Top
Best
New

Posted by Timofeibu 4 hours ago

Not alive, but not dead: disembodied human brains used for drug testing(www.science.org)
122 points | 98 commentspage 2
WalterBright 3 hours ago|
There is a documentary about this:

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0052646/mediaviewer/rm713036545...

artursapek 1 hour ago||
A nice reminder to not check the "organ donor" box at the DMV
ckemere 3 hours ago||
The obvious question I would have asked: given the concern that this may not be ethical if the brains are still “alive” AND the concern that a brain separated from the body probably doesn’t function these same, why wouldn’t we test things in living monkeys (instead of mice)???

It seems that the likelihood is high that the right animal model would yield superior data???

jjk166 2 hours ago||
Let me add Johnny Got His Gun to the surprisingly large number of works that seem to anticipate exactly this premise.
acdbddh 3 hours ago||
To be honest, if my only other option was to be buried, I would love to let my brain be connected to some machine that try to keep it as alive-like as possible.

Just please don't remove my brain before I'm 1000% certainly dead.

bsimpson 1 hour ago||
This is precisely why I've never been interested in being an organ donor.

I don't remember where specifically I learned this, but I was taught that tissue has to be alive to be useful, so they harvest it when you're almost-dead. Having my last moments be being literally dismembered is not something I wish for my future self.

scratchyone 1 hour ago||
They will never remove tissue if you're still alive. This is the reason organ donation is most common in brain-death cases, because the tissue is still alive but you are entirely dead. As you point out, it would be horrible to dismember someone who is still alive and would certainly violate their oath.

I hope this is a comforting answer, I choose to be an organ donor because of these details.

saalweachter 3 hours ago||
To some extent, volunteering for any sort of medical study is signing up to be tortured in the hopes that someone down the line might be saved by the research. Most cancer treatments, for instance, are objectively terrible to go through, and when you're testing and developing the protocols you're pumping already sick people full of poisons and hoping for the best.

There's some fraction of people who would prefer to be kept alive as a brain in a jar, depending on the alternatives, but getting to that point is going to require a bunch of people to volunteer to undergo excruciating torture as we learn how to keep the brain alive, how to keep them comfortable, how to keep them conscious, sane and let them interact with the world.

aussieguy1234 1 hour ago||
Does this tech take us one step closer to a human brain in a robot body, or some kind of simulated reality?
akomtu 1 hour ago||
That's demonic creativity.
kypro 2 hours ago||
This is literally my biggest fear. The idea that my biology or consciousness could be keep alive and in a state of suffering for years, decades, centuries or longer via neural simulation or biological intervention.

I do wonder if AI advancements will allow me to see these horrors play out. Hopefully not to myself.

https://spikeartmagazine.com/articles/libra-season-hello-cru...

ReptileMan 2 hours ago||
They have no mouth and they must scream...
caconym_ 3 hours ago|
What the fuck? This is beyond the pale.
More comments...