Top
Best
New

Posted by ytkimirti 6 hours ago

Show HN: I made Google Trends for Hacker News by indexing 18 years of comments(hackernewstrends.com)
548 points | 137 commentspage 3
Insanity 4 hours ago|
This looks quite nice! But suspiciously absent data points.. no Java or Go for the languages? Seems odd. No Amazon in companies, yet I think it's often mentioned.

I wondered if "go" got filtered out because it's also just a regular word.

Either way, very cool!

cloudkj 5 hours ago||
This is great, I was just hoping to find a tool like this and specifically scoped to "Show HN" posts? Is there a way to do that?
ytkimirti 5 hours ago|
Great idea actually, I'll add that as well for sure
scarecrw 5 hours ago||
Very cool!

I'd love to have some sort of normalization option to separate more subtle positive trends from the general increase in number of posts.

aberrahmane_b 3 hours ago||
Great project.The popular comparisons are probably the most useful part because they show the relay race between tools pretty clearly.

One thing I’d like to see is normalization by total HN activity over time.

chfritz 4 hours ago||
great idea! Now, you are running into the same issue Google Trends had to solve: term disambiguation. For instance, "atom" is ambiguous in a comparison of editors like this: https://hackernewstrends.com/?q=sublime&q=atom&q=vscode. Given LLMs it might be possible to use an embedding vector (with context) instead of a text string for indexing, and if you do, this problem might go away.
jasonjmcghee 1 hour ago||
Terms with spaces seem to be an "or"
ytkimirti 5 hours ago||
We had to take the site down for a second, it'll be online in a few minutes. Thanks for trying it out
linzhangrun 4 hours ago||
Great job! I've also been wanting to do similar statistics recently, wanting to know when LLMs becoming the absolute dominant topic on HN. Now it seems like half of the posts were about LLMs.
jazzpush2 3 hours ago||
This is a great project. It'd be fun to look at some of the more popular startups over time, both those that ended up successful and those that didn't.
corv 4 hours ago|
The 'flash vs html5' chart looks strange juxtaposed with that conclusion
al_borland 4 hours ago|
There are a few technologies with pretty generic names which don’t lend themselves so well to this kind of trend analysis.

I was curious about Atom. According to the trend it’s still neck and neck with VS Code. But are people really talking about Atom the text editor that much still, or other types of atoms?

fg137 4 hours ago|||
I think Google Trends is actually smart enough to suggest which topic you want to see for the same keywords -- it understands the semantics.
linmer 3 hours ago|||
I think atom is no longer being developed, so it must not be a that popular topic. is that what you meant?
al_borland 2 hours ago||
That’s my assumption, yes.
More comments...