Top
Best
New

Posted by predkambrij 8 hours ago

Anthropic, please ship an official Claude Desktop for Linux(github.com)
368 points | 204 commentspage 4
rtk_asp 5 hours ago|
"Sources for the load-bearing claims"

I no longer know if this is a real person who is simping for Anthropic and will be ultimately enslaved by Anthropic or if this is an Anthropic ad to have "proof" for the high demand of their services.

applfanboysbgon 4 hours ago|
Neither, it is just a random LLM-generated issue.
zombot 4 hours ago||
It it was an LLM, why didn't it just vibecode the desired software instead of generating ticket spam?
pixl97 2 hours ago||
Because using cheap LLMs to spam GH is way less expensive than fixing software with SOTA models.
2OEH8eoCRo0 5 hours ago||
I love the dueling messages on AI

"It'll make software easy and replace all software jobs!"

"Sorry, a Linux client is too hard and too much work!"

pixl97 2 hours ago|
Interesting take away, but one that I'd think is intrinsically wrong.

The Linux desktop is fragmented and gatekept in such a manner that most people of a reasonable mind aren't going to waste tokens on it, and damned sure not going to waste software/support engineer time on it.

Note that none of these complaints are about CLI or server software. "Linux" the kernel + GNU utils + shell handle all of this just fine. The year of the Linux desktop is just never going to happen unless one desktop standard takes over and 'wins' in the short to medium term.

Now, in the longer term when tokens run cheap maybe we'll successfully have 20 different competing, incompatible Linux deskstops, but it doesn't seem likely.

trumpdong 5 hours ago||
Doesn't Wayland make it impossible anyway?
monooso 5 hours ago|
In what way?
trumpdong 4 hours ago||
In the way of eschewing all the APIs that allow an X11 client to control your desktop.
dahkenangnon 8 hours ago||
We are all waiting for it.
dstnn 6 hours ago||
You're better off just using code cli
coretx 7 hours ago||
Why dont you ask Claude to write you a TUI ?
cyanydeez 7 hours ago||
Why would they do that with their...checks notes...software changing AI?
gaiagraphia 6 hours ago|
Anthropic one-shotting a Linux distro would be quite the ad...

Perplexity are devleoping Comet as an AI-powered browser. I wonder if anybody will take the OS leap.

JohnHaugeland 7 hours ago||
just use WINE or docker
syllogistic 7 hours ago|
> Just use WINE

Did you just tell me to go fuck myself ?

xdavidliu 7 hours ago||
pull requests are welcome
LoganDark 3 hours ago||
"Linux" is not an operating system. One does not "just" release something "for Linux"
the__alchemist 2 hours ago|
Inded. But... Let's say by compiling for Windows and MacOS you are making it work on 80% of users' computers. Then you compile on an older Ubuntu version which will work on any newer Ubuntu or Debian system, and you're at 90%. Worth doing. Then you do a Centos/RH build to get to 95%.

This won't work for all Linux users, but that doesn't have to be the bar. Making a few linux builds for the most popular distros is incrementally better than saying it's Windows/Mac only.

shevy-java 5 hours ago|
Please don't.

There is already way too much slop.

More comments...