Top
Best
New

Posted by garycomtois 3 hours ago

Please Use AI(shawnsmucker.substack.com)
599 points | 267 commentspage 3
faangguyindia 2 hours ago|
I know a few guys here who were doing sysadmin, devops, frontend jobs for a few years in India and now they are driving a taxi in India.

AI took their job. There have been mass layoffs by foreign companies in India; fewer outsourcing contracts are flowing to India.

As a result, many service companies are moving to product businesses.

ChrisMarshallNY 2 hours ago|
> fewer outsourcing contracts are flowing to India.

That's not necessarily because of AI. The trend has been going downward for some time, anyway.

Outsourcing has drawbacks; usually ones that aren't apparent, until it has been in place for a while (I won't go into what they are, because this isn't really the proper venue, and I don't feel like arguing). I think that many companies have been learning about these drawbacks, in the last few years.

But AI is likely to impact some (not all) jobs that would normally be offshored.

nathanfig 2 hours ago||
I've been pondering the question: "What does it mean to live well with AI?"

We are certainly scrambling for productivity with "token maxxing" and scrambling for entertainment with AI companions, but I haven't seen many thoughtful takes on how AI might look in a life well-lived.

skydhash 2 hours ago|
Even though I spent the majority of my work day with computers, my fascination with them starts and stops on understanding how they work. Aside from that, they’re only utilitarian. What I really like to do is grab a nice book, put on some nice album to listen too, and enjoy a quiet night with my SO. If not for the fact that it’s easier to get books and music in digital format where I live, I’d spend even less time with computers.
nathanfig 1 hour ago||
Yeah it's entirely possible the answer is: "You don't." But I haven't even seen people attempting to imagine life well-lived. Like with so much technology it's basically an afterthought.
jdw64 2 hours ago||
I am truly envious of people who have the luxury of a supportive environment that allows them to write a post like this.

For my first dev job, I was made to set up a sole proprietorship just so the company could illegally dodge minimum wage and severance. I didn't get mentored; I learned through constant abuse. It was only when I first used AI that I realized the people around me were teaching me garbage and my books were completely obsolete.

I envy that this person was surrounded by people who cared. Before AI, trying to learn programming just meant dealing with insults. They can stay in touch with their network because they were respected. I had zero people in my environment for intellectual discussions or programming.

It really shows how your environment shapes your relationship with tools. I have a love-hate dynamic with AI. It frustrates me that my manual coding skills are degrading, but I'm incredibly thankful for the easy access to knowledge I never had. At the end of the day, reading this just makes me envy those who get to live and work in a warm, respectful setting.

g-b-r 1 hour ago|
Buddy, I have no idea what happened you, but I never heard someone linking learning programming to insults.

It seems unlikely to have happened to anyone else, ever.

"Before" AI there was internet, and before that often just your room, your computer, and tinkering with it for years before meeting anyone else with the same interest.

And trust me that there are many books better than AI.

I'm sorry for your experience, anyhow

jdw64 1 hour ago||
[dead]
zug_zug 1 hour ago||
I mean I get it hits you in the feels... but at the same time... DO talk to your friends, but then use AI too?

Like I don't want to say it's a strawman exactly, because some people probably do use AI too much. But it's a really emotional (and not exactly logical) play to emotions that sort of implies don't use AI at all, which I don't agree with.

Like if you're writing a speech for my wedding, please do a sanity check against AI before saying a really crass or risky joke. Because some of us have those maybe-on-the-spectrum acquaintances and AI actually can be a great sanity check for those people.

iainctduncan 1 hour ago||
Lots of "but I don't have those friends" replies here....

..which is only going to get worse the more you rely on a statisical model for things instead of talking to people.

elliotbnvl 2 hours ago||
Though I deeply agree with this sentiment, the author fails to address that there can be multiple goals to an action. And writing can be for art or communication or both but not always both, and removing the art from communication doesn’t destroy its ability to communicate.
jimbokun 1 hour ago|
No, I think it does.

The only purpose of communicating is to transmit your thoughts to one or more other people.

If the thoughts are the thoughts of the AI, you are not communicating anything.

postalcoder 2 hours ago||
I agree with this sentiment.

I've seen other parents create AI videos of their toddlers being visited at night by Santa. I've seen parents happily throw their children into AI video generators to entertain them.

People are using AI recklessly. I can't imagine stealing the gift of a child's imagination away from them and instead, replacing it with these hollow representations of reality. It disgusts me.

I use AI all the time for coding, but I've drawn a hard line at the point of intermediation with others.

jimbokun 1 hour ago|
Yep, we all thought giving young kids was "helping them learn to use computers to be ready for the future" too.

Some people learned that lesson and are now pushing back on letting their kids access AI. But not everyone.

alf42red 1 hour ago||
After skimming through this, I want to write a post about how others are living their lives wrong. It must really feel great to be right about things on the internet. How do I start? I guess I'll just ask AI ...
g-b-r 1 hour ago|
8 years after making that account you finally decided to use it to write that, congratulations
bob001 2 hours ago||
Please use books.

Please use the internet.

Please use search engines.

Please use AI.

Everything old is good and everything new is evil. The irony of this being posted online in written form is lost on the author. Socrates would probably have an aneurysm.

yanis_t 2 hours ago|
Be sure to use a mobile phone when making your next, I don’t know, meal plan, for example. Definitely do not come in person to your friend who loves to cook and ask her for her favorite recipes or tips or ways to save time making meals
draftsman 1 hour ago||
You’ve either willfully ignored the point, or completely missed it as it flew over your head. AI wants to replace “your friend” completely.
bigfishrunning 2 hours ago||
You've missed the point. You're describing replacing a method of communication, the poem describes replacing a relationship.
yanis_t 2 hours ago||
Right, but why attacking AI specifically? I just don’t buy the example, she could use a book with recepies instead of calling her friend, right? Maybe she just doesn’t want to call her friend this time, you know, and maybe it doesn’t make her less human.
More comments...