||
This is so sloppy I really doubt this is an attempt at malware. It’s more likely the author is, uh, “socially unaware”.
bdcravens 5 days ago||
The Mac port is open source, and has rebranded:

https://github.com/nextpad-plus-plus/nextpad-plus-plus-macos

The name was a trademark violation, but the project appears to be compliant with the open source license used by Notepad++.

mobeigi 5 days ago|
I wish people wouldn't abuse the author of that project over this. Giving them the benefit of the doubt in that this was a mistake and not intentionally malicious, it feels really bad for hundreds if not thousands of people to send hate, insults, abuse to a single individual. Shame on the people who are doing that.
adamtulinius 5 days ago||
The only way you can consider this a mistake is by not having read the github comments here: https://github.com/notepad-plus-plus/notepad-plus-plus/issue...
kjs3 5 days ago||
I think you need to do a little more research before you give the poor, poor little author of 'that project' a pass.
More comments...