Top
Best
New

Posted by jvilalta 2 hours ago

Ask HN: What surprised you about Estonia e-Residency and running an Estonian OÜ?

From the official information online, joining the e-Residency program and setting up an Estonian company seems relatively straightforward.

I'm considering using an Estonian OÜ for a SaaS business and would love to hear from people who have actually gone through the process.

What surprised you after becoming an e-resident and establishing your company? Were there recurring costs, compliance requirements, banking/payment issues, tax complications, or other operational challenges you didn't anticipate?

How easy has it been to run the company remotely? Have you ever needed to travel to Estonia to resolve an issue?

Looking back, would you do it again? What do you wish you had known before getting started?

I'd appreciate any lessons learned, gotchas, or advice from current or former e-residents.

67 points | 58 comments
ExpertAdvisor01 1 hour ago|
Useless + overhyped .

Company will end up as tax resident from the country where it is managed & controlled .

If there is an DTA the tie breaker rule applies and the country from where it is managed & controlled gets the right to tax .

Also you get to enjoy bureaucracy+ dual accounting in both countries .

If there is no DTA it can lead to double taxation .

And if you don't have a fixed place of management/business+ tax residency (basically nomading) a US LLC disregarded for tax purposes is a much better fit .

penpendian 51 minutes ago||
There is no cake will drop from sky, and if there is, well it came with gravity
edoceo 1 hour ago||
Username checks out.
ttoinou 2 hours ago||
I was surprised how amazing it is ?

  What do you wish you had known before getting started?
Your yearly financial data is public, everyone will know your income / profit. And you will get spammed, your email will be public too.

  How easy has it been to run the company remotely?
Great

  Have you ever needed to travel to Estonia to resolve an issue?
Only visited once to open bank account LHV but I closed it since then and can use remote banking

  Looking back, would you do it again?
Yes
gdotdesign 1 hour ago|
Same experience for me, it's been great!

I never needed to visit since I could use Wise for banking.

The only thing is that surprised me was the tax rate, when I created my Company the advertised rate was 20/80 but in reality it was ~25/75 and it increased since.

atlasunshrugged 1 hour ago|||
Yes, it was stable for a long time but has been changing mainly due to factors associated with the war in Ukraine (spikes in inflation, especially related to energy prices as well as a need for increased defense spending)
m00dy 1 hour ago|||
Wise is not a bank.
atlasunshrugged 1 hour ago||
Its been a few years but I ran BD for the program in '19-'20 -- I would say that people underestimate the difficulty in shutting down the company if that needs to happen, sometimes getting access to a proper bank account can be annoying, and don't always understand the tax implications (ex. if I was resident in Germany, all my customers were in Germany, but I tried to run everything through this Estonian biz and pay taxes only there, that could very well cause you lots of issues/complications).

Also, shameless plug for people broadly interested in the country of Estonia and how it became a leader in e-gov/tech only a generation after independence from the Soviet Union, I wrote a book about it after being curious myself! https://www.rebootinganation.com/

Gys 1 hour ago||
Please beware:

From: https://learn.e-resident.gov.ee/hc/en-gb/articles/3600007215...

> Corporate tax residency

> However, some countries have different rules for deciding if a company is tax resident. It is common that, in addition to the place of incorporation, the place of effective management can trigger tax residence. If you run your company from a country with regulations like this, then the company may end up having dual tax residence. This happens when two states believe that the company is tax resident in their jurisdiction and will want to tax the company’s profits.

This 'It is common that [...] the place of effective management can trigger tax residence' is indeed common.

logifail 1 hour ago||
Hence the executives/boardmembers-all-fly-to-some-island (Jersey is the one in my mind), have board meeting in the airport, sign the papers, and all fly home?

Company stays "in" Jersey, none of the humans need to live there?

Swinx43 1 hour ago|||
That is unfortunately not how it works. Most commonly the place from which decisions are made on a day to day basis is used. This results in the country in which 50% or more of your directors reside for 183 days a year.

So if 50% or more of your directors spend 183 days per year in the UK then your Estonian based business becomes UK tax resident in the eyes of the UK.

Do not underestimate the complexity of these rules.

Gys 54 minutes ago||||
If the company is managed 'day by day' by a local director (for example by a company like Intertrust or Trustmoore) then the non-local board and/or shareholders can indeed flyin to have 'a meeting with extensive discussions where all decisions where made and some papers were signed'. I had a company in Singapore for some years doing this.
graemep 1 hour ago|||
That does not work necessarily work in the UK anymore.
jocaal 1 hour ago||
Also estonian law doesn't recognize trusts, so if you want to save your assets for your children that's a problem.
victorbjorklund 1 hour ago|||
I assume we are taking about a foreign trust and not an Estonian one. In what regard? When it comes to money laundering? Profit distributions?
ExpertAdvisor01 1 hour ago|||
You mostly use foundations for that purpose in civil law countries (which are also not part of the hague trust convention )
hakanderyal 1 hour ago||
UK, USA and Singapore are the popular choices for this. UK is simple and cheaper, Singapore is a bit more expensive. I don’t see a reason to go USA route unless you are seeking investment from there.

