Top
Best
New

Posted by verditelabs 6 hours ago

An entire Herculaneum scroll has been read for the first time(scrollprize.org)
Preprint: https://scrollprize.org/pdf/main.pdf

https://github.com/ScrollPrize/villa

572 points | 139 commentspage 3
suddenlybananas 4 hours ago|
Scrolls from Herculaneum have been read for a very long time. Not disputing the achievement of digitally unrolling one, but the scrolls from the library of have been studied since the 18th century.
verditelabs 4 hours ago||
I think it's a case of HN once again butchering the title. I submitted it as the exact title from our page on scrollprize.org, "An _Entire_ Herculaneum Scroll Has Been Read For The First Time", which is IIRC true.
dang 2 hours ago||
Ok, I've restored the entire title above. Sorry about that!

(Btw, you can use the 'edit' link to fix things like this if the software gets a title change wrong.)

legitster 2 hours ago|||
*Some scrolls.

They are in a variety of conditions - some of them people were able to "break" open and read. But the vast majority of what remains is too delicate and brittle to risk.

tokai 4 hours ago||
Sure, but its the potential scale that is important. There are also more scrolls still in the ground, which would make sense to dig out if they could be read.
suddenlybananas 4 hours ago||
Of course! But the title is misleading and gives people the impression that we don't already know the library is just full of Epicurean texts.
IAmBroom 4 hours ago||
It's also technically incorrect. The texts have been read; this particular text was read for the first time in the modern era.
charcircuit 3 hours ago||
I thought we were able to read some of these scrolls years ago?
shevy-java 3 hours ago||
Kind of cool. The eruption sort of "froze" some information in time, for later generations to learn from people living ~2000 years in the past.
tokai 4 hours ago||
I'm really hoping that the library contains some lost older Greek works. But its going to be awesome what ever we find.
helterskelter 4 hours ago|
I'm hoping for a complete(ish) Heraclitus. Also Eratosthenes, whose methods have been described but we don't have the original work where we calculated the circumference of the Earth. Also Hipparchus and Thales.
annodomini2019 3 hours ago|||
My pick would easily be the missing books of ab urbe condita by Livy, so much early Roman history that would be wonderfully filled out for us
helterskelter 3 hours ago|||
Also, Aristarchus.
josefritzishere 4 hours ago||
This is huge, we're about to learn so much about ancient texts.
yuvrajsa 3 hours ago||
[flagged]
jwitchel 2 hours ago|
"I'm gonna have to science the shit out of this."

Fantastic work!

VoodooJuJu 2 hours ago|
[dead]