Top
Best
New

Posted by arunc 4 hours ago

Anthropic updates their terms to verify age or identity(www.anthropic.com)
184 points | 162 commentspage 3
lnenad 4 hours ago|
I was really hoping we’d have more time before enshittification arrived. But apparently, an old Xeon running Qwen is my destiny.
Azantys 4 hours ago|
+1
CrzyLngPwd 3 hours ago||
Reason #1 why I won't be working with their stuff.
ChrisArchitect 3 hours ago||
[dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48618455
onesandofgrain 4 hours ago||
So in practise this means I need to upload my passport to continue using the CLI and the chat?
andrewstuart 4 hours ago||
If programming requires LLM/AI then regulation by government is needed to stop this overreach, which has the primary goal of banning you permanently forever making sure you can never come back to programming, in the event some AI in their system decides you have done something “wrong”.
nosioptar 3 hours ago|
Agreed.

Fortunately for all, clankers aren't required at all to program.

baq 3 hours ago|||
They aren’t, but we’re riding an exponential here. It’s like saying ‘you can still build a computer out of transistors’ in 1976 - as true and irrelevant today as it was then.
thelonelyborg 3 hours ago||
this was inevitable
moogly 3 hours ago||
Hmm, is this a thing for enterprise accounts too? My employer has gone all-in on Claude, but if I get a pop-up that requires me to give my ugly mug to a literal cardinal enemy of the human race Peter Thiel, then I will have to seriously consider switching jobs, because I have some of them silly principles.
timmg 4 hours ago||
They probably don't have much, I guess.
etchalon 4 hours ago||
I should be worried about this, but Anthropic's products are a paid product. You can't use them without providing some identifying information, unless you're going out of your way to provide them inaccurate information.

I generally dislike services which require this level of identity verification but also, so far, those have mostly been freemium services and community tools. And I dislike gating those communities.

I'm sure I should have more of a problem with this.

D2OQZG8l5BI1S06 4 hours ago|
I have no problem paying my groceries with my credit card, but I'd rather not give them a copy of my passport...
Tangurena2 3 hours ago|||
The British company doing age verification for Discord got hacked and the hackers got about 70k user identity documents. Discord claimed that the scanned documents would be deleted after verification. Surprise! They were not deleted at all.

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2025/oct/09/hack-age-verif...

lucasban 3 hours ago||||
What about a signed attestation of your identity based on your passport? I don’t particularly want a future where we need to present ID for any online service, but for certain high-risk services (e.g. financial services, medical records, government portals) I’d rather a proper identity system than cobbling something like this together.

As an aside, when traveling internationally it’s not uncommon to need to provide your passport information if you want to get a sales tax rebate. I’ve never purchased something expensive enough abroad to bother with it.

etchalon 3 hours ago|||
I'd have a problem with that too. In fact, I'd have a problem not being allowed to use cash.

I am deeply inconsistent on this.

micromacrofoot 4 hours ago|
that's what my credit card is for
ceejayoz 4 hours ago|
Credit cards don't validate age. I set my kids up with authorized user cards when they started going out with friends.
onepointsixC 4 hours ago|||
Maybe they should. It would be far less intrusive for venders who wish to sell age restricted goods to simply have it built in like that.
ceejayoz 4 hours ago||
You want to let every merchant I swipe my card at know my age? To improve privacy?
galleywest200 3 hours ago|||
No, the assumption is that you must be 18 years old to apply for a credit card. Surely we could have the machines determine that an "authorized user card" does not guarantee 18+ but the actual card does.
nairboon 3 hours ago||||
They don't need to know the exact age. But if kids couldn't get credit cards... then possession of a credit card would be a proof of adulthood.
ACCount37 3 hours ago||||
An absence of "this user is underage" flag would be good enough. Less than 1 bit of private information leaked by transaction.
scottlamb 3 hours ago|||
ceejayoz> You want to let every merchant I swipe my card at know my age? To improve privacy?

Remember the site guidelines:

SG> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize.

The obvious solution is instead of "every transaction comes with the user's birthday", the vendor can in some way set a minimum age enum of say (13, 15, 18, 21, 25) — a handful of ages that are significant with respect to some law or regulation. Then the transaction succeeds or fails.

micromacrofoot 3 hours ago|||
neither does my face but that isn't stopping them, so what exactly are we doing here
ceejayoz 3 hours ago||
Isn't the face scan intended to validate your passport, which you show, and does demonstrate age and identity?
micromacrofoot 3 hours ago||
haha wait they ask for passports too?
ceejayoz 2 hours ago||
The Fable shutdown requires them to limit access to US citizens.
More comments...