I’m using UK myself. It takes a few forms and half a day to get a working Wise/Stripe account.

jvilalta 55 minutes ago||
None of those countries are in the EU, which is important for my use case.
Onavo 1 hour ago||
Finally somebody who knows their stuff. I never understood why people preferred Estonian incorporation given that it's almost certainly more expensive and less convenient than the other options.
atlasunshrugged 1 hour ago|||
I think the main reason is to have a business incorporated within the EU if that's relevant for the person. Delaware is great, and UK filled this role until Brexit but after that if you needed an EU incorporated company it was a massive pain basically everywhere except Estonia which was relatively cheap and everyone in the industry speaks English
jvilalta 53 minutes ago|||
This is indeed the main reason for the question, and for the reasons you mention.
Onavo 1 hour ago|||
Your username is cool
atlasunshrugged 1 hour ago||
Ha, thank you!
victorbjorklund 1 hour ago|||
Its for sure over hyped but its not useless. Its nice that you can reinvest the profits within the company and only pay taxes on distribution (if this works of course depends on where the owner is. But at least in Sweden it works).
dgellow 2 hours ago||
Where are you located? Where will you administer the company from? That impacts your tax situation quite a lot.

See https://www.e-resident.gov.ee/understanding-cross-border-tax..., look for “Permanent Establishment”

jvilalta 1 hour ago|
I am in the US currently, would be managing initially from the US. I understand there will be US tax complications, but I can/would deal with those.
atlasunshrugged 1 hour ago|||
I saw this a lot when I ran BD for the program (I'm also an American) and its good you know there will be US tax complications but I would say that unless you expect to 1) have many EU customers and 2) working remotely globally and redomicile elsewhere so you are not considered US tax resident that it probably doesn't make more sense than using something like Stripe Atlas to just set up an LLC or C-Corp
jvilalta 57 minutes ago||
The point is serving EU customers as a EU company yes.
Gys 47 minutes ago||||
Unless you have some specific reason for being in the EU, I suggest you also look into Singapore.
ExpertAdvisor01 1 hour ago||||
The worst thing you could do as an us citizen (I assume ) and resident is to incorporate outside of the US.
jvilalta 49 minutes ago||
I can think of worse things myself.
pyvpx 1 hour ago|||
This is a terrible idea. please hire a professional with direct experience on these matters and not blog posts from influencers
jvilalta 58 minutes ago||
Any suggestions or alternative ways to setup a EU company remotely in your extensive experience and wisdom?
wayneshng 1 hour ago||
It has been a great experience. Setting up the company was online, and it took 3 days, including the time spent to change the name because the initial name was rejected. You can use Wise for banking, but LHV is also visible but there is an account limit if you don’t live there. Accounting is easy, but you will need an accountant for tax reporting if you have a VAT ID. My accountant charges me 60 euros per month and does an amazing job.
forks 1 hour ago||
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47500239
mhog_hn 1 hour ago||
Any tips for a 2 person European company. One founder based in Amsterdam, the other in London. We are close to setting things up, some input from other founders would be great
ExpertAdvisor01 1 hour ago||
Probably a UK limited liability partnership would be an option .

But you have to investigate how the Dutch will treat it .

You could apply for a advance tax ruling with the Dutch tax authorities before doing anything

HatchedLake721 1 hour ago||
Why LLP over Ltd?
ExpertAdvisor01 55 minutes ago||
Because it's transparent so you pay income tax ( which is lower than corp+dividend taxes especially at lower incomes ) .

Later on when you scale, you can convert the LLP into an LTD.

Also you might avoid exit taxes as it is an partnership , if you move between countries.

Also there is basically no information in the post besides 2 founders in different countries.

euph0ria 59 minutes ago||
Incorporate in one of the two countries. If you're serving EU, with GDPR it might be easier to do Netherlands instead of the UK.
poly2it 2 hours ago|
Question: are OÜs particularly beneficial even for non-Estonians (EU), and in what way?
jvilalta 1 hour ago|
I can't speak about all EU countries, but the one country I looked into (Spain), I couldn't find a way to do everything remotely. It required being physically present for some things, so that's why I am asking about whether Estonia actually delivers IRL on the e part of e-residence.
More comments...