Top
Best
New

Posted by citelao 4 hours ago

Car touchscreens are cheap, not good(ben.stolovitz.com)
81 points | 111 commentspage 3
t1234s 2 hours ago|
I think its easier to develop muscle memory to certain buttons. For instance I had a similar 1DIN head unit to the one pictured in the article. I never needed to look at it to operate it.
scottyah 2 hours ago|
On my last button car, I could control volume and turning on/off the radio without looking, but that was it. With the touchscreen, I do have to glance away but am way faster to get back looking at the road. Most things I just don't need to fiddle with anymore, before I'd need to redirect 3 fans, change a dial to put AC mode on/off, another two sliders to make driver and passenger the same (desired) temp (more or less- would have to change later), etc. Now I just adjust one smart "auto mode" a couple degree depending on what I feel like, then can get more granular in controls if I want in two taps.

With voice control I never have to take my eyes off the road at all.

dayyan 3 hours ago||
Just ask the car, unfortunately, asking rarely works unless you're in a Tesla.
bijowo1676 4 hours ago||
Voice interface is the future, just have voice assistant do everything without relying on knobs nor touch screen

same way people just talk to claude code via whisper

drakythe 3 hours ago||
Lordy I hope not. Cannot imagine having to childproof my car's entertainment system, or make sure I don't sing a trigger word, or try to turn on the defroster to dehumidify the windshield during an intense rain storm where I can barely hear myself think.

Also: I don't want a microphone in my car at all times. Thank you.

_flux 3 hours ago||
It could use array microphone to detect that the sound originates from the driver's seat (in addition to using it for filtering out not-from-driver's-seat sounds).
recursive 3 hours ago||
I mean that's cool, if it actually works reliably. Automation tech enthusiasts are willing to be impressed by 99% reliability. To get buy-in from regular people, it needs to just work better. To be clear, I don't know how reliable this actually is now, but I'd be willing to bet that it's not reliable enough.
scottyah 2 hours ago||
Then it seems like we should work on making it better instead of just trashing the idea?
recursive 2 hours ago||
Both could be possible. It belongs in an R&D lab unless and until it's good enough. If, after some time and dollar threshold, it's still not good enough there might be a case for spending those resources elsewhere.
nancyminusone 3 hours ago|||
Hell no. I'd sooner tear out my own vocal cords than accept this future.
macintux 3 hours ago|||
No. No, please, no. I won't buy a car that relies on voice for anything, and I really don't want to rent one either. Wildly inefficient, slow, unpredictable.
AnatolySkuba 2 hours ago||
Voice makes sense as a third input mode, but it seems like a poor replacement for the controls you need while stressed or time-constrained. In a car the real UX test isn't "can the system eventually understand me?", it's "can I do this eyes-free, in noise, with high confidence, in under a second?" That's why defrost, wipers, volume, and temperature feel fundamentally different from "navigate to X". Touch is fine for discoverability, voice is fine for occasional commands, but safety-critical/high-frequency actions still want dedicated hardware.
BorisMelnik 3 hours ago||
car touchescreens are in the same category of most laptop webcams/cams: just make it good enough, and make it fit (and they both suck, most of the time)
hackityhack 3 hours ago||
If we ever get flying cars, I hope they have real buttons. I imagine it's too late for land cars to ever go all the way back to buttons.
exabrial 3 hours ago||
Car touchscreens are a safety hazzard. Everyone hates them (except tesla owners), they need to largely banned
Whatarethese 3 hours ago||
Maybe people should stop buying cars with crappy touch screens then? The touchscreens in my Model 3 has been amazing. Ever since I took delivery of it in 2019. Manufactures need to do better.
jms703 3 hours ago|
I hate the way climate controls take over the whole screen, causing me to lose my map screen.