Top
Best
New

Posted by Audiophilip 2 days ago

Thomann takes legal action against Fender(www.thomann.de)
203 points | 140 commentspage 3
DDayMace 2 days ago|
[dead]
ben7799 2 days ago||
I play guitar, I own a Fender guitar and a Fender amp, along with another non-fender amp and 2 other non Fender guitars.

I'm just super sick of hearing about this story. Guitar players online are way too worked up about this. Fender is being annoying, but there is no way I'm getting rid of my Fender guitar or amp over this, and there is no way any of this would stop me from buying another one.

The Fender shapes just don't need to be copied at all. I live near a famous boutique type shop. They may have some boutique guitars that rip off the shapes of Fenders, it's been tolerated, but they have a lot of guitars that don't rip off Fender shapes and many of them are really great guitars.

Too many players are acting like the sky is falling if Fender wins with any of this stuff. The sky is not going to fall. We'll go back to the way things used to be where Fender body shapes weren't ripped off so often and it will be fine.

I think some of the doom and gloom is also because too many players are super obsessed with buying more and more guitars all the time. It's all about what is the next purchase as opposed to just enjoying the guitar they have.

Aboutplants 2 days ago||
Fender has seen quality deteriorate to extremely concerning levels in the past 5-10 years, ask any luthier. That frustrated players and now this is icing on the cake as competition has surpassed them in quality and in value and now they come beating them up since they are seeing their piece of the marketplace get smaller.
ben7799 2 days ago||
I've been playing long enough that I disagree.

Fender's quality is very good now compared to when I started playing.

But so is everyone else's.

grayhatter 2 days ago|||
It's really impressive how you could apparently argue so strongly for Fender's defense: but the message that I took away was Fender is obviously the bad guy in this story, and I want nothing to do with them... and I haven't even clicked on the new tab for the story yet.
levicole 2 days ago|||
I'll take my Suhr "Strat" over any American made Strat any day, as well as my hand wired boutique amp over any pro reverb (new or vintage).
ben7799 2 days ago||
But would you have refused to buy that guitar if it looked a little more different than a Fender Stratocaster?

You clearly aren't bothered by it having a different headstock shape, Suhr could and probably will just change the body shape a little bit and it would be fine.

Ibanez sells tons of guitars like this. They're double cutaway guitars that are kind of similar to the Stratocaster shape, but they are uniquely different and still loved.

The weirdest thing is someone who hates Fender and won't buy a Fender but simultaneously demands that their guitar looks so close to a Fender that it would be in danger of infringing.

nemomarx 2 days ago||
the shape is in the public domain though? it would be like trying to patent a rounded rectangle, it's inherently silly
hettygreen 2 days ago|
F*ck em - let them have that body shape. Seriously at this point do we need more stratocaster shaped guitars?

There's so many cool companies doing unique body shapes, if you're gonna take the time to build a guitar why not put some thought into the design?