Top
Best
New

Posted by apitman 20 hours ago

I admire Fabrice Bellard. He is almost certainly a better overall programmer(twitter.com)
https://xcancel.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/2064095424420487226
847 points | 416 commentspage 6
latexr 17 hours ago|
I’m asking genuinely: What’s the point of linking to Carmack’s tweet? The intellectual curiosity (what HN is ostensibly about) is all in the quoted tweet (despite it being written like an LLM trained on LinkedIn posts). Carmack isn’t really adding anything of importance or interest. Linking to him feels a bit cult of personality, as if Bellard is deserving of attention because Carmack gave some vague praise with qualifiers. Why not link directly to the quoted tweet, or even the Wikipedia page?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fabrice_Bellard

Surely we are all capable of understanding Bellard’s contributions and judge them on their own merits without needing some famous programmer to point directly at it and saying “this good”.

menaerus 16 hours ago||
The tweet also reads a bit off to me too. Carmack positions himself as if he is a some sort of a litmus test for being a great and successful programmer, which I don't doubt that he is but it's a bit strange. Egotripping.
Capricorn2481 7 hours ago||
If most people would agree with that, is it really egotripping?
latexr 10 hours ago||
This has gotten a ton of upvotes, then a ton of downvotes. Yet no one has yet answered the question. If you are downvoting, presumably you believe there is a point to linking to Carmack’s tweet. That it somehow adds more value than the alternative. So please explain why. Like I said before, I am asking genuinely.
shevy-java 18 hours ago||
Fabrice is kind of like a space explorer. He goes where few people went before.

I think I first noticed this either with regard to JSLinux, or possibly some software he wrote before that; don't fully remember which year. It's like some people go deliberately to more unique problems with regards to software that actually works in achieving that outcome, whatever the outcome may be.

streaming 6 hours ago||
[dead]
123sereusername 9 hours ago||
[dead]
willXare 7 hours ago||
[dead]
huflungdung 18 hours ago||
[dead]
ergl 14 hours ago||
[flagged]
thunderbong 14 hours ago|
Why don't you click on the xcancel link and read the whole thing?
stymaar 14 hours ago||
The whole slop you mean?
self_awareness 16 hours ago||
Fabrice Bellard is the actual greatest programmer that has ever lived.

Carmack's "almost certainly" doesn't look good here.

dude250711 16 hours ago|
The actual greatest programmer is the one who gets compensated according to their output.
kergonath 13 hours ago|||
What does it have to do with compensation? Creativity for creativity’s sake is also important. Not everyone spends their life chasing dollars.
self_awareness 15 hours ago|||
No, that's a regular programmer.
j3th9n 16 hours ago|
#howtomakethisaboutme "Almost certainly better than I am", eff off Carmack.
More comments...