Top
Best
New

Posted by sofumel 8 hours ago

We're testing new ad formats in Search and expanding our Direct Offers pilot(blog.google)
460 points | 395 commentspage 3
flohofwoe 5 hours ago|
So the same thing that ruined Google Search (replacing "knowledge search" with "product search") will now also ruin AI results. Got it (good riddance though).
zeafoamrun 6 hours ago||
I guess I'm used to seeing the english language being mangled by corp-speak but "creative" as a noun that doesn't even refer to a "creative" person (which also feels like a recent addition) really grates!
unsane 6 hours ago||
I had the same reaction, and checked dictionary.com.

This new meaning was there, with its only example relating to AI ads!

2. material made for advertising and other aspects of marketing, as a billboard, video ad, or web page design, or the activity of designing and producing it.

"In our latest campaign for a luxury services client, we used an AI platform to fine-tune creative based on user behavior."

Did AI make up this variant meaning and put it in the dictionary, and AI used the word in generating Google's article? What came first, the chicken or the egg? Regardless things are moving fast.

jpadkins 3 hours ago|||
ad creative (also just 'creative' for short in an advertising context) has been around since the 1960's. It was used in web banner advertising at its inception in the 1990s. Tribes have their own lingo, and language changes all the time. Sorry you don't like what the marketing tribe did more than 50 years ago.
xnorswap 6 hours ago|||
I thought "a creative" was the person who designs adverts, but I guess it's acting as a good filter, to filter out people like me, because I'm clearly not the target audience for this.
zeafoamrun 6 hours ago|||
You're on the right track, a creative makes creatives (to be included alongside google searches, obviously)
onionisafruit 5 hours ago||
My ask is that we not use creative as a noun
margorczynski 3 hours ago||
But who'll pay for those ads? Why would I pay Google if it just plops out some LLM answer with maybe my site as a source - which 90%+ of people will ignore as they don't care about it.
boldlybold 2 hours ago|
Is this any different than current search ads (as far as people ignoring them)? I think this is a lot better for Google. It's always at the top of the page, harder to block with an adblocker, possibly more trusted (we'll see...)
butz 2 hours ago||
Anyone made a LLM model that parses such text and removes ads? Ad blocking is getting more interesting.
cdrnsf 4 hours ago||
I've never bought anything from a search or social media ad. I can't imagine this will change that.
jillesvangurp 4 hours ago|
The reason advertising is such a big market, especially online, is that it actually delivers results for advertisers.

Traditional advertising was very indirect. You see ads. Some time later you make a buying decision. And you recognize the brand name that was advertised and you buy the branded thing. A click on an ad is just one of several ways in which an ad can convert for an advertiser.

Anyway, I use Firefox and it still has effective ad blocking. Even Amazon Prime which is supposed to have ads is showing ad free for me. I get these second long black transitions where they would have shown me an ad. Hilarious. Same with Youtube. No ads. But sometimes the black screen lasts for 20 seconds. Which is fine with me. I prefer that over some obnoxious ad.

bborud 3 hours ago||
And just when we thought Google couldn’t make themselves less attractive.
dzonga 5 hours ago||
we r now playing a game without winners well maybe except google or any of the large tech companies.

small businesses & brands etc spend a fortune on these ads & yet most of them see a negative ROI. they might as well be gambling.

just recently Google was found to be inflating Ad-prices (so yeah the 'auction' is fake)

maybe the only way to win is not to play. & do commerce without ads like how it has been done since eon

netcan 6 hours ago|
Google might be jumping the gun here... and making an innovators dilemma type mistake.

LLMs are an alternative to search engines, which endangers google's whole ad business.

"AI mode" search is a sort of bridge. It gets Gemini a lot of customers that otherwise would not have used an LLM at all.

They may get stuck trying to keep the llm pattern similar enough to the search engine that the adwords business working more or less the same way.

This could be self limiting.

More comments